Rank and Rate 12th May Performances! - Page 4

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

Yes Sweetmusic U dont have any favourites.... but I can make out that u hate TV..... They got seven for their performance and not singing.... They got six stars for singing and that to for attempting difficult song....

U remember this was the basis for ID walkout.....

Except for this hater.... ur opinion was unbiased

Sorry Kabhiji, BTW I am a she. Hate is a strong word.I dont hate any contestant. Twinkle really is not singing up to the mark. Most of the songs she has sung now ae really not suited for her voice and some reallya re male voices nly. So I definitely dont think she is good. Onthe otherhand, Vishwas is very good. Forget about thestars they really dont meanmuch, especially Leslie's. His idea of performance is so skewed an he will not be happy evenif Shreya and SOnu sing also.

In sRGMP Twinkle was much better under thea ble guidance and mentorship of ID and good song choices. so thats my analysis. Sorry if youdiasagree

Hats off to Sharib for improvising the animalistic howling in Tera Suroor to a fantastic song. I was just amazed to see the improvisations he did on that song. He had brought a fluidity in the song. It was completely different from the original. This proves that he is not only a very good singer but also has a tremendous music knowledge. 👏

For a change, Banjo was very good today.

Originally posted by: DAISYRABLE

Hehe First time I liked that song aftr hearing from Sharib.

Same here. I was just amazed.

Sharib & Banjyotsna were very good 👏

Just watched the episode... gosh I can't believe Banjo has come a long way she was just excellent ...Sharib sang the song "Tera Suroor" exceptionally well adding his own touches and yes Apparao i fully agree with you when you say he is not only a good singer but possess sound knowledge of music as well...simply fabulous.. 👏 👏 ...just cant understand why leslieji cant appreciate them for their singing.. and is stuck on 4 or 5 EMAET rating.. 🤢

Vishwas was just amazing today .. sorry to say twinkle did not compliment him in anyway whatsoever other than to do some latkas aur jatkas.. 🤢 ...i somehow feel that both the judges are in love with this jodi.. (may be with twinkle.. 😉 )

Originally posted by: Sima Samuel

Just watched the episode... gosh I can't believe Banjo has come a long way she was just excellent ...Sharib sang the song "Tera Suroor" exceptionally well adding his own touches and yes Apparao i fully agree with you when you say he is not only a good singer but possess sound knowledge of music as well...simply fabulous.. 👏 👏 ...just cant understand why leslieji cant appreciate them for their singing.. and is stuck on 4 or 5 EMAET rating.. 🤢

Vishwas was just amazing today .. sorry to say twinkle did not compliment him in anyway whatsoever other than to do some latkas aur jatkas.. 🤢 ...i somehow feel that both the judges are in love with this jodi.. (may be with twinkle.. 😉 )

Yeh dono buddhe ka niyat kharab hai. 😡

Twinkle was pathetic today but still was highly praised by the judges. Vishwas was very good but Twinkle was 🤢

must say sharib was excellent they were the best today.i also felt sr were pretty good dunno why ggs gave em so less.in naam tera tera rajeev went a little flat but still he was good for the rest of the song.even banjo's voice cracked once on tera suroor and still got 6 stars.in short sr deserved more

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

BS were great! Leave aside LL's inexplicable chemistry rankings and they got the highest number of stars for singing

i agree 😃

Originally posted by: sweetmusic

I hope all the charitable activities really mean something to these contestants. Especially the girls, were acting all the time. If Zee really wants to do something they better contribute a part of their earnings to these noble caused..

I am so tired of LEslie's comments about dancing and using stage. I think the contestants should start rolling on the stage and running all over to satisfy.

1st round

1: BS: awesome, awesome, awesome. speechless. Sharib was excellent and good emotions. BAnjyotsna sang beautifully and it suited her voice very well. excellent best performance so far , I think they deserved 6 stars from both.
I think the judges should use their veto onthem if needed. awesome

2. Twinkle vishwas: I cannot bear to hear this song anymore since we are hearing this so much.
Vishwas was good, but was getting tired in higher pitches and ending abruptly. and one point
Rang De Basanti by Vishwas was kind off sur. But good effort. It is a difficult song. I cannot believe Twinkle chose this song. Her voice cannot even reach that high. She barely managed it.
Their voices did not match with each other contrary to what the groovy 😡 leslie said. I dont even know what he talks. But seriously does he sing also. I dont think they deserved 7 stars definitely.

3. UA: Aishwarya was very good. Ujjaini seemed like she had some problems with high pitches. How come she didnot realise when practising and picked up another song. I think she had some breath issues. It was ok. Good performance. Ujjaini sang so much out of sur the whole song, I felt bad for Ujjaini since we know she can do better

4. Rajeev/Sanchali: ok. I think they were singing in a lower pitch. RAjeev's voice sounded very gruff. very low energy. It seemed like their voices were not co ordinating. average

2nd round:WAs it HR round? I did not like any song choices, but did not have a choice but to listen.

1. SB:
I did not like the song choice. Surprise, you can actually sing this song in a regular voice too. I think Sharib sang in his original voice without the nasal twang 😉 and sounded much better than HR. I loved the fact that Sharib made the song his own. very bold attempt. Banjyotsna had some difficulties with starting her lines, But still very very very good.

2. SR: I think it was fair not great. SAnchali's voice inlow pitch did not sound good. THEre was some problem in the antara with RAjeev . For once agree with Leslie about the song not suiting their scales.

3. TV: I cannot stand Twinkle's voice. It is like she is crying or really struggling to sing. SHarib must be glad that she is not paired with him. She just changes the tune when she cant sing higher notes verysubtly, but if you are a singer you know. vishwas was good. Ithink it was fair. nothing great.

4. UA: I think they are getting nervous. Ujjaini sounded awful. They should have reduced the scale if it was hard for her, instead of yelling. It is easy to sing this song nasally at higher pitches, but hard in original voice. bad song choice and Ujjaini really sang awful. What happened toher? Did leslie really think that Ujjaini sang well? Hariji was right on mark with his comments about Ujjaini, but dontknow about HR being a great man.

Overall:
1.SB



2/3. TV/SR

4. UA

.

wonderful analysis!!! 👏

keep it up 😃

BS were the best this week!!! 👏