Looks or Singing ?

Hear Amit Sana, last years Indian Idol runner up render Woh Kisna Hai almost effortlessly..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dokgBOWJItw

I was totally blown when I saw this performance. I heard it itself I was shocked but seeing it was a totally new experience. I never thought Amit Sana could weave such a magical wonder!

Which brings me to what my topic is, quoting Farah Khan, Amit Sana isn't conventionally good looking and yet he had an X factor, applying the same to singing, I thought he sang really well.. and he was one guy who didnt experiment too much with his looks. He looked just a bit more polished when he left the show not like a totally different person unlike Abhijit. In order to please the public by looking good are contestants comprimising on more important things ?

This is Rahul Saxena's performance in SRGMP Golden Voice Hunt.. it was absolutely divine..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0vsrWF0TKaU&search=Rahul% 20%2B%20Saxena

somehow after his 'makeover' in II, he couldnt deliver the same magic.

Same happened to twinkle and ujjaini in Challenge 2005 but atleast there they concentrated on singing. People said that C05 was a farce and all it concentrated on was concoted love stories..but atleast musically it was good..

What about the shows now on TV ? so much emphasis given to looks..what are looking for Ms/Mr India or a singer ?! Does the voice of India HAVE to be good looking ?!

if they are coming on tv they should be having good looks or else they can sing on radio

Amit Sana's Kisna was a flash in the pan..I recently saw him sing "saathiya" in II2.Man!! He sucked.big time

Rahul Saxena..the best contestant from II-1.Has got a great range 👍🏼 Hasn't done playback yet

Originally posted by: arun_8687

Amit Sana's Kisna was a flash in the pan..I recently saw him sing "saathiya" in II2.Man!! He sucked.big time

Rahul Saxena..the best contestant from II-1.Has got a great range 👍🏼 Hasn't done playback yet

I beg to disagree..Sana was one of the best voices in II 1.. Rahul Saxena, him and Prajakta were good.. Sana's Rabba, Marhaba, Yaaron Dosti were really good.. his Tanhayee song in the album is super.. I mean till I heard Hemu, I thought only Sana could do justice to that song.. I personally thought Sana was better than Abhijit..

TallyHo, you need to look good but this is a singing show.. are looks THAT important ?!

Yep Madhavi,Sana was way better than Abhijeet.Abhijeet jaise singers SRGMP ke hazooron aa chuke hain 😊

But Still..Amit Sana aint in Rahul Saxena league IMO

Oh btw,Prajakta was the BEST..she is the highest class 👏 👏

😆 😆
Rahul Vaidya was okay..but copied Sonu to the core (more than Vinit)

Vinit kissi ki copy nahin karta... He has his OWN original voice..... 😳

In any case, good looks are not enough. If you sing like crap, you are not going to make it. Even if you win the contest with your looks, only your talent will dictate your future.

Rahul Saxena..the best contestant from II-1.Has got a great range 👍🏼 Hasn't done playback yet

Arun , i think Rahul Saxena has sung a song in movie Jawani Diwani.