Tadap Tadap - Page 2

First Previous

Page

Poll

Whose version was better?

Frequent Posters

Sana

@sana.abraham

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: tinad
sharib was head and shoulder above others.Not only in this song but in all songs. U cant search for a singer like sharib.But u can search others.
I remember pt.Jasraj said during this song to Ismail Darbar that -'i have heard this song many times in the movie,and heard many singers sang it,but never like this before.He is mindblowing'.

i totalllllly agree..his voice realllly touches your heart..i remember he sang..kaho na kaho..now that song i heard SOO MANY times but never liked it much..but sharibs version..blew me away...all the best to sharib...i really hope he gets some good songs to sing ..and fast...i miss hearing him.

Quote

Rishav

@aashiq2005

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: sana.abraham

i totalllllly agree..his voice realllly touches your heart..i remember he sang..kaho na kaho..now that song i heard SOO MANY times but never liked it much..but sharibs version..blew me away...all the best to sharib...i really hope he gets some good songs to sing ..and fast...i miss hearing him.

This poll is absurd, it is like comparing Apples(SHARIB) to ONIONS(AMEY), and Rotten ONIONS(Aishwarya).

SHARIB had all the elements in his rendition to pierce one's soul....his had a strange serenity and melancholy in it. Kaash kuch aur gaane uske gaye hue sun sakte....

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

shanthesh kulur

@bangboy

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 19 years ago

#13

But Aishwarya was also a very good singer may be most of us have forgottten him as he wasnt in Agnipariksha..U may not like him but surely he is not rotten onion,He has the ability to win C-2006

Quote

Swastika

@Swastika

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: bangboy

Ya I have noticed that.. In all the polls of best singer of 2005 Hemu is leading...Suppose if the same is put next yr (challenge-2006), He may get less votes than the newcomers (eventhough they may/maynot deserve it)

Bilkul Sahi Farmaya! Remember "Dus ke dus" on Sony where II1 and FG singers competed? And FG singers were the top 3 ( Rahul Saxena, Aditi, Prajekta were very popular )... ye public bhi naa😡

Quote

Swastika

@Swastika

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: anshu03
Hey you dont have Abhijeet sawant who sang this in the piano round. He was fabulous and the best i have ever heard this song. How come he is not in the list ??

Agree😊 He was just too good.
My vote goes to Sharib.

Quote

pravina

@gaggo

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: aashiq2005

This poll is absurd, it is like comparing Apples(SHARIB) to ONIONS(AMEY), and Rotten ONIONS(Aishwarya).

SHARIB had all the elements in his rendition to pierce one's soul....his had a strange serenity and melancholy in it. Kaash kuch aur gaane uske gaye hue sun sakte....

[/QUOte

I agree...wish we could hear more of him

Quote

bratati

@Bratati_0712

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#17

sharib
he sang superblyyyyyyyyyyyyy 😛

Quote

Raghav Rao

@raghav64

Navigator

Posted: 19 years ago

#18

Abhijit Sawant was the best. He sang it with just piano in the background and also added his own touch to it. Next would be Sharib...

Quote

Swastika

@Swastika

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: raghav64
Abhijit Sawant was the best. He sang it with just piano in the background and also added his own touch to it. Next would be Sharib...

True! I was in a trance... Abhijeet's "Tu Mile" and "Kar Chale" are the other two great performances.