Debojit’s win - I SAID SO... - Page 4

Originally posted by: Luckiegrl

As a member of the Dev Team, I would like to request you guys to please not point fingers. Manjot, maybe a Dev Team member but she does have a right to express her opinion, does she not?

Originally posted by: Luckiegrl

You guys can not criticize a mod for their opinion. Every person has a right to their opinion and that opinion does not reflect on how Manjot fulfills her duties as a Dev Team Member. IF is very proud to have someone like Manjot on our Dev Team and thus we do not need to be pitied. It is our honor! And Manjot has every right to express what she felt, being a dev team member does not take the right of expressing your opinion away!

Dolly

No question about that

Originally posted by: Luckiegrl

As a member of the Dev Team, I would like to request you guys to please not point fingers. Manjot, maybe a Dev Team member but she does have a right to express her opinion, does she not? She only expressed something that was a fact - yes we are all one as India but the show kept emphasizing the number of votes from each section. No one is cutting our country into pieces here but the amount of votes from every region were announced over and over again. So she just pointed that out.

Is that so??? I always thought that the role of a 'moderator' is to 'mediate' in a discussion....BUT DEFINITELY NOT TAKE ONE SIDE AND INCITE THE OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF DISCUSSION...???

Dolly, on the other hand, take my suggestion. For advocating on her behalf, please advise her to moderate her views before posting on this forum...

If you go back and read the posts, you will see that people pointed fingers at her as a Dev Team Member and not as a member. Why should she be felt unworthy of moderating? Yes we are in a discussion forum and everyone has the privelage to voice their opinion, but people pointed to her a moderator, not as a fellow member. There is no problem in telling a fellow member that you are wrong or that we disagree with you but instead what she was told was that we pity a forum that has a mod like you.

The role of a moderator is definetely to medieate discussions but at the same time, they do have a right to express their opinions and take part in discussions that they would like to. Should mods have no right to say what they feel? At the end of the day its just a discussion, Manjot did not incite the other participants. Perhaphs, some here are forgeting that yes one is a moderator but she is also a member. Manjot is not a Saregamapa Mod but she is interested in the show, so she came here and posted. Her rights are equal to that of a member's, and when she posts her she is like any other member. So please guys again its easy to point fingers, but don't forget that we mods are members in certain sections at the end of the day!

Dolly

Originally posted by: taikoo

What do you mean by 'don't point fingers?' I thought we are participating in a forum where every one has freedom of expression. If manjot has expressed her opinion as a member, then each of the other members have every right to tell her that what she said is wrong. I never thought we cannot express our opinion on a 'faulty' opinion in this forum (incidentally a 'moderator' in this case)...may be no one is cutting the country into pieces but you need to understand that in SRGMP forum what manjot pointed out is a sensitive matter....and it can create ammunition to do that....

Is that so??? I always thought that the role of a 'moderator' is to 'mediate' in a discussion....BUT DEFINITELY NOT TAKE ONE SIDE AND INCITE THE OTHER PARTICIPANTS OF DISCUSSION...???

Dolly, on the other hand, take my suggestion. For advocating on her behalf, please advise her to moderate her views before posting on this forum...

What is a stupidity to you, may not seem to someone else. Manjot quoted what she saw and expressed that she felt that maybe this is why Debojit won. Did she force anyone to agree with her? It was just her opinion. Yes she made an inference, and that was her choice. And she expressed how she felt. We are a discussion forum over here, and so we discuss our opinons and what we feel. ITs not about this is right and this is wrong, cause everyone has different opinions. As a member if you point out to a fellow member that look I disagree and you misinterpreted what you saw that's a different story. But how can some point at her as a moderator and pity the forum? I am sorry but basing what she felt about SRGMP and comparing that to her moderating skills (When she isn't even a mod in this section), is unfair. You are welcome to tell a member or even a mod that they are wrong but just because you feel and its your opinion that they are wrong, does that make them a bad moderator? Or does it make IF a forum to be pitied?

Dolly

Originally posted by: sareg

True

Quoting half the facts, is a certain way of getting bashed in this kind of discussion. The show contained a lot of stupidities(aplogoize for the words, but no other more suitable word comes to mind), If you raise an argument based upon those stupidities, you are subject to Ridicule

We Indians have time and time again demonstrated we are not capable of deciphering half the facts and it was a mistake of the show to highlight that. This result did not announce the break-up of the votes per region, that is her inference and if you infer something you better have something to back it up. Does Manjot have more information about the breakup than is common knowledge? The heat she is getting is only on one statement the East zone statement

No question about that

Originally posted by: manjot

guys just tell me one thing...how is debu india ki voice??...more than 50% of the total votes were from the east zone...so hes only east india ki voice...

anyways congrats to all the debu fans...
and vinit fans don't be upset...he has a lot of time to make his career..just be happy that he was one of the final 2...

simple. dont have to be a rocket scientist to figure that one out.😉

let's assume like some supporters are so fond of saying - no one else in india watches sgmp or cares about it, other than the east zone. so the only votes that come in is from the east. debo wins. Well, he is india's voice then, isn't he?

we have elections for President. no body bothers to vote for him from the south. is he or is he not India's President? (i understand the actual voting 4 Pres is different but this example is to underscore my point)

feel free to ask other qns... am here to help😉

its gud tht debo or else i felt tht his wife wud die if he wud loose

Originally posted by: sareg

True

Quoting half the facts, is a certain way of getting bashed in this kind of discussion. The show contained a lot of stupidities(aplogoize for the words, but no other more suitable word comes to mind), If you raise an argument based upon those stupidities, you are subject to Ridicule

We Indians have time and time again demonstrated we are not capable of deciphering half the facts and it was a mistake of the show to highlight that. This result did not announce the break-up of the votes per region, that is her inference and if you infer something you better have something to back it up. Does Manjot have more information about the breakup than is common knowledge? The heat she is getting is only on one statement the East zone statement

No question about that

no problem with this person expressing their opinion. it is however a problem when they are supposed to be "unbiased" moderators. it's like appointing a bank teller to run a bank.

or is being unbiased and qualified not part of the requirement?

Originally posted by: chatbuster

no problem with this person expressing their opinion. it is however a problem when they are supposed to be "unbiased" moderators. it's like appointing a bank teller to run a bank.

or is being unbiased and qualified not part of the requirement?

Chatbuster,

I think we need to let it go....many of us tried to explain why we found fault with one particular view, which was sensitive in this SRGMP forum....if they don't understand, there is no point in continuing with this argument...don't you agree?

Cheers...

Originally posted by: cashmoney

its gud tht debo or else i felt tht his wife wud die if he wud loose

cash,

later in your life when you get married and when you are climbing up in your life/career ladder, at that time when you are being cheered and admired by your wife, you will not come up with this comment again...

God bless you...

Originally posted by: IamVinitChacha

namaskaar bhai/bahen log..aaj ek batwa mere ko aap sab logan ko batana hai...hum bhi debo ko vote diaa thaa... hamra bhatijwa to resham bai ke chakkar mein barbaad ho gaya... kitna acha gata thaa munh se bachpan se... lekin ab naak se gaane laga ee bhi... kharbooja kharbooja ka rang le leta hai na....

yaar, kaheen toh budbak dalna thha... aur mazaa aata. um, grrrr, brrr, budbak kaheen ka. ee bhi nahi samjha budbak ke bina kya jina? 😛