why does everyone hate vinit and HR? - Page 2

Originally posted by: sareg

Dont hate HR, but dislike his tactics b'cos
HR is a mentor, mentor is supposed to bring impartial, even though his aim is to make his contestant win, but to stay within his bounds and help his mentoree win,A mentors job is not to hype his mentoree but teach them finer points of the singing.

I agree with every word over there about HR.

Vinit - I don't dislike him, his singing, or the fact that HR is his mentor. He is doing great with the talent that he has. Most of his songs have been flawless. But I still believe he is not the best "overall", simply because while other contestants have proven their versatality by singing songs of various genres, he has not. Moreover, he can really work hard on his pronounciation and voice quality. Just as an example - in "baar baar haan" song, he sur was fabulous, but his voice didn't convery the spirit of the song, and he kept pronouncing "jeet" as "jitt".

Well without a doubt Zee has unfairly hyped him. Then HR has unfairly
hyped him. Then the media has unfairly hyped him.

He is not the best singer - -Nihira was.



BTW, This topic has been done before:
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=185470&TPN=2

The fact that it is so popular says something itself.

Another topic was Why is vinit blamed more and I responded with the
following:

Vinit and his mentor have been shown to be underhanded (doctored
track, soar throat, fake Assam threats) so when something bad happens
he does not get the benefit of the doubt.


But having said that, people should vote for the best singer. Separately,
with the rules being changed, this whole thing seems set up to have Vinit
win.

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

I can write a thesis on this topic. But Vinit and that
rascal 😡 is not worth my time.

A thesis!

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

I can write a thesis on this topic. But Vinit and that rascal 😡 is not worth my time.

👏

Originally posted by: libra21

👏

👏👏

bcauz vinit and himesh never appricite other singers voice they always praise their own singers specially vinit. in my opion dejojit voice is mature and his voice suit to all the heroes and debojit voice is matured and he is good human being.
khan

Dont say such things abt VINIT. HE ROCKS........ 😉

Originally posted by: radz_2cool

Yeah even I wanted to open this same topic but I knew I would be attacked so din't say.

Many people say Vinit's voice is immature. If his voice is really very immature then why do people vote for him, why do mentors appreciate his singing ? Some times his pronounciatian can be wrong(Debojit and Hema's pronounciation was not perfect too) sooo why do people bash only Vinit. U all guys think he is doing drama. how can u proove it. it may be true he is luv. u can't guarantee na he is lying. If people doesn't like his voice then fine I don't mind but don't atleast bash Vinit like tht

Hr (The most talented Music director at present times)is always bashed for the reason he supports Vinit a lot. Even ID supports Debojit a lot but no1 makes a issue of tht . People only makes a issue of HR ji. U all even called hima monkey just because he sings in a odd position. Every people has theis singing style, u can't just hate HR ji because of tht. HR ji's every music these days r going a hit but people instead of appreciating it is just saying he is disgusting.

Yeah even I agree HR created a lot of drama but even all the other mentors did so all the mentors should be abashed together why only HR?

Hr and Vinit haters plzzz answer this. i wanna your answer.

Tell me why do u guys hate them?

Idont hate Vinit. He is sweet kid but with wrong menotr. if he was with any other mentor they would have made him better singer. Wat did HR do? He spoiled lil child (teen) with love stories just to get votes. I am Nihira fan but still think Debo sings better than Vinit but i can be wrong.

But HR...........he is worst mentor of all. his job is to groom Vinit in to better singer and wat does HR do? he makes him arrogant person with wrong attitude and stupid love story. Do u really watch Saregamapa for Vinits love story? HR puts down other good singers just to promot Vinit and.......

If Vinit loses it would be coz of HR only... Not public and not NE voters for sure

Hate is a strong word...
I have a question for Vinit fans....
Do you notice that most viewers us the word "hate" for the mentor and not Vinit? When Gatheee says "If Vinit loses, it will be because of HR" - rings a real trithful bell to it. Not because of poor Vinit's singing, but because of HR's tactics and his way of bringing out HIS own singing styles 🤢 and preferences out of Vinit - Rather than appreciate and nurture Vinit's natural talent, which he has plenty of.
Thati sthe reason i can not stand HR 😡 , but I do not "Hate" Vinit. 😳
In the 26th Jan episode , when he sang "Ab tumhare haathon mein vatan saathiyo" - He stressed on "saathinnnyyyyonnnn" just like HR. I thought he sang the song really well except for that part which was really non musical 🤢 to some ears. Viewers who get to vote may reconsider their vote if it is based onthat performance.In the same context, why was Hemu's pronunciation such a big issue then?
This is my POV. Nothing personal and I repeat I do not "Hate"