WHoevr said Hemu cant sing at High Notes - Page 4

Originally posted by: Swastika

Hema was just superb yesterday!!

But he honestly is not very good with high ranges, well that's the reason he
altered the "preeyasi" tune. But that doesn't change the fact that he was just
awesome yesterday! Nahin saamne tu is my fav.song!

Yes we all loved his Nahin Samne Tu, I will appreciate if you can elaborate on
"that's the reason he altered the preeyasi tune" His Preyasi was the highlight
of the show yesterday!!

khatri.or wateva ur name is..Hemu was the most consistent of the lot

And Ms. Swastika,He altered the taan??? Gimme a bek for Gods sake.I know that song inside out.The second time he took that taan he even made a harkat at the highest note.
ID was shell-shocked at that

Originally posted by: arun_8687

khatri.or wateva ur name is..Hemu was the most
consistent of the lot

And Ms. Swastika,He altered the taan??? Gimme a bek for Gods sake.I know
that song inside out.The second time he took that taan he even made a
harkat at the highest note.
ID was shell-shocked at that

100% true, thats why I posed the same question to Swastika!!

Sh Mite be a Vinit wonderin if he can attempt this song.
I'd advise him to not even try.He dusnt have the breath control for dat.

apparaohoare

well we hardcore fans of Hemu have a very good reason as to why we blindly believe in him. we have been very confident of his skills from the very beginning i'd say even before he was chosen for a particular gharana, i can say that for myself atleast.

yes agreed that to go far one has to face critisism and improvise on it . but at the same time one has to have proper guidance from a right person so as to receive the critisim from, with AS he was totally lost. HR on the other hand is another extreme yes he may have spoilt vinit but at the sametime his training has not done anything for Vinit either on the contrary vinit's voice has gone nasal to some point as well. As Tabu said the way you sing shows that HR has trained you, that was really funny. 😆 😆 😆

the walk out was something which surprised everyone but looking at Hemu that day one would have thgt that he was somehow was caught in it all unwillfully. to top it all he is only 17. did this hurt him i would say not because vinit was not affected in anyway having said things which proved he is very immatured. of course with all this and both AS + HR's attitute toward NE India further instigated the ppl in NE and hence we have the results today i.e. Debojit with a clear lead based on votes.

So all have their own prospective into this whole thing but bottom line Hemu made us his fans very proud and he proved to the rest who had doubts in his abilities that he has a class of his own.

Originally posted by: simranlaks_2005

apparaohoareji - I simply loved Hema's rendition of Vande Mataram and
he had a hat-trick with Ramta Jogi and Mitwa. Vande Mataram is an
extremely difficuly song to pull off!!

But Hema didn't stop with the hat-trick, his Nahin Samne left all of us
speechless!

about the walk-out what goes behind the scene we will never know and it
is wrong to judge anyone without full information (in this case we may
never know the truth). All I know is Hema seems very cultured, humble
and above all extremely talented (beyond comparison!!)

That way we can go on and on about who did right or wrong, ID's walk
out, biased scoring by mentors - for God's sake it affects someone's
career (Debo and Hema were targets for most part - somehow Vinit got
away!) and many other such incidents can be quoted.

I have never said that Hema did not sing well before yesterday's performance. Remember, I am a Hama fan. Ramta Jogi and Mitwa was fantastic. Did I ever say that these songs were bad, but these songs did not have standing high notes. Vande Mataram had high notes, I liked it but not very much. Again that's my personal opinion I felt he was stressing himself. I expected more from Hema. But yesterday's performance overshadowed everything.

About the walk out. Counting other's faults does not reduce my faults. So no matter who all did what in the sets earlier, ultimately what the audience has seen is Hemu doing a walk out. Whether he was forced by Vinit or Himani or the mentors, it really doesnot matter. When he walked out he became equally responsible for it, and that's what was not expected from him. He comes from a cultured, respectible, and musical family.

Originally posted by: simranlaks_2005

Yes we all loved his Nahin Samne Tu, I will appreciate if you can elaborate on
"that's the reason he altered the preeyasi tune" His Preyasi was the highlight
of the show yesterday!!

Ya, the harkat was done in low notes. If you hear the hariharan sog you'll know what I mean. I am his fan but not a blind one.

In the last part of the word "preeyasi" Hariharn goes higher while Hemu goes lower.

Hariharan hasnt taken the taan at a stretch.He goes lower and then higher,But he dusnt go higher than Hemu.

And I know my music well,Noone'z blind over here.
Singin in recording studio and singin live are two diff. things

Originally posted by: Swastika

Ya, the harkat was done in low notes. If you hear the hariharan sog you'll
know what I mean. I am his fan but not a blind one.

well I have heard the original hariharan many times, I completely disagree
with you. Even Subhash Ghai agreed that hema got it exact! What makes you
think we are blind fans? Please don't make statements for the sake of
making them. We are giving you our gneuine opinion on what we felt and
was asking for clarification.