archana_era thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1
Hi everyone
I went through the posts and somehow feel that its no fault of either Hemu or himani. I dont think they had done anything wrong. There walkout from the show was not against Debu but against the politics being played. Just imagine these two the strongest singers in the show never get highest votes and for sure they will be the only contestants to be eliminated in coming episodes even if they sing 200% better than Vinit and debu.
The reason is ID will quit show if his contestant will not reach finals and HR will hang himself if vinit doesnot reach final. AS and his students have become scapegoats. It was ID and HR who were against Rajeev being going to next rounds because he was not a great singer. But today when Hemu and himani are singing better and gaining popularity they have made them scapegoats just to satisfy their egos which is totally unfair.
Coming to Debu getting high votes its NOT because of ULFA threats But it is to satisfy Mr ID which actually brought ina conflict between HR and ID. Rather than Sa re ga ma pa it has become HR AND ID pa da ni sa which is a pity.
And if you think Hemu and himani were disgraceful Himani would have not silently accepted defeat nor would Hema be back in show to be out next week.
I dont understand how regional votes have not ever helped hema with the fact that people of all south indian states ie andhra pradesh , keraka, karnataka and tamil nadu are voting for him.
A simple statistic even 25% votes from each sothern state would be more when compared to 25% votes from North -east whose population is less than half compared to the entire south belt.

Created

Last reply

Replies

51

Views

3.5k

Users

29

Frequent Posters

sherley thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
very well said archana.... 👏seriously these two r made the scapegoats. i agree with u totally....
mohanpsk thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
Zee is ranked some 76 in top 100 programs ... and it will be some 200 in south ... not many watch zee andn not many vote for Hema from south
simplyskud thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: archana_era

Hi everyone
I went through the posts and somehow feel that its no fault of either Hemu or himani. I dont think they had done anything wrong. There walkout from the show was not against Debu but against the politics being played. Just imagine these two the strongest singers in the show never get highest votes and for sure they will be the only contestants to be eliminated in coming episodes even if they sing 200% better than Vinit and debu.
The reason is ID will quit show if his contestant will not reach finals and HR will hang himself if vinit doesnot reach final. AS and his students have become scapegoats. It was ID and HR who were against Rajeev being going to next rounds because he was not a great singer. But today when Hemu and himani are singing better and gaining popularity they have made them scapegoats just to satisfy their egos which is totally unfair.
Coming to Debu getting high votes its NOT because of ULFA threats But it is to satisfy Mr ID which actually brought ina conflict between HR and ID. Rather than Sa re ga ma pa it has become HR AND ID pa da ni sa which is a pity.
And if you think Hemu and himani were disgraceful Himani would have not silently accepted defeat nor would Hema be back in show to be out next week.
I dont understand how regional votes have not ever helped hema with the fact that people of all south indian states ie andhra pradesh , keraka, karnataka and tamil nadu are voting for him.
A simple statistic even 25% votes from each sothern state would be more when compared to 25% votes from North -east whose population is less than half compared to the entire south belt.

I think you better do a survey first ... leave 25% of votes for Hema from the south ... you think even 25% of south India regularly tunes in and watches the show ??

And even if they did, they would vote like the people of North-East ?? No way, get your premises right first.

The people of North-East have always been sidelined and ignored and they have taken it on them to vote for Debojit. It's commendable to have such a fan following .... so I'd say, Go Debojit ... go on and on ...

If the whole of India thinks this is unfair, they should wake up and vote for their favourite participant ... nothing's stopping them ... isn't it ?? And archana_era you can get all south indians to vote for Hema ....

Unfortunately, the rest of India knows what the North East is doing isn't wrong. You asked for public voting so accept the results whatever and however they may be ....

😉 😉 😉

archana_era thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
Zee Tv is quite popular in South belt . Apart many news channels in South like TV 9 AND eTV , newspapers have also promoted Hema. And to add to it television and media impact on people is more in south india rather in north east part . Notheast part still has not had such development. And the people in south are really crazy when it comes to encouraging talent which was the reason Sarwar ahuja from Hyderabad won the Zee cinestar ki khoj contest.
archana_era thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
Just answerhow come sarwar won and remenber one thing hema is very talented and can give other singers run for money.
coolmanasip thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
Hey archana_era,

You are saying that hema and Himani should win because they have talent though they never highest votes. Then can u explain Nihira's removal. She was a talent dynamite much much better than Himani or Hemu then why was she removed. If the reason that she got lower votes was true there then then it applies now too. If either get low votes they have to go, though I really wish Hemachandra stays on.
sareg thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
Comeon!!
Himani begged for votes for being a girl, for being from NCR etc, that was ok?
Hema begged for votes from South, heck his parents spent 2 lacs for his promotion, that was ok?
Debo begged for votes from N.E, that is not ok?
Vineet The less said is better, he has been hung out over here for weeks for this
Nihira words in Marathi were, if you like my singing, vote for me!
Ujjaini begged for Bengali votes
Rajiv begged for Himachal votes

We accepted this as a norm when the final 12 began, Live with it!
simplyskud thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: archana_era

Zee Tv is quite popular in South belt . Apart many news channels in South like TV 9 AND eTV , newspapers have also promoted Hema. And to add to it television and media impact on people is more in south india rather in north east part . Notheast part still has not had such development. And the people in south are really crazy when it comes to encouraging talent which was the reason Sarwar ahuja from Hyderabad won the Zee cinestar ki khoj contest.

Television and Media impact on people is more in South India doesn't mean anything dear !!! Just because Hema appears in a daily newspaper doesn't guarantee people getting up and voting for him. If the whole of south India as you say were voting for Hema ... his votes itself would have been over 30-40 lakhs .... but then you're ignoring the very premises that just marketing won't work ... it's clever marketing that needs to work. Look at Vinit .... even though he's the least qualified on a musical scale among the participants, HR's gimmicks about 'Topi','Love' and 'Ma' is making sure Vinit still gets the vote .... that's called clever marketing (even though it can be cheap !!) ....

As regards to Debojit, the people of North East have taken it on themselves to make Debojit the winner no matter what. If an average person in Assam earning 2000 can spend 1000 bucks on sms, it would count more than a normal/wealthy south indian reading the newspaper or hearing the news and voting for Hema once ..... and that's how it's going on ....

😉 😉 😉

And Debojit's got another reason to smile. He's got the love and blessings of so many mothers and fathers (all those elderly people of the old age home .....) Try bringing ever a smile on these elderly people ... you'll know what I mean ....

😉 😉 😉

Kumar Gaurav thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10
Its as simple as this...
1. Gajji brought about the public voting so he could cash in on his show's popularity.
2. AS and HR had planned to boot out Debo which explains the low scores he got two weeks in a row.
3. ID's comments when he walked out were "before I taken out of this show, I will walk out myself..." implying that he felt that Debo was being set up for an elimination.
4. Nobody dreamt of the tidal wave of support that Debo would get from Assam. This time...the public votes took over from both Gajji and HR's little plans.
5. Everybody has played the regional card before and nobody cried or walked out when deserving contestants like Sharib, Swananda and Nihira exited earlier than deserved while Rajeev and Paresh enjoyed a relatively longer run...so why complain now?
6. Hema would have been out had his mother not fought back to save him. I doubt AS picked him over Himani.
Right now, the only thing guaranteed is Vineet winning unless Assam mounts an unsurmountable tidal wave of support.
7. Debo still has to deal with all the threats of AS about his career after all this...so his struggle isn't going to end with this contest.
God bless that loving young couple. Good luck to them.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".