UPDATE 6th JAN 2005 - Page 7

thankz for the update.......and hope himani winz

what is this i am hearing NIHIRA's gone NO WAY 😭

Debu deserved better scores but this was not his best day -- I heard that
the 4 was preplanned.

Nihira -- Incredible! Just a difficult song. I think that the joking bad
dance video hurt her chances which is too bad since it was meant to focus
on her singing. As Shaan said, every performance is moving. I thought
that she was better than Himani today.

Vinit good but not tearworthy. He needs more breath control and more
control on the lower notes. When I think of Sonu's incredible rendition of
this song, it is hard to match.

Hema was awesome in the Hai Rama song amd I do not understand why
he did not get a perfect 10. It was such a difficult song. I felt like the
mentors have just checked out. Don't people know the difference.

Himani missed a couple of notes in the Chittiye but she did sing it with a
lot of feeling and I really enjoyed the performance. I guess it was a
difficult song but I am not sure that she deserved the perfect 10's and
sometimes I feel like this whole thing is rigged.

Also did I hear HR specifically call Hema South Bend and comment that he
does not universal appeal -- perhaps I did not understand the Hindi
clearly -- please clarify someone.

I'm getting pissed off at the judges. Vineet's getting 10's for almost no reason while Nihira & Hema who sing so superbly get stuck in 9's?

What's going on on the show?

I Just watched this episode. These are my rankings:

1. Hema: (10, 10). I know Nihira sang a more difficult song. But Hema's whole package was awesome. His voice quality is so awesome. Half the battle was won there. Perfect song for him. He gave the song such a sexy touch. He voice is manly, romantic and sexy at the same time.
2. Nihira (10, 10). Nothing new to say about her.. She is perfect. She is a class apart from all other singers in the show. I think her going out is better for her. There must be so many music directors waiting for her to ge freed up. Its better that she didn't win the challenge and unnecessarily get stuck in a contract.
3. Himani (9,9). This was again a song of her genre. She was good.
4. Debo: (8,8) He sang well. It was a difficult song. No one else in the challenge can attempt that song. I am shocked that Aadesh gave him a 4.
5. Vinit: (7,7) He was so flat and airy in all the low notes. Not a song for him. Since this song has too many low notes. The whole crying thing was because of the meaning of the song and was more situational. Kapil not even once talked about Vinit's singing. Our masses must have been confused because the whole situation was too subtle.
Over all, I think Kapil liked Nihira and Hema based on his comments.
I prefer Hema comes number 2 and Vinit/Himani/Debo win the challenge.. The enigma of being being number 2 is sometimes more glamourous than number 1. I am sure Rahman and other music directors will definitely sign him.

Originally posted by: mdroy

Debu deserved better scores but this was not his best day -- I heard that
the 4 was preplanned.

Nihira -- Incredible! Just a difficult song. I think that the joking bad
dance video hurt her chances which is too bad since it was meant to focus
on her singing. As Shaan said, every performance is moving. I thought
that she was better than Himani today.

Vinit good but not tearworthy. He needs more breath control and more
control on the lower notes. When I think of Sonu's incredible rendition of
this song, it is hard to match.

Hema was awesome in the Hai Rama song amd I do not understand why
he did not get a perfect 10. It was such a difficult song. I felt like the
mentors have just checked out. Don't people know the difference.

Himani missed a couple of notes in the Chittiye but she did sing it with a
lot of feeling and I really enjoyed the performance. I guess it was a
difficult song but I am not sure that she deserved the perfect 10's and
sometimes I feel like this whole thing is rigged.

Also did I hear HR specifically call Hema South Bend and comment that he
does not universal appeal -- perhaps I did not understand the Hindi
clearly -- please clarify someone.

I couldn't watch her sing this time and didn't either bother to watch the repeat as I was told that she had chosen one of her trademark songs. It is sad to know that she didn't turned up to be a 'sher in her own ghar'.....
Also, the feeling you could see in her singing, is not able to reach me, or for the sake of feeling what not had I done????? Believe me I can be damn stubborn at times!!! It is not a difficult song at all. Being an ardent watcher of gymnastics, I know what it demands to score a perfect 10. It is just like a draw of lots for dear himani with all the chits having 10's for us all to end up fools.😕😕

Originally posted by: soniashahzad

what is this i am hearing NIHIRA's gone NO WAY 😭

NOT POSSIBLE.. SOME ONE MIGHT BE JOKING...

Originally posted by: mano123

I Just watched this episode. These are my rankings:

1. Hema: (10, 10). I know Nihira sang a more difficult song. But Hema's whole package was awesome. His voice quality is so awesome. Half the battle was won there. Perfect song for him. He gave the song such a sexy touch. He voice is manly, romantic and sexy at the same time.

I think Kapil liked Nihira and Hema based on his comments.
I prefer Hema comes number 2 and Vinit/Himani/Debo win the challenge.. The enigma of being being number 2 is sometimes more glamourous than number 1. I am sure Rahman and other music directors will definitely sign him.

Yes boss I agree with you Hem deserved the perfect 10 I was expecting the same but I don't know where they found his fault. anyway as you rightly said that He will be definitely watched by Rahman and if once he got an opportunity he will be like SPB

Originally posted by: bveer

NOT POSSIBLE.. SOME ONE MIGHT BE JOKING...

yes yaar "Bhagwan kare ye jhooth ho"🤢🤢

As you all have said Vinit did nothing extraordinary. Nihira's song gave me goose bumps. I love the way she gets right into the song and the heck with dancing. If it is a fair system Vinit should be out. He sounds like the 'poor man's' Sonu Nigam and we already have Rahul Vaidya with a similar voice. Hema has the most powerful voice and is good in different genres. If Nihira is out, I have lost interest in the program already.