Round 3: Udit Narayan

Feel free to discuss his rating for this performance!

Note: No theme for this round. So anything goes.

Brutal.
The best way to describe this awe inspring track sung by udit narayan and preeti uttam.
The music of blockbuster movie Gadar is very highly underrated. I question now why was it?
Anyways, preeti's start is a bit shaky, and her voice strains at high notes. But that's it. The following tune after it can get you surprised. Themed as a song when lovers get seperated as a result of partition, the music is perfectly fitting for this theme. That's just the beginning. Its uttam singh at his best.
Enter udit narayan. His start is killer. The way he opens his voice to the fullest and the amount of feel injected into this track is just mesmerizing. The chorus sounds amazing too. The track progesses, and preeti takes giant strides by adding emotions, and more emotions. The clarity of voice is just top class.
The second verse takes udit's singing to an altogether new level. His voice modulation is just killer. The tone plus scale maintained is perfect, no ifs and buts there. And then listen to his word,"sajna"....in one breath, he goes from low to high to higher to highest and again the scale changes. the openness and emotional feel reeks of quality. Trademark udit at his best.
Verse 3. Preeti's turn. She gets better, and better. And then listen to her word,"sanjaaa". One breath, full test of vocal chord, 10 seconds without a hitch. She gets better and her rustic tone sets her apart.
Th end is fitting too, it gets lower, lower and feel gets added to it. Bindaas. And udit's bucketloads of feel adds a immaculate touch to it.

If duet was to be rated, it would have got a 8.5 because of preeti's voice quality. But the overall impact that this track makes is worthy of an applause and udit's efforts put into it cannot be ignored. Perfect, picture perfect.

Just get a feel of it and the best way-listen to this track in a surround sound at a high volume. Tune it higher. Goosebumps guaranteed.

10/10.👏

giving this song a 10 means comparing it with the likes of roja and dhan dhan dharti...which is totally unjustified...
apart from one alaap there is nothing in the singing...

6/10

Hmm.. haven't heard this song before..

Coming to the singing part of Udit ji, though its a limited portion, but the high notes are pleasantly sung, likeable.. Quite serious expressions are to be portrayed here, which Udit ji does well, though I don't know why I was not able to connect with them.. Nothing impressionable, unfortunately.. Overall, a good effort..

My score would be a 7 out of 10..

Final Rating: 9/10

sorry kinda busy to give detailed ratings.

Wow, I did not expect this from a singer like Udit ji! He could've done much, much better than this. His singing was average compared to what he could've done, and the feeling was not even present. Nothing special in this rendition by him, except that he clearly overshadowed the female singer.

Good singing by Udit Narayan!


There were many great parts sung by Udit Narayan. I really liked his high pitch in the middle of the song. That was very well done. Otherwise, the singing was good, but nothing great. I don't think he had the right feel in his singing either.


Rating: 8/10

Probably heard this song back in the day when it first came out. However, recently it has become more special.