SRGMP 8th October-DISCUSSION & WRITTEN UPDATE

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

malaysiangirl

@Malaysian_Girl

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#41

I like Nakul voice quality and looking forward fo his next performance.

Fareed was awesome as always on second half of the song and whatever commented by shekhar on first half of his singing was right.

Lets hope for the best and am sure all of the singers will try to give their best for tomorrow and god bless all of them and best of luck to top11.

God bless.

with best wishes,

Malaysiangirl

Edited by Malaysian_Girl - 14 years ago

Quote

malaysiangirl

@Malaysian_Girl

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#42

I have completed my short written update and good nite all.

God bless.

with best wishes,

Malaysiangirl

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Anamika21

@Anamika21

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: rajucole
and that too from the same country.it seems that there is shortage of constestants in the world,

Sahi baat hai Canada se bhi kisi ko le sakte the.

😊

Quote

rajucole

@rajucole

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#44

😃

Originally posted by: Anamika21

Sahi baat hai Canada se bhi kisi ko le sakte the.

😊

we have cutiepie rani and others.

Edited by rajucole - 14 years ago

Quote

Indradhanush

@Indradhanush

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#45

Note; Aim of this thread of is to discuss the show of the past evening, pls do not digress to the point the thread loses value.

Indo-Pak discussion will not be allowed, we will trash the irrelevant posts on this thread

SRGM Dev Team

Edited by Indradhanush - 14 years ago

Quote

Indradhanush

@Indradhanush

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#46

Is quality of singing so bad these days or they are not doing auditions in a correct way, I feel selection me bhi pasia chal raha hai kya? Ek do thik thak singer le lo baki .....

Quote

433796

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#47

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Note; Aim of this thread of is to discuss the show of the past evening, pls do not digress to the point the thread loses value.

Indo-Pak discussion will not be allowed, we will trash the irrelevant posts on this thread

SRGM Dev Team

Good job.👏

Quote

Debayon Dutta

@debayon

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#48

Rani was completely crap. She did not sounded right and her voice did not strike the right notes at all. She was so concerned with her 'performance' taht she forgot the defintion of singing.

I was disapponted with Angshuman. He was one of my favorites during the auditions, the purity in his voice was awesome. But today, he too got too involved with external factors, like performance and was completely off-key. And what was up with him mispronouncing Kurbaan?

Pawani: She was pretty good, IDK why judges objected to her singing. I liked her voice and singing. Of course, she did miss a few notes, but I guess it was because of nervousness. She was certainly better than the previous 2 contestants, so I thoguht she deserved a spot. Oh well. Whatever maybe the case, she did not deserve as harsh a judgement as what Wajid gave her.

Fareed Hassan was just marvelous, just from his voice and a few lines of his singing you notice that he has a strong classical base and he is hugely accomplished in that field. Just wanted to mention that I have a notion that he won't be versatile, which is what the judges, especially V-S are looking for, But I am not sure, let's see what happens..

Parul Mishra- Her voice quality is very good, her texture is a bit coarse and needs polishing upon. That's all I can say for her.

Nakul: Nothing special with him, he just sung a song that was comfortable for his voice and range, but yes, I did like how he did not try to sing it like the original singer and had his own version of singing. Anyways, I don't mind him beng selected, all the best to him!

Ali Sher- Another singer who I think would be non-versatile. But I loved his Sufi singing👏👏The variations etc were done so wonderfully.

Oindrilla- I loved her singing. Dunno why the judges eliminated her. Her voice did not sound raw to me, even Ali Sher had gone flat for a beat, whereas I don't think she did. I was surprised when her name wasn't announced.

Quote

Indradhanush

@Indradhanush

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#49

[quote=debayon]Fareed Hassan was just marvelous, just from his voice and a few lines of his singing you notice that he has a strong classical base and he is hugely accomplished in that field. Just wanted to mention that I have a notion that he won't be versatile, which is what the judges, especially V-S are looking for[/quote]

VS will go after him just like they are after some other strong contestants . With Sajid busy in flirting, DM literally non existent, V-S enjoy good clout and will use it to the best to demoralise him.

Get ready for comments like you need to know Fareed what a raaga is & how to demonstrate its chalan on stage from ShekharHe obviously becomes very uncomfortable with strong classical based singers, he himself couldn't qualify for even semis in his days

Quote

rajucole

@rajucole

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#50

Originally posted by: debayon
Rani was completely crap. She did not sounded right and her voice did not strike the right notes at all. She was so concerned with her 'performance' taht she forgot the defintion of singing.

I was disapponted with Angshuman. He was one of my favorites during the auditions, the purity in his voice was awesome. But today, he too got too involved with external factors, like performance and was completely off-key. And what was up with him mispronouncing Kurbaan?

Pawani: She was pretty good, IDK why judges objected to her singing. I liked her voice and singing. Of course, she did miss a few notes, but I guess it was because of nervousness. She was certainly better than the previous 2 contestants, so I thoguht she deserved a spot. Oh well. Whatever maybe the case, she did not deserve as harsh a judgement as what Wajid gave her.

Fareed Hassan was just marvelous, just from his voice and a few lines of his singing you notice that he has a strong classical base and he is hugely accomplished in that field. Just wanted to mention that I have a notion that he won't be versatile, which is what the judges, especially V-S are looking for, But I am not sure, let's see what happens..

Parul Mishra- Her voice quality is very good, her texture is a bit coarse and needs polishing upon. That's all I can say for her.

Nakul: Nothing special with him, he just sung a song that was comfortable for his voice and range, but yes, I did like how he did not try to sing it like the original singer and had his own version of singing. Anyways, I don't mind him beng selected, all the best to him!

Ali Sher- Another singer who I think would be non-versatile. But I loved his Sufi singing👏👏The variations etc were done so wonderfully.

Oindrilla- I loved her singing. Dunno why the judges eliminated her. Her voice did not sound raw to me, even Ali Sher had gone flat for a beat, whereas I don't think she did. I was surprised when her name wasn't announced.