Thoughts on HR and next round elimination

HR's conduct on the show has really changed since the Brahmastra round !!! He used to be more on the quiet side, polite, not raising his voice or fighting with the judges, etc. I actually felt sorry for him as he lost his candidates, one by one, and was only left with Vineet in the finals.

However, things have been very different since Brahmastra round… In the first place, I never understood why HR did not call Vishwas back. He was very popular and deserving!!! At first I thought it was because HR wanted to give a chance to people who were in his gharana. (I didn't know the Brahmastra winners would go to HR's gharana). I knew HR wanted to give Aishwarya a 2^nd chance, but why not Vishwas ??? Every poll here indicates how much people loved Vishwas…

My feeling is that HR didn't want more competition for Vineet…

The sad thing is that people are acting as if HR some how has "control" over who stays/wins… or can pull strings… The fact that Ujjaini and Paresh are surviving so long because they switched gharanas… Paresh, especially has never even got ONE yellow card !!!

My point in all this… that I always thought shows like Fame Gurukul were scripted, and that QAZI was a "SONY made STAR"… I thought Saregamapa was different… I didn't think that people like Mr. G. Singh would be "planning a good time for Hema's exit…" That's one of the saddest, (though maybe honest) statements I read here…

If Hemachandra is eliminated in the next round… or before Rajeev and Paresh, I will be VERY VERY SAD… (on the other hand, what could be worse than Sharib's exit ????? ) 😭 😭

Please, don't get me wrong… I love Vineet, and I'll be VERY HAPPY if he wins… 👏 But I wish all other candidates like Sharib, Hema, and Debojit had been equally supported !!!!! It looks like ZEE is only interested in making Vineet and Nihira (or Himani) the next big discoveries !!!!!!!!!!

PS… No offence to HR fans, these are just my thoughts… please, no lashing out !! 😊

Originally posted by: shesthebest

HR's conduct on the show has really changed since the Brahmastra round !!! He used to be more on the quiet side, polite, not raising his voice or fighting with the judges, etc. I actually felt sorry for him as he lost his candidates, one by one, and was only left with Vineet in the finals.

However, things have been very different since Brahmastra round… In the first place, I never understood why HR did not call Vishwas back. He was very popular and deserving!!! At first I thought it was because HR wanted to give a chance to people who were in his gharana. (I didn't know the Brahmastra winners would go to HR's gharana). I knew HR wanted to give Aishwarya a 2^nd chance, but why not Vishwas ??? Every poll here indicates how much people loved Vishwas…

My feeling is that HR didn't want more competition for Vineet…

The sad thing is that people are acting as if HR some how has "control" over who stays/wins… or can pull strings… The fact that Ujjaini and Paresh are surviving so long because they switched gharanas… Paresh, especially has never even got ONE yellow card !!!

My point in all this… that I always thought shows like Fame Gurukul were scripted, and that QAZI was a "SONY made STAR"… I thought Saregamapa was different… I didn't think that people like Mr. G. Singh would be "planning a good time for Hema's exit…" That's one of the saddest, (though maybe honest) statements I read here…

If Hemachandra is eliminated in the next round… or before Rajeev and Paresh, I will be VERY VERY SAD… (on the other hand, what could be worse than Sharib's exit ????? ) 😭 😭

Please, don't get me wrong… I love Vineet, and I'll be VERY HAPPY if he wins… 👏 But I wish all other candidates like Sharib, Hema, and Debojit had been equally supported !!!!! It looks like ZEE is only interested in making Vineet and Nihira (or Himani) the next big discoveries !!!!!!!!!!

PS… No offence to HR fans, these are just my thoughts… please, no lashing out !! 😊

comapring vinit with qazi??? great job!!! let me tell u, qazi will be soon forgotten when the dust settles... but as for vinit, its his singing that has brought him thus far... i dont think he is that goodlooking that people will vote for him because of that... his singing has that quality that u want to hear it again and again... and srgmp or no srgmp - he will live in the hearts of people... why other mentors dont support their gharana contestants is their problem... it does not imply that since they dont do it, HR shud not do it as well...

u say zee is interested only in vinit , nihira and himani... (so u picked all the good singers...) did u notice this week except for these and deb, there were clippings shown on participants.... how paresh's family is supporting him, how ujjaini's school teachers are shown, how twinkle's mom is distributing sweets, and how hem's mom is breaking "naariyals"... where was the footage for vinit/nihira/himani (did i miss it...)....

HR is deliberate in his attempt to a less marking binge for all the other contestants outside his gharana 👎🏼.Like in the previous round he rated Debojit a six which was totally uncalled for 😡....he was way out of line.

Originally posted by: nonny

HR is deliberate in his attempt to a less marking binge to all other contestants outside his gharana 👎🏼.Like in the previous round he rated Debojit a six which was totally uncalled for 😡....he was way out of line.

i hope u also noticed that this week he gave deb 10 while ID gave deb 9...

am yet to see that actually since it will be aired here only this coming tuesday.

Originally posted by: nonny

am yet to see that actually since it will be aired here only this coming tuesday.

good... ur complaint will soon be rectified...

Originally posted by: scs07

good... ur complaint will soon be rectified...

😆 nah! not really.....he does it all the time.

To sc07:

comapring vinit with qazi??? great job!!! let me tell u, qazi will be soon forgotten when the dust settles... but as for vinit, its his singing that has brought him thus far...

If you thought my post was about comparing Vineet with Qazi… or even remotely doing that… then I'm sorry to say, you missed my whole point !!!!!!!!

The remark I made was about shows being scripted !!!!!!!!!

I guess you missed my stmt that… "I love Vineet, and I'll be VERY HAPPY if he wins…"
Vineet is a very good, singer, and very consistent… But he does NOT need extra support from HR or ZEE to make it… and THAT was my point…

u say zee is interested only in vinit , nihira and himani... (so u picked all the good singers...)

I actually meant to say that Zee is only interested in making "Vineet and Nihira" (not even Himani) their next BIG discoveries… along the lines of Shreya Ghosal and Kunal Ganjewala… And I didn't pick all the good singers… I consider Himani, Debojit and Hemachandra equally deserving… not to forget Sharib and Swananda.

About the footage about other candidates you mentioned… In the first place I haven't seen the 4th round because I don't live in India… and even so, I still stand by my original opinion… and that's all it is… my opinion about the administration of the show.

Originally posted by: shesthebest

I actually meant to say that Zee is only interested in making "Vineet and Nihira" (not even Himani) their next BIG discoveries… along the lines of Shreya Ghosal and Kunal Ganjewala… And I didn't pick all the good singers… I consider Himani, Debojit and Hemachandra equally deserving… not to forget Sharib and Swananda.

my point is that by saying that zee is interested in making vinit/nihira their discovery, u r taking credit away from these two contestants which they well deserve...

Originally posted by: scs07

my point is that by saying that zee is interested in making vinit/nihira their discovery, u r taking credit away from these two contestants which they well deserve...

That's EXACTLY what I'm NOT trying to say !!!!!!!

The SAD thing is that Vineet and Nihira ARE very deserving !!!!!!! And they could easily win fair and square.... They don't need any special support from anyone...

Can you image what the final 6 competititon would have been like if it came down to Vineet, Sharib, Hema (or Debojit), Nihira, Himani and Swananda ?? Then it would have been a REAL competition and a real victory for the FINAL winner...