Why Ismail Darbar? Is Zee That Desperate? - Page 4

The judge I really liked is Sherya Goshal. She was a judge on Chote Ustaad and she was very knowledgeable good.

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

I saw thru ID and his true colors during C-05 which lot of people saw later on during C-07 or VOI...🤢😳

Man I thank Mother Nature that Nihira's mom attended every show and inadvertantly protected her little girl from her guruji.

Originally posted by: April2007

The judge I really liked is Sherya Goshal. She was a judge on Chote Ustaad and she was very knowledgeable good.

A good human being too 👏 👏

Originally posted by: musicmuse

A good human being too 👏 👏

[quote]Originally posted by tulipbaby53

i don't mind ismail darbar being there as long as he doesn't start any controversies. he knows a great deal about music and has the knowledge and ear to be a good judge

^ Does he really? Hmmmn that is news to me.[/quote]

And what makes you doubt his musical credentials?

If being out of job is a contraindication for being invited then what about Khayyam, R Jain and other stalwarts whom we want on the stage?

Don't mix his personal & professional life.

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

[quote]Originally posted by tulipbaby53

i don't mind ismail darbar being there as long as he doesn't start any controversies. he knows a great deal about music and has the knowledge and ear to be a good judge

^ Does he really? Hmmmn that is news to me.[/quote]

And what makes you doubt his musical credentials?

If being out of job is a contraindication for being invited then what about Khayyam, R Jain and other stalwarts whom we want on the stage?

Don't mix his personal & professional life.

[quote]orry Indrashanushji, could you please compare apples with apples and oranges with oranges! Furthere more could you stick to the same brand when comparing apples to apples or oranges to oranges? Khayyamji and Ravindra Jain sahab have successfully composed music individually for many more movies than Ismail Darbar has till now or and I contend, ever will! The reality these days is very very different from my younger days. Both music composers and singers are a dime a dozen today and only the fit survive. So I believe your comments are unjustified, premature and shot from the hip rather than reason or brain. No offence but just reality check.[/quote]

@BBT; my comment was regarding inviting job less composers and not about their class or prowess. Hope it is clear now.

And be happy; if bashing Ismail & me gives you immense satisfaction go on.

And do write to Zee that their decision is wrong and ID should be black listed.

Originally posted by: bunbutt_too

Is this news true?

If yes, it is beyond my comprehension. This music composer has done very little to nil after Devdas. If his music was a hit in that movie it had a lot to do with Sanjay Leela Bansali. In fact during the making of that movie they had even quit communicating since Sanjay made Ismail recompose a lot of the tunes, and that became a big bone of contention between the two. Sanjay has not used Ismail in any of his movies since then, and Ismail's career has gone nowhere ever since. Why is Zee inviting this "has been" to their show and giving him the status of a revered guest?

Bigg Boss has supposedly breathed new life in quite a few careers. However even that show could not salvage or resurrect this "has been" composer's career. He was on no producer's radar before or after Bigg Boss. Could it be that Zee is desperate for guests and at this stage will allow any warm body to heat the chairs? If true, that is a very sad state of affairs, since Saregama is one of the few shows on reality television that has had an illustrious history and class in the past. Why are the current producers dragging down the standard of this show and flushing it down the drain by inviting such mediocrity? Beyond my comprehension and very disturbing.

Tumhari kyun sulag rahi hai agar Zee ne usse bulaya aor izzat dia? One can not force other to respect him. Zee and other might have seen something in him. Keep your bakwaas point to yourself. If ID could not give good music without SLB then SLB also could not bring the Jaadoo without ID. Both sufferred, SLB had earned lot of money from HDDC and Devdas, so he is still in good shape economically, ID could not earn lot as music composer that is why people are taunting him for his economical condition. ID does not need respect from such a jealous/desparate person, he has respect in hearts of millions and Zee. You should remember that ID accused Zee for fraud but Zee still give him the respect. You know Zee could bring any chief guest but still Zee calling him, not for one but two episodes. Zee is much much bigger than you and they are giving respect then why should ID care for you.

Originally posted by: bunbutt_too

Man I thank Mother Nature that Nihira's mom attended every show and inadvertantly protected her little girl from her guruji.

What about you? The person always see other as himself.