swananda....................(ID gharana) - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

2.6k

Users

16

Frequent Posters

just4fun thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#11
Why complain about Swananda, Ujjaini keeps saying I dropped out of school/ lost on year of school. Paresh says "main bahar se aaya hoon... Who cares? Then they use their regional languages to grab vote...
kishore_bhakta thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#12
I think Swananda was always a great singer except for Monday's US episode, The sur slips can't be ignored. That is sad if she really got the red card and thus be eliminated.

I didn't like Twinkle ever since she said that she didn't want to become a singer but a performer. Only time I thought her voice was actually feminine was when she sang her song in the pre-lims (tumhe yaad karte karte) even though she added the wrong expressions, but great sur. Since then, almost all of her songs she has been doing was most performance >> singing. I felt the same way Jatin did when ID told her to focus more on singing and doesn't want to give false praises. If Swananda is really out, then Twinkle, think of this as your brahmastra... jivan dan.

Was there really a need to invite Gulshan Grover or Koena Mitra to the show? I am glad that the legends like Lataji, Ashaji, Mukeshji, Rafisaab, Mannada, Hemantda, etc. were all singers and stuck to it, which is why they became successful. Kishoreda was an exception. He was a jack-of-all-trades, singer, music director, actor, director, producer, lyricist, to which Lataji called him a "sampurna kalakaar."
jayantc thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#13

>> Swananda is voted out this wk.

How do you know?.

We like her singing. But she appears to be out of place (given that every one is "performing").

Edited by jayantc - 19 years ago
nonny thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#14
Swananda has a sweet voice but she is definitely not in
Nihira's league.There can be no comparison whatsoever.However, Some people are all set to sabotage Nihira by putting baseless allegations 😔.It seems like they have a personal vendetta against her.Everyone has their favs but her stealing the limelight seems to be getting under the skin of a few.An exceptionally talented singer like Nihira comes along rarely....she is unparallel & all set to rock the nation.She's a star by her own rights!She sets a certain standard in the comp which makes u crave for the best only....Kudos to Nihira....u go girl! šŸ‘.
classyhombre thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: nonny

Swananda has a sweet voice but she is definitely not in
Nihira's league.There can be no comparison whatsoever.However, Some people are all set to sabotage Nihira by putting baseless allegations 😔.It seems like they have a personal vendetta against her.Everyone has their favs but her stealing the limelight seems to be getting under the skin of a few.An exceptionally talented singer like Nihira comes along rarely....she is unparallel & all set to rock the nation.She's a star by her own rights!She sets a certain standard in the comp which makes u crave for the best only....Kudos to Nihira....u go girl! šŸ‘.

classyhombre thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#16
nonny, well said.

nihira is the best
Redroselover thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#17
I totally agree with nonny and nihira is the best and cannot be compared to all other contestants
dotraj thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#18
Nihira & Hemachandra rocks.. šŸ‘ and ofcourse debo giving tough competition for hemachandra...
*Jaya* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#19
Even I think Swananda sounded better when she sang "Jaane kya baat hai" in her earlier rounds.. After that she has never sounded great... JL keep refering to her voice as being similar to Ashaji's voice in younger days.. but I do not agree.. I don't think Swananda's voice has that Silky smoothness... I also agree that Ujjaini dissapoints me these days and somehow has not been able to perform how she had done for the Black number(maine bhi chhokar dekha hai).. Twinkle also peaked with 'daiyan yeh main kaha aa fasi'.. Nihira and Himani keep on surprising us, and I believe they are going to go a long way.. but one girl who was really improving every day was Raktima.. the way she rendered 'sawan ke jhule', 'odhani', 'yeh haseen wadiyan' and 'rang de' was just amazing.. it was so sad to see her get eliminated last time.. and i was surprised why swananda did not feature in bottom 3 last time.. she almost killed the lovely song 'chupke se'.. she wasn't good in this round too.. I think - Swananda, Rajeev and Twinkle might have come in bottom 3 this time and Swananda would have got eliminated!
gaggo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: jayc1234

Even I think Swananda sounded better when she sang "Jaane kya baat hai" in her earlier rounds.. After that she has never sounded great... JL keep refering to her voice as being similar to Ashaji's voice in younger days.. but I do not agree.. I don't think Swananda's voice has that Silky smoothness... I also agree that Ujjaini dissapoints me these days and somehow has not been able to perform how she had done for the Black number(maine bhi chhokar dekha hai).. Twinkle also peaked with 'daiyan yeh main kaha aa fasi'.. Nihira and Himani keep on surprising us, and I believe they are going to go a long way.. but one girl who was really improving every day was Raktima.. the way she rendered 'sawan ke jhule', 'odhani', 'yeh haseen wadiyan' and 'rang de' was just amazing.. it was so sad to see her get eliminated last time.. and i was surprised why swananda did not feature in bottom 3 last time.. she almost killed the lovely song 'chupke se'.. she wasn't good in this round too.. I think - Swananda, Rajeev and Twinkle might have come in bottom 3 this time and Swananda would have got eliminated!

I agree with you totally.Swananda was perfect when she sang Jane kya baat hai.Her mentors JL had commented about one of the singers that the voice had THAKAVAT.Lately Swananda was also sounding thaka hua.Raktima was improving...I had noticed her when she sang Sawan ke Jhoole pade.She was very good in Odhni number,but personally I found her voice a little Khurdari had the feel of sandpaper.I am not impressed by Ujjaini..IMHO Sanchali should have come back.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".