SRGMP-Challenge/updates/comments.. - Page 85

Originally posted by: navvie_27

what???..im in canada so i dont c this episode until next week...could cum1 plx explain the whole nihira n himani thing in the quote??...

They both came as guest singers

Originally posted by: dhoottarika

Hi guys n gals,
its sreemoyee here!! Am a gr8 fan of SAREGAMAPA! n may b d gr8est fan of Vinit!
I truly support Vinit,Himani n Hem 4 watever they hv done!! Can U ppl tolerate dat Nihira n Himani got out bcoz of dat singer Debojit!! Does he sing better dan them!! I feel itz ridiculous!! 😆

Why u think Nihira n Hemani got out coz of Debo? This is narrow thinking. Did u ever think that may be they went coz of Hema or Vinit? Vinit is the one who might be sharing votes of North with hemani. Yes i do agree that both Himani n Nihira should be in final 3. Lets make it final btwn Hema, Nihira and Himani since Vinit is no match with them 3. pls just sto bashing Debo for getting more votes. Its public who gave him votes

Originally posted by: sanbel

Gathee, this cry is because the "Regionalized Biased Voting" has stretched so much, that we are loosing talented people. Debo is good singer but I don't think he even deserved in top 10. That's my opinion I may be wrong. I think the lady meant being "This is India's Voce because" the other person said this is "Assam's Voice". She meant that the show is of whole India not only of Assam. Off course there can be many interpretations and she only knows what she said and we people can SPIN her statement as we want. But again this is not the point we want to concentrate.

If we don't voice (crying as you termed it) the system will not improve. Through this discussions we know what other people think, we get an idea. I have not heard/read single person here that Nihira was bad. I also think Himani is better then Debo. Vinit, he sings well. But I don't like HR's sentimental begging.
I am not against of Debo or anybody, I just like to see talented people getting success. If talented people are not selected and other people get selected based on Regionalism and Emotional basis, it will not put a good precedent. What will happen is in the next challenge the contestants will use those biased things to win. Thus they will not concentrate on talent or talented people would not participate, as they know they can't win. So look how the system is going to form. That's why we have to raise the voice. It's better to be Late then never Right?
I am not saying you are stupid, I will never say like that, I can understand what you are saying.

And I agree with you about Hema too. I think its completely wrong. Nihira ,Hemani & Sharib should have been in the finals. And you are right about Paresh too. I liked him, I appreciate what tremendous efforts he has taken. We want these kind of people Geetha.

I don't like this "Reservation" system at all. In professional life everything should based on Talent , Honesty and hard work.Sentiments or Emotional factors should not be considered.

First of all let me thank u for ur understanding.. now to ur point abt we must voice our opinion i agree.. Only thing i fail to understand is why R WE TALKING RIGIONLISM NOW? Why were we all quiet when Sharib, Swananda, Paresh or NIHIRA left. Why we din say anything when vinit was first or when Hemu got 40% votes from south.

I say again ( even i am not music expert) that final 4 should have been Hemu, Nihira, Himani and Sharib.

thanks again

Originally posted by: sanbel

This is all FUZZY LOGIC. Let me Explain WHY:

Shan said they received around 70 laks votes. Lets imagine for sake all contestants got same votes 17.5. As Debojit was winner lets imagine Debo got only one extra vote then the second. 80% of 17.5 lakhs is around 14 lakhs and 20% is 4 lakshs.

So now YOU WANT TO BELEIVE US THAT 20% of 17.5 is greater then 50%. of 17.5 lakhs. And also 2.2% of 17.5 lakhs is 38,500 THIRTY FIVE THOUSAND ONLY. And you say it's greater then 10% of 17.5 lakhs which is 1.75 lakhs.

My Friend this was one case. Also now you must be thinking Debojit must have got 40 lakhs . Lets consider even that case though we know it's not true.(but just for your FUZZY LOGIC I want to take it):

so Debo got 32 lakhs from NE (80%).

2.2 % of 40 lakh is 88 thousand.

Now lets say Viniti got 10 lakhs(which again is highly impossible condition and considering he came 2nd)

10% of 10 lakhs is 1 lakhs. So 88 thousand is greater greater then 1 lakhs

THIS PROVES YOU ARE TOTALLY BIASED. GROW UP DUDE.

Again I am not taking Vinit's side , I also don't like him. BUT I think purely on talent and SkILL basis Debo shouldn't be even in Top 10.

I am AGIANST this REGIONAL BIASED VOTING and "MAAA KA SAPNAAA", "MERAAA PYAARRR" kind of emotional voting.

lol San..u and ur math. ok correct me if i am wrong here. 80 % of votes (total) were from NE. So his rest of 20% from rest of India which was more than 33% the votes vinit got. and may be much more than half of wat Hemu and Himani got. Can we end this maths pls?

those who believe that debo is much better than vinit,himani and hem should go to doctor for check-up their ears.debo is a nice guy and hard worker but this is compitation, i wish success for him but not here. go vinit go

Originally posted by: gatheee

lol San..u and ur math. ok correct me if i am wrong here. 80 % of votes (total) were from NE. So his rest of 20% from rest of India which was more than 33% the votes vinit got. and may be much more than half of wat Hemu and Himani got. Can we end this maths pls?

Ohh My God Gatheee You are Unbelievable.

That's not correct. I have do it again for you, Ok NP ( You need to pay fees for this )

Total votes Came In: 70 Lakhs

Debojit got 40% of 70 Lakhs i.e 28 lakhs over all.

Out of 28 Lakhs 80% from NE i.e 22.4 lakhs from NE Alone.

That Means 20% from Other Part which is 5.6 lakhs

Vinit got 33% out 70 lakhs i.e 23.1 lakhs.

Therefore 33% of Viniti is not greater then 20% Debojit.

I just don't understand why don't you accept that there is REGIONAL BIASED VOTING FOR A PERSON WHO IS NOT THAT TALENTED.

Why RUN around BUSHES.

i'm surprised u ppl still havent got da idea abt wat public voting is all abt.

The ppl of assam are very much indians. So their votes are very much VALID to bring forth the voice of india! the topic of regionalism voting shudnt be arising at all.... cuz u cant possibly stop ppl in a certain region frm voting for their local contestant. giv a man a break!!! da whole goddamn public of india is not musically educated! Tat u HAVE to agree with me! If u keep asking for votes based on the best singer then its like assuming tat the whole indian voters consist of trained musicians! so to expect ppl to vote for the best singer is pure crap.... so now indians being the emotional creatures tat they are... u can only expect loyalty and support for the kids from their states!

debo might not be the best singer in da final 3 rite now, but he hav the votes... lucky man!

but on second thots, why bother voting and wasting money? all our votes are gonna go to waste.... cuz da winner is not gonna share his contract and apartment with us hehehehe

I saw few postings that Vinit would be out.
Could some one please explain, how that conclusion was drawn?
Thanks

Originally posted by: shikaii

i'm surprised u ppl still havent got da idea abt wat public voting is all abt.

The ppl of assam are very much indians. So their votes are very much VALID to bring forth the voice of india! the topic of regionalism voting shudnt be arising at all.... cuz u cant possibly stop ppl in a certain region frm voting for their local contestant. giv a man a break!!! da whole goddamn public of india is not musically educated! Tat u HAVE to agree with me! If u keep asking for votes based on the best singer then its like assuming tat the whole indian voters consist of trained musicians! so to expect ppl to vote for the best singer is pure crap.... so now indians being the emotional creatures tat they are... u can only expect loyalty and support for the kids from their states!

debo might not be the best singer in da final 3 rite now, but he hav the votes... lucky man!

but on second thots, why bother voting and wasting money? all our votes are gonna go to waste.... cuz da winner is not gonna share his contract and apartment with us hehehehe

That's right Shikai, he is LUCKY man and NOT TALENTED man. It doesn't require ROCKET SCIENCE to know who is singing well. Atleast Incase of Nihira and Debojit.

We will say that in coming who does well.

My question is : Why can't people rise above the territory and vote for talented people.

This question is bigger then this competition. This happens in our everyday life may be in our profession. And this attitude of "Biased Regionalism" is not good.

Originally posted by: sanbel

Ohh My God Gatheee You are Unbelievable.

That's not correct. I have do it again for you, Ok NP ( You need to pay fees for this )

Total votes Came In: 70 Lakhs

Debojit got 40% of 70 Lakhs i.e 28 lakhs over all.

Out of 28 Lakhs 80% from NE i.e 22.4 lakhs from NE Alone.

That Means 20% from Other Part which is 5.6 lakhs

Vinit got 33% out 70 lakhs i.e 23.1 lakhs.

Therefore 33% of Viniti is not greater then 20% Debojit.

I just don't understand why don't you accept that there is REGIONAL BIASED VOTING FOR A PERSON WHO IS NOT THAT TALENTED.

Why RUN around BUSHES.

OMG>>>>>>>>> san u also something... why r u on my back 😉 ? may be u r right but the way rules of games are set and on top they give results by region wat u expect?

Bring Nihira back and i will agree to watever u say 😉. since she to me was the best singer and mind u am not marathi :D.

yes may be ur math is right but let it go buddy...its too late for this now. as per rumors vinit is gone so its btwn Hema and Debo.

i am gujju living in US may i ask where u from san? lol

God Bless us both 😊