Wat do u guys think of elimination?...............

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

sudesh kumar

@qwertyesque

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

#21

i think the judges are doing a good job.. and for all who criticize shalini.. i feel she is a good singer with a veri good pitch.. why people consider her average.. she is a good singer..the eliminations are happening appropriately

Quote

chutneyx4404

@chutneyx4404

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: lats55
people posting here do not know anything about music.. sorry to say this.. how can you bash little children like the way you are .. shame on you... all of them are good singers that is the reason for their selection.. it is not that everytime they perform perfect.. there are days they don't perform so they are been eliminated.... comparing one another is not good.. poor 8 year old girl shalini is been so much criticised... if you don't like to listen to her mute the tv volume, rather than coming to the forum and bashing the small kid.. shame on you all..

judges know who is the best out there.. so let them do their job ..

You kind of have to compare them when there's an elimination. Because the whole point of elimination is picking the worst out of the batch. And she's not being bashed so much as saying that she's not as good as the kids being eliminated.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#23

Qwerty Pooh Aapka hi intezaar tha.....Kya assessment kiya hai?????

Long time no see.....

Petsy 🤗

Edited by Dabulls23 - 16 years ago

Quote

sudesh kumar

@qwertyesque

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

🤗... yeah i am back.. for a while atleast.. petsy.. how have you been.. btw the assessment is based on the fact that most boys.. look meek to me with the exception of yatarth...and he too is overrated..with strong but lifeless vioce.. my favorite and most likyly winner is shreyasi.. unless some unfortunate miracle happens....even that antara..has such a solid voice.. i think.. they are hypeing up the boys so it doesnt look unfair from the veri start.. that explains elimination of the two gals.. in first two episodes...i actually expected that.. now priyanka maliya has veri good voice but lacks confidence so like debolina she could be gone... but SRGMP it seems has some message for bikaner and her community so she will survive...

Quote

mintyblue

@mintyblue

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

#25

For the first time, my favourites Yathrth and Shreyasi are the favourites of both judges n producers so I am happy:)

But yes,eliminations should be based on talent and nothing else. i would like to see Swarit and Shalini gone soon

Quote

Lathika

@hide

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

Hey shut up, zipp your mouth ASAP. Bara sa bhompooooooooooo wala AV rakh lie to apne pandit ji maharaj music wale samajh lie kaya. sorry to say this. Real shame on you only.😡

i don't needed to answer to this, as your mentality is clearly reflected on your answer.. feeling so sorry for you..

Quote

Lathika

@hide

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#27

Originally posted by: Awww
Appreciate your concerns for Shalini. I am sure she has fans out there who love her singing, however to many ears she is a average singer.

As you said that when singers don't perform well, they get eliminated...I wonder why Yashodhan was eliminated despite giving outstanding performance that day?! Didn't u see the looks of pleasure on all three judges when Yashodhan was singing?? Than how do you explain that Yashodhan's elimination?

One can not tell me that he sang average on friday and hence saturday he got eliminated, coz that is not true! We all heard his rendition to Chand Sifarish, and it was not bad at all.

True Shalini got a Champ of the day that day, but next day she did not perform well, even the judges said the same, yet she was spared, where as Priyanka got champ of the day and the next day she got eliminated!

Why double standars there??

True, I don't know the ABC of music as the judges do, but am glad I know the classic song like Aaoge Jab tum Sajna, where Alka has never heard that song?! I don't think it's fair for any judge to sit on the chair of a judge, if he/she is has no knowledge that such songs exsists!

You must listen to what KK said about shalini... that is what even my thinking on her.. she is too good.. yes she do have few drop performances, but when she was not performing, equally others were not performing either.. along with her priyanka faced the problem too, that way both the days her performance were poor... then on Yashodhan his first day's performance in comparison with others were no good.. so is the reason for his elimination.. as i once again say all those children out there as so good.. but there are bad days for them too..

eventhough priyanka was good, she was making so many mistakes in her performances.. that is the problem which she needed to be looked into.. variation problems...

alka may not heard those number does not mean that she cannot judge the performance.. even many of the numbers sang by priyanka i never heard of, but very cleary make out the mistakes she is making...

look at the way Swarit sang the Notations for KK's singing..same way when a person sings, people who know the music know the Notations automatic and can make out the mistakes.. they don't needed to know the song at all...

it will not look good in bashing those children who is trying to give their best out there..

Edited by lats55 - 16 years ago

Quote

433796

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

#28

Originally posted by: lats55

i don't needed to answer to this, as your mentality is clearly reflected on your answer.. feeling so sorry for you..

What a rubbish, you answered my post but saying won't answer. Are you in right frame of mind? Dont attack anybody personally other be ready to be attacked. First shame is you say yourself music pandit and say Shalini's ooo aaa singing as the best thing. It shows where does your music knowledge stand.

Edited by HakkaBakka - 16 years ago

Quote

433796

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

#29

Originally posted by: lats55

You must listen to what KK said about shalini... that is what even my thinking on her.. she is too good.. yes she do have few drop performances, but when she was not performing, equally others were not performing either.. along with her priyanka faced the problem too, that way both the days her performance were poor... then on Yashodhan his first day's performance in comparison with others were no good.. so is the reason for his elimination.. as i once again say all those children out there as so good.. but there are bad days for them too..

eventhough priyanka was good, she was making so many mistakes in her performances.. that is the problem which she needed to be looked into.. variation problems...

alka may not heard those number does not mean that she cannot judge the performance.. even many of the numbers sang by priyanka i never heard of, but very cleary make out the mistakes she is making...

look at the way Swarit sang the Notations for KK's singing..same way when a person sings, people who know the music know the Notations automatic and can make out the mistakes.. they don't needed to know the song at all...

it will not look good in bashing those children who is trying to give their best out there..

By your definition of bashing, the bold part is also bashing. To me it is just opinion same as other has given their opinion about Shalini or Swarit or anybody else. But I dont know why are you taking members opinion personally and saying it bashing of any contestant and attacking the member and questioning the musical knowledge of members here.