About Challenge 2005

Page

satishbeh

@satishbeh

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

I am watching the show regularly. The judges should be consistent through out the show. Show judges look for sur, some for voice quality and others for performance. Due to inconsistency some contestants like Joyeeta, Sanchali, Abhijeet etc. have gone out of Challenge 2005.

I would like to mention about the Mentors. They should respect the judges and their judgement. In the last show in which Qayyam and Kumar Shanu was the judge, Aadesh and Lalit voiced their opinion on the result. They should know that the program is watched by many people. Moreover Aadesh and Jatin Lalit and partial to their participants and do not give good comments on the other contestants.

Quote

Frequent Posters

mani_sakshi

@mani_sakshi

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

u should say like this for all mentors..why r u saying for only jatin and adesh.himesh and ismil are aslo said like this so many times.i dont like himesh and ismil

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

@ejaz4eva

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 19 years ago

joyeeta sang the last song very nicely itz was aweomse.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Quote

Queenie

@queenie

Explorer

Posted: 19 years ago

I absolutely agree. The judges should be given some kind of framework to give marks to the contestants. We cannot blame the judges because they are using their experience in their field to judge these performes. ShivHari and Jagjit singh are stage performers whereas kumar shanu, alka yagnik , kavita krishnamoorthy are playback singers. So they stress on different aspects of the performance. At the end of the day these singers will have to work with the current music directors. Maybe they would be better judges. just a thought.

Quote

Kanta80

@Kanta80

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

I agree with Satishbeh. Aadesh and Jatin/Lalit get partial toward their own participants and it's very obvious. If their participants are not selected, then they start arguing about it which are often very rude. I like Ismail and Himesh's opinions.

Quote

About Challenge 2005

Related Topics

Explore Topics