Nov 07/08 Spoiler

Vinay Jha

@v12345

Inactive

7

Posted: 16 years ago

#21

Soumen and Pratibha cannot be eliminated or else Adesh and Shankar doesnt have anybody in their team.

Pratibha is very good singer and people already have recognised it, thats the reason she is always in top 3 or atleast between the line and never in bottom 3.

Anyways, there are many like me who are providing full support to her in terms of voting..... 😆 👏

Reply

Quote

akanna

@akanna

Rocker

28

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: v12345
Soumen and Pratibha cannot be eliminated or else Adesh and Shankar doesnt have anybody in their team.
Pratibha is very good singer and people already have recognised it, thats the reason she is always in top 3 or atleast between the line and never in bottom 3.
Anyways, there are many like me who are providing full support to her in terms of voting..... 😆 👏

I agree - me too. But I really wonder whether our vote counts for/by Zee at all?!

Both Prathibha and Soumen cannot be eliminated before the finale, as that means both judges to be out. Having Shankar on the panel is not a small thing for Zee and I dont think they will let him go before the finale. Between Pritam and Aadesh, one of them would go before the finale. I hope and wish that Soumen will remain until the finale...

Reply

Quote

kuhu.kuhu

@kuhu.kuhu

Sparkler

33

Posted: 16 years ago

#23

We really have to re-do our math....

Can anybody imagine Himmy shouting for Asma saying is baar ladkii hi jitegi???....and Vaishali and Zaheer out ?????....I just hope they don't try to retain Asma in order to keep this international theme going .....Let the best singers prevail...

I am fine with Sara gone ....somebody has to go ..I just wouldn't mind her one more week but looks like the girl I wanted to go this week is here to stay😕....

U know I am really inquisitive about the mindset of those who r voting for Asma ....of course she is bringing in votes otherwise Zee wouldn't even blink to throw her out ....but why r they voting ????..Do they really think she is better singer than Naina, Sara, Mitika et al , or she is "cute"..or she belongs to a specific region or something else ????....I am just curious ..... It will be really frustrating to watch Zaheer and Vaishali go so that Himesh has Asma in his team to scream for .........How lame that would be ....

Reply

Quote

R_khan

@R_khan

Beginner

1

Posted: 16 years ago

#24

[

Getting Asma and Tarun in for Brahmastra round literally proved as "wild" cards!! They deliberatley avoided Arshad, Sayon, Anupama and Jenice from that round to make it easier for Asma to get in. Then they showed Manisha lost to Asma!! Manisha, a very good singer who hails from Calcutta, losing to Asma - who would buy that?! They should have brought Jeffrey in that round instead of Asma, and he would have done a great job - his singing is superb, I have watched him on SRGMP 2008 USA.

Now if they are going to have a second wild card round, they better bring in Mitika, Naina, and Kaushik at least, even if they leave out Arshad, Sayon, Manisha, and all. Whoever votes for Asma can buy all her CDs and lose in her 'asynchronous' voice for the rest of their lives, but I wont take it even if they are given away for free! Anyone else on the show can do a way better job than her!!

Thanks Akanna, makes lot of sense because having Asma (don't take me wrong) in the competition is a joke because everyone voting needs to realize that this is singing comp and not whom you like as a person, because if you can't sing you can not have your album sold in the market. Asma is a good person but a good person is not going to sell CD's and make money for the promoter.

Reply

Quote

akanna

@akanna

Rocker

28

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: bruno4
U know I am really inquisitive about the mindset of those who r voting for Asma ....of course she is bringing in votes otherwise Zee wouldn't even blink to throw her out ....but why r they voting ????..Do they really think she is better singer than Naina, Sara, Mitika et al , or she is "cute"..or she belongs to a specific region or something else ????....I am just curious ..... It will be really frustrating to watch Zaheer and Vaishali go so that Himesh has Asma in his team to scream for .........How lame that would be ....

I think I posted this on another thread here. I worry the same way about the so-called voters who vote for Asma! Obviously they are only "seeing" music and not listening or hearing it!! 😡 I wonder whether the producers + Zee would be able to sell her CD for at least 5% number of her total votes per week?! Even those who vote for her would not be buying her CD at the end. She puts me off when she sings and I cannot imagine listening to her CD even by accident!!! She might be a good person, but her singing is just awful, and it leaves screeching sound in my ears!!

Reply

Quote

akanna

@akanna

Rocker

28

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: R_khan

Thanks Akanna, makes lot of sense because having Asma (don't take me wrong) in the competition is a joke because everyone voting needs to realize that this is singing comp and not whom you like as a person, because if you can't sing you can not have your album sold in the market. Asma is a good person but a good person is not going to sell CD's and make money for the promoter.

You said it! Personality is not going to make the sale as you dont "see" her in the CD but only hear her. Even if they decide to have a VCD or DVD for her instead of just audio CD, no thanks! If you look at all the great singers, many of them do not have cute faces but their voices are heavenly and that's why their music sells. The movie folks put pretty faces for them on screen, and that adds more to the masti of the song.

If Asma wins, then the producer would have to distribute the CDs as free toys for kids to play with!! Or her father would have to buy boxes of them and take to Oman for promotional distribution.

Reply

Quote

R_khan

@R_khan

Beginner

1

Posted: 16 years ago

#27

[

You said it! Personality is not going to make the sale as you dont "see" her in the CD but only hear her. Even if they decide to have a VCD or DVD for her instead of just audio CD, no thanks! If you look at all the great singers, many of them do not have cute faces but their voices are heavenly and that's why their music sells. The movie folks put pretty faces for them on screen, and that adds more to the masti of the song.

If Asma wins, then the producer would have to distribute the CDs as free toys for kids to play with!! Or her father would have to buy boxes of them and take to Oman for promotional distribution.

Lol, but 100% truth behind the statement.

Reply

Quote

Khtronkakhilari

@Khtronkakhilari

Navigator

12

Posted: 16 years ago

#28

If it is true then I am never going to watch this show again and I am also not going to start any topic, but I will keep on visiting the forum just to say hello to all my friends (you are all wonderful people). I was very upset on the elimination of Naina, Tarun, and Kaushik and Sara's elimination is the last nail in the coffin. I would have done the same if any one of Yashita, Vaishali, Prabhita, Zaheer, and Soumen - this is height of injustice. This is my way of protesting - Zee has lost atleast one viewer today.

Good luck to all the remaining contest and I hope all of you survive before Asma.

Reply

Quote

Summer3

@Summer3

Trailblazer

42

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#29

yes it is very sad. Votes are partly divided between Sara and Zaheer, I think.

Reply

Quote

Vinay Jha

@v12345

Inactive

7

Posted: 16 years ago

#30

Originally posted by: jo_jo1214
If it is true then I am never going to watch this show again and I am also not going to start any topic, but I will keep on visiting the forum just to say hello to all my friends (you are all wonderful people). I was very upset on the elimination of Naina, Tarun, and Kaushik and Sara's elimination is the last nail in the coffin. I would have done the same if any one of Yashita, Vaishali, Prabhita, Zaheer, and Soumen - this is height of injustice. This is my way of protesting - Zee has lost atleast one viewer today.

Good luck to all the remaining contest and I hope all of you survive before Asma.

I understand you are great fan of Sara, but the fact is also there can be only one winner in the end.
Sara got the platform to demonstrate her talent and she has got all the recognition to work in music industry, so dont be dishearten. Zaheer is still there and you can support him. same is true for all the singer how good or bad they are.
I do agree, Asma shouldnt be there by now, but nothing can be done.

Reply

Quote

Nov 07/08 Spoiler - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics