So where are the morals and integrity

Khtronkakhilari thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
Is there any thing like moral and integrity.

I am really questioning the morals and integrity of all these judges and the show.

I personally do not care who win this contest, whether it's Vaishai, Yashita, Sara, Pratibha, soumen or Zaheer, the reason being they are all good singers and any one can win this contest (there is no clear winner). We all have our own favourite(s) for different reasons (may be because you like certain style of music or for any other reason) at least they are all talented, but when you see that singers like Zaheer, Soumen, and Tarun are in bottom three and Asam is in between lines then you start wondering what's going on. When you see that Asma is still in the contest and singers like Shujaat, Tarun, Naina, Kaushik and others are already gone then you start questioning the integrity of the show.

I know you guys are going to come up with different reasoning(may be just because you like HR or Shankar or any other mentor and you do not want to hear any thing against them), but honestly how can you give History to an awful(Asam) singer on an awful performance (their comments have nothing to do with voting). Some of you might say it's all Zee publicity/propaganda or these mentors have signed a contract with Zee and they are all helpless, so my question is why would you sign such a contract - is it all about money?

I know I am going to take a heat from some of you, but your comments are welcome.

Edited by jo_jo1214 - 16 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

983

Users

9

Frequent Posters

Summer3 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
Mentors are freely distributing top marks to everyone and Shankarji said from next week onwards it will not be easy to get top marks from him. Voting is by the "Janta"???
I think Zee will get some Public voting figures and readjust them.
Khtronkakhilari thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Summer3

Mentors are freely distributing top marks to everyone and Shankarji said from next week onwards it will not be easy to get top marks from him. Voting is by the "Janta"???

I think Zee will get some Public voting figures and readjust them.



That's a big question mark?
200467 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
Honestly, I fail to understand their definition of History now. They have been doling it out for pretty much everyone.
I think I know my top 3 now - that is who I would like to see in top 3 - and they are Vaishali, Soumen and Pratibha.
366774 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
see if u r asking y asma got history then yes i too have a problem with this but voting is a public matter then y do we see her between the lines each week especailly wen majority is not in favour for her presence in SRGMP tht shows zee takes decision not public voting.
bruce thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

I completely agree with jo_jo. It breaks my heart to see Asma when such talented singers are no longer there and she just shows up with not even 'acceptable' talent.

musica10 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
Asma will last only for a couple more weeks. I do not even consider her as a contestant. The competition is really between the remaining who are singers. Tarun probably got the lowest votes among the rest this week.

As for the judges, their comments are rarely sincere. They should only have history and superhit as ratings, since no one ever gets anything below that.

I don't think even think the contestants take it seriously. Honestly, if they make a mistake, they know it.

I guess it is really all about the money and the publicity.




akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Gauri_3

Honestly, I fail to understand their definition of History now. They have been doling it out for pretty much everyone.

I think I know my top 3 now - that is who I would like to see in top 3 - and they are Vaishali, Soumen and Pratibha.

Me too. 😃
I look at History as just a common term used now in the show than a real "history" kind of performance - not even in the show's history that is!! For example, Mauli's Maiya Maiya, Raja's Haji Ali, etc were historical performances for the SRGMP show. In SRGMP 2009, same goes with Debo's first song, Soumen's first song, a couple of songs by Vaishali and Prathibha, Sara'a Masha Allah, a couple of songs by Mitika, and so on. Apart from a few selected ones like that, I dont think any of the others deserved to be 'history' in any way. Hopefully next week onwards, Shankarji will prove to everyone what the real definition of 'history' is...
Khtronkakhilari thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#9

Me too. 😃
I look at History as just a common term used now in the show than a real "history" kind of performance - not even in the show's history that is!! For example, Mauli's Maiya Maiya, Raja's Haji Ali, etc were historical performances for the SRGMP show. In SRGMP 2009, same goes with Debo's first song, Soumen's first song, a couple of songs by Vaishali and Prathibha, Sara'a Masha Allah, a couple of songs by Mitika, and so on. Apart from a few selected ones like that, I dont think any of the others deserved to be 'history' in any way. Hopefully next week onwards, Shankarji will prove to everyone what the real definition of 'history' is...


I totally agree with you - let's see what happen from now on.
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
Judges giving out history has barely anything to do with a contestant getting higher votes....unless votes are fixed by Zee-SRGMP.
Asma is in either because show is keeping her there over other better singers or she is popular in janta's eyes and janta is voting for her....Simple as that..
My Top 3 are Vaishali, Zaheer, Pratibha-Soumen.
I don't care what happens or who really wins. I accept these shows with their winners....

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".