Manisha Lamba:A better judge than adesh and pritam

Originally posted by: fcuk_2good

I thought Manisha lamba gave much more sensible comments than the two judges adesh and pritam.It seemed they had something personal or some pet peeve against some contestants and deliberately pulled them down. don't know why but they sounded very biased.On the other hand, lamba seemed to have a better music sense than them and she was very objective with her analysis, which is required of the judges!
I would say bring her back to replace these two 'drama queens'!

Originally posted by: BibiS

Yes, totally agree with you. Pritam and Aadesh are really getting on my nerves now... they have to be so personal and offensive with the contestants. Shankar and Himesh make much better judges.

Himesh is as good a judge as the SRGMP set. Has he ever provided any constructive input on the show. Has he ever bothered to correct the contestants on their mistakes. Sorry, but a CD player playing 'Superb...Outstanding..wateva' would do just as well as Himesh😛