Mohammad Aman-- winner??

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

If Mohd Aman keeps singing as he has and even better than I have no issue him winning the whole thing and him & not being versatile...Simply being classical singer...Its abt time someone like him be a winner...Will give out a great msg IMHO..

Originally posted by: desicrowd

If we go by today's trend then he would be expected to be versatile and even though he is a fantastic singer he woul be required to sing a non singer songs like that of Atif Aslam or Neeraj Shreedhar...but I feel it's about time we respect our culture and its rich singing base and give it to a amazingly talented classical singer... It's not as if Mohamad Aman's singing sucks... But I would like to see him rendering equally amazing performances every time...
And even if the lad doesn't win I will be thankful to him for bringing us closer to classical singing...and giving such outstanding renditions...

Originally posted by: gaayika

when the mentors are judging the contestants, they keep talking about the attitude and the stage presense etc . So they are not just lookign for good singing and voice quality . yes Mohd Aman is not dancng on the stage while singing ... but he is completely immersed in his sadhana, his body and soul are one when he sings .

Attitude is required to bring out the essense of the song for example when Parul sang Jhalla Wallah , it was so dull . The original song that Shreya sung, you can feel the masti .

In classical , there can be no attitude ...Really , it would be great to have a good singer win , rather than trying to get a most versatile singer . If the singer is classically trained, he/she can sing almost anything .. Yes I know , diction gurus will pounce on this statement of mine .. But then Sunidhi is classically trained and can sing in any genre with ease ...

Originally posted by: kiti_g

If you are as adept in classical singing as Md Aman is, then versatility is just a matter of time!!! He will learn with time, its the base that matters and when his singing base is so strong its not hard to sing film songs!

How many of you feel that Shankar Mahadevan is versatile?!!! Well he started as a classical singer and even now gives pure classical performances!!

So I am all for crowning Md Aman as the winner! He is already a winner for me!

At the same time there are some other singers like Vishwajeet and Shehnaz who are also well qualified to be winners on this show!