Performance Discussion Thread (17-18 March) - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

2.8k

Users

10

Likes

91

Frequent Posters

pjyo thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#21
Can we replace judges with the gang of kiddo judges😛-their comments were more honest and sensible than the actual judges 👍🏼 ,the 3 boys divyansh ,kian and prabhjot did perfect judges impersonation👍🏼 ,their segment was super entertaining.👏...

Zaid gave a good haji ali rendition , very heartfelt 👍🏼
Rohanpreet sang well sticking to his comfort zone.. Hemant's singing was most impressive⭐️ ,cant say the same about younger brijwasi who screams😵 more than sings..
Reinit has amazing playback quality voice but his pitching slips a lot 🤔maybe due to hearing issues..
Shashank singing wasn't good enough ,his extra dose of sob stories didn't work this time..
Sunday episode was a mishmash of everything -some music ,kids comedy ,sob stories ,movie promotions and if that wasn't enough😉 -Siindhutai running on beach🤪 that too in slow motion.🤪-felt like kids were babysitting the granny🤣...
pjyo thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: LizzieBennett


Ha..that's probably it! I didn't see all those skits so I must've missed connecting it to the theme.😛 I usually skip all the extras and go straight to the performances. Sometimes I stay to hear what the judges have to stay after a performance. And anyways, stuff that most people find cute about little kids - them donning adult get-ups and playing little adults always turns me off - I find them precocious and off-putting rather than cute, I prefer kids to stay kids! 😊

oh they weren't the cute oversweet😉 irritating types 😛..give them a watch -100 times more sensible than monali and divyansh who played shankar his comments very very well written -had stuff shankar would wanna say but avoids😛..
lissa007 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: pjyo

Can we replace judges with the gang of kiddo judges😛-their comments were more honest and sensible than the actual judges 👍🏼 ,the 3 boys divyansh ,kian and prabhjot did perfect judges impersonation👍🏼 ,their segment was super entertaining.👏...

Zaid gave a good haji ali rendition , very heartfelt 👍🏼
Rohanpreet sang well sticking to his comfort zone.. Hemant's singing was most impressive⭐️ ,cant say the same about younger brijwasi who screams😵 more than sings..
Reinit has amazing playback quality voice but his pitching slips a lot 🤔maybe due to hearing issues..
Shashank singing wasn't good enough ,his extra dose of sob stories didn't work this time..
Sunday episode was a mishmash of everything -some music ,kids comedy ,sob stories ,movie promotions and if that wasn't enough😉 -Siindhutai running on beach🤪 that too in slow motion.🤪-felt like kids were babysitting the granny🤣...


I just love your reviews. ⭐️ Was waiting for one today tbh. You are too funny. Please never stop writing them 👏
altgr thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: lissa007


I just love your reviews. ⭐️ Was waiting for one today tbh. You are too funny. Please never stop writing them 👏

Same here. I too love pjyo's comments. It'salmost one year now since I know her. She is really very funny.
altgr thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#25
Sunday episode was definitely better than Saturday's. I usually don't like the drama part but those three kids were awesome, I laughed a lot when they came for the second time. Great job.

Zaid - He sang so beautifully, loved his performance. Also enjoyed his dad singing with him.

Rohanpreet - I think when it comes to feel, he is the best among all. Yes he is singing almost same type of songs but he sings with perfect feel.

Chetan - It was a good performance, nothing special.

Raenit - I have not watched the audition episodes completely, just watched some clips on Voot. So I don't remember how he performed there but the recent two performances I didn't like. But he performed better than last time.

Shashank - OK OK performance, not much impressed.

Aafreen Group - They sound almost same everytime. Don't know why judges, specially Shankar Ji praises them so much.

Hemant - Easily the best performance of the week. He is consistently giving superb performances, deserves to be a finalist. Also with last two performances he has proved that he is versatile.

It was good to watch Shaan. Like someone mentioned, I too wanted him to sit on the expert's chair like other guests.
Edited by altgr - 7 years ago
naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: LizzieBennett

I don't know how they split the contestants between Sat and Sun, but the ones that perform on Sunday always have better luck of the draw because of the theme. It gives them more to play with and better songs to choose. That said - how did they choose these songs for the "Bachpan ke din" theme? I'm mystified! 😕

They very deliberately split Jaya and Shashank between Sat and Sun, possibly manipulating their exits, anticipating they would be the lowest scorers. What tricks these channels play! 😕
Anyway, today's episode was so much better and so were the performances! After yesterday's damp squib, I'm happy to be able to at least rate the performances today 😆

1. Hemant Brijwasi: Great song choice! And what a performance! I love this song and he made me love it even more! I agree with Shankar about the little extra harkats he added and made the song his own! Amazing! Flawless! And I eat my words about him sticking to the same genre. With today's performance, he proved he can be versatile with different genres too. 👏👏. He deserved all the tutaaris and then some!

2. Zaid Ali: This kid stole my heart. Such sincerity and such devotion in his voice! He stayed true to the composition, and added his own unique flavor to it. Superb!

3. Rohanpreet: I've always liked him, today was no exception. He did sound a bit off, possibly because of his sore throat, but I daresay I didn't notice a significant difference in his singing which is totally to his credit. I do wish he'd try a different genre, he keeps doing the same old sad, slow, romantic numbers.

4. Rainit: I liked his performance. I don't know why Shankar thought he should've left. In fact, his comment in the end to Shashank left such a bad taste. It didn't make anyone happy - not Shashank, not Rainit and definitely not me. Why did he make that comment? And he didn't vote for Rainit but voted down for Shashank! That shows clearly who he thought was inferior! Then why did he do a turnabout? 😲😡 And I saw Monali was trying to cover up for her faux pas yesterday by commending Rainit's efforts at being able to sing with hearing loss.😡 Sorry, ma'am! The damage you caused cannot be undone. She should apologize.
Anyway, Rainit's performance, though not terrific, was definitely good. I agree he has sung better in previous performances though. This song he picked was good too. Suited his voice. And he did a decent job.

5. Chetan Brijwasi: I don't mean to be harsh, but singing a high energy song doesn't mean screaming it at the top of your voice! You can bring the energy into it by other ways! I'm sorry but I thought he was just shouting and the only reason I'm putting him above Afreen group is because their performance just doesn't work for me.

6. Afreen group and Shashank: They're tied for bottom place for me. I actually thought Shashank wasn't too bad when he started out, but I'm not familiar with the song and I don't know how much justice he did to it. Afreen group sounds like chaos! I don't know why the judges praise them so much. I cannot understand their appeal at all! Tharki Chokro is a great song and they should've infused it with the fun element that the song needs. They were anything but fun! They sounded sad! I had to perk up my ears to figure out if they were indeed singing that song or something else!

All the dramedy with the little kid impersonators, Rainit's mom, Sindhu Tai etc etc- I just sacrificed with my forward button. Three cheers for it! I intend to use it a lot more for this show! 😆


one thing even if you havent heard a song or are not familiar with it. if the singer is singing it well you will like it. I have so many times heard some songs for the 1st time in these shows and i have liked their performance so much that i go back & search for the original song
naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#27
what i the so called back sob story of shashank. i dont get it why he is always so sad😕😕. i always switch channels when they show sob stories . why was he crying yesterday and is something wrong with his daughter? sorry to say afreen group too has come from a not so well to do background but they are not crying and asking for sympathy always
LizzieBennet thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: naq5


one thing even if you havent heard a song or are not familiar with it. if the singer is singing it well you will like it. I have so many times heard some songs for the 1st time in these shows and i have liked their performance so much that i go back & search for the original song


When I say i'm not familiar with the song i'm just making it clear that my like or dislike of the performance could be clouded by the fact that i haven't heard the original and so wouldn't know how well or badly the contestant has sung it. It has nothing to do with whether I like the song or not. There are many performances that have gone by that i have liked despite not liking the song they chose simply because i thought they did justice to the rendition. I'm not reviewing if the song is good or bad, i'm reviewing the contestant's rendition of it and if i don't know the song or have never heard it, how then will i know if it was well performed? Just my two cents- no offense! 😊
pjyo thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: naq5

what i the so called back sob story of shashank. i dont get it why he is always so sad😕😕. i always switch channels when they show sob stories . why was he crying yesterday and is something wrong with his daughter? sorry to say afreen group too has come from a not so well to do background but they are not crying and asking for sympathy always

He just wants to cry in all his video segments🤪 ,this time he added extra dose of tears😭 by digging up bachpan ki garibi🤔,dad ki beemari🤔,eloctrucution plus spinal chord injury😲...nothing wrong with the daughter ,even she had confused expression seeing dad cry in one episode
thank god he left varna he would have dug up many more sob stories for future 😭episodes ...He cried more than colors ki serial bahus😆 ,iske aansovon😭 mein rising star bhi doob jaatha🤪..

naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: LizzieBennett


When I say i'm not familiar with the song i'm just making it clear that my like or dislike of the performance could be clouded by the fact that i haven't heard the original and so wouldn't know how well or badly the contestant has sung it. It has nothing to do with whether I like the song or not. There are many performances that have gone by that i have liked despite not liking the song they chose simply because i thought they did justice to the rendition. I'm not reviewing if the song is good or bad, i'm reviewing the contestant's rendition of it and if i don't know the song or have never heard it, how then will i know if it was well performed? Just my two cents- no offense! 😊

no you misunderstood my comment. i was trying to say that if the contestant has sung it well, we will like the performance irrespective of weather we have herd the song before or not. we may not be able to dissect the details but we will like the song. if you havent liked it that means the contestant has not performed well😆. sometimes a good performance of the contestant also makes me go n listen to the original because i liked the performnce.
for eg. in a past kids realty show a contestant performed on 'o rangrez'. i never heard it before and i really liked the song because the contestant preformed it well. i went back n listened to the original one . i liked the shreya goshal bits but not the male bits. i still prefer to listen to the version of the song by shreyan. same happened with "tere bin' from wazir , i heard it for the first time by a contestant and when i listened to the original i liked that too.
similarly i too dint hear mamta's song before nor do i like such fast paced songs but the way she sang i knew she did it properly without going besura.
with shashank the song is a really good one. he dint sing it well. even i heard it for the 1st time on a realty show by shreyan & i liked it then. if i would have heard it from shashank for the first time i wouldnt have bothered to hear the original.

i hope i am being more clear this time😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".