What the hell happened with Kabir?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Mehek25

@Mehek25

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#41

Originally posted by .Rinnie.

Seriously, I mean from where did this whole 'I need to tell you the truth' realization come from? Why did he suddenly drop such a HUGE bomb on her outta nowhere?

Did I miss an episode or a scene inbetween or something?

Wasn't he just giving her a thumbs up and behaving so cheerfully with her? Did Ronnie's confession really hit him THAT HARD in the head? 😆

Like what just happened? 😳

Originally posted by BedouinMe

EXACTLY !!! Even I didnt get that. Out of nowhere, why did he think of dropping this bomb on Ananya ? Has it got something to do with Ananya's reporting about that boy Navdeep. "Dil ki baat bata deni chahiye, or else it can lead to disasters" Was it the fear of a disaster in their relationship that provoked Kabir to reveal the truth?

Even I was wondering how this happened so suddenly...I think its something in the editing...Some sort of thinking process of Kabir's should have been shown before this scene...

Quote

IAmNotActive

@IAmNotActive

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: Fantasia_junkie
Surely there is more to Kabir's confession, but we do not know if the truth was kept intentionally from her, because he didn't want to bombard her with too many shocks and provoke her to take things into her own hands, Or he really has no clue about what really happened to her father..
His version of the truth does seem very convincing, and it certainly didn't seem like Kabir was lying (Rajeev-itis ki kasam!). But maybe he only revealed bits that he needed her to know, for now.. Once she accepts the truth, it'll be easier for her to bear the shocks that would follow..
What could be worse than losing her father! He knows she is a syrong, intelligent girl and would eventually find a closure to her pain.. And that's exactly what he does .
But the question remains - What triggered his batti to jalofy? The only vaguely possible reason seems to be that he is just as confused as we are; and decided that as her friend, and her father's confidante - he owes her the truth..

And I think or rather, I hope Kabir hasn't given up entirely on Sudhir Kashyap's case..
Coz as much as the suicide story does make sense, powerless or not I don't think Kabir Sharma would buy that story filled with uncertainties..

He even says - tum jaanti ho main iss sach ke liye qayamat tak bhi jaa sakta hoon.. (Aaing- scratches head* yeh kab hua?) Did we really miss an episode? 🥱

@ Rinnie - Darling, this gives me LRL-RN feels.. And Im scared to even imagine what wud happen if our fears come true..
But something tells me, unlike Raj, Kabir might only be responsible for hiding the truth.. He might not be involved in her father's death, in any way!

Kabir looked absolutely genuine when he was talking to Ananya, that's what made me believe that he is telling all he knew. But your POV makes lot of sense too.

It is possible that he didn't want to bombard Ananya with everything he know at once, especially if the truth is too too bitter. But I do think he is convinced that Sudhir is really dead, otherwise he woudn't have emphasised so much about wanting Ananya to accept it. It is possible that Sudhir was murdered instead of sucide, and Kabir is aware of it. Kabir might think if he tell the whole truth to Ananya at once, she (and her family) will be robbed off their chance to grieve, instead Ananya will be filled with the vengeance to seek justice for her father's murder.

Probably Kabir wants the family to mourn in peace before moving on to the next level. I really hope Kabir is not planning to hide the complete truth (if there is more) forever in some misguided protective instinct. Ananya is a brave girl, she doesn't need molly coddling, what she needs is the support to face & accept the truth.

Not sure whether it is a blooper or something more to it, but the legal background of Sudhir's death doesn't ring true, if police did declare him dead after giving up the search operations, Ananya's family (atleast her mom) would have been informed of it and the wallet should have been handed over to her by police, and if the case is still not closed, the wallet would remain with police as an evidence. How did Kabir retain the wallet with him instead of handing over to police, that is possible only if the police was never formally involved, and Kabir did the search (of the jungle) on his own with assistance from his police friends (Khurana). And if that was the situation,, the case might be dormant, but not closed.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Rabzonedge

@rabzonedge

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 9 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: Geetha_R

I agree, probably it would have been easy for many to accept Kabir 'suddenly' dishing out the 'truth' if he was shown in some deep contemplation. I guess, I was mentally prepared for this truth scene from the moment they had shown Friday precap where Ananya was shown to be waiting for Kabir to come. It is too early for them to go on a date, hence I felt it is obvious that he is coming to drop the bombshell.

I too think Sudhir Kasyhap case is not over yet, either he is murdered or still alive, but I think Kabir is telling all he knows. Probably he wasn't a seasoned reporter at that point in time to chase behind hidden truth. .And he didn't know Sudhir that well as a person, he probably had gone by the phone recordings and accepted it to be the truth. With Ananya in the picture now, the equation would be different. She would want to dig deep and he can't deny her his supoort. I think Kabir was insisting on accepting the truth right there, because he doesn't want her or her family to suffer in dilemma anymore, he wants them to have the closure, because without accepting the truth, one cannot move on. But Ananya can't have closure until it is proven without doubt that her father is dead. And to Kabir too, this case would hold a different interest after knowing who Sudhir was / is. He too would look at the case with a diffeent perspective.

Omg ur prediction coming true 😲