RRuthless Proposition - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

64

Views

6.6k

Users

28

Likes

355

Frequent Posters

loveanime thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#11
Naps brilliant you brought out what we were all struggling with. We all were wondering why can't paro love rudra he is so yummy, a protector, loyal and a dream boat, but is he really and scary thought paro was seeing him as such. That is what it is wrong about this relationship is that paro was idealizing him, it is either one extreme or the other for her. He is either jallad or a god no way Paro will survive Rudra if that is her outlook of him. Paro as much as she knows Rudra doesn't know him at all. She will never truly love him until she sees his dark side and knows he can be that man that can set fire to her but instead of fearing the fire she needs to walk it with him. But she needs to accept that her Rudra is neither a Jallad or a god he is just a man, a desperate man, a flawed man who is capable of things her idealized rakshak won't do. She needs to get past this hero worship phase if she wants to be his wife in the true sense she needs to understand him for what he is and for that Rudra needs to fall in Paro's eyes. If he can be good he can be just as bad, not bad in the sense of Tejawat but bad enough for her white character to be shocked but willing to accept. For now Paro is overcompensating for her earlier bad behavior she thinks she has insulted her god and has commited a sin against her Bholenaath.
What Rudra today did was more than just grey behavior. He gave another man money selling her off as such. It wasn't just marry Sumer if it ended there fine but money exchanged hands and for an woman what can be a bigger insult. What Rudra did today neither Varun or Tejawat accomplished that is taint her honor. Varun could have dumped a box full of vermillion on Paro's head and she still would have her dignity intact no one would point fingers on her. Rudra whether he admits it or not and whether Paro understands it or not, Rudra and Paro belong with each other. To have your man barter you off in front of socieity/family for a fixed sum ouccchhh. Brilliant work writers because this is Rudra and we might hate Rudra for what he did today but we can't hate what was shown today because in keeping part with the story and characters it was amazing stuff. Whatever might have been Rudra's reasons it was not shocking he is capable of this.
Paro will love Rudra come what may but will she ever respect and hold him in the same regard as before. Draupadi never forgave Yudhishtr for what he did, as much as Dushaasan pulled on her saree it was her protector her husband who should have guraded her honor with his life put her in that position where her very existence was tarnished. Rudra might get back Paro but he has not realized he has staked her honor in this and Paro would have forgiven Rudra for anything but not this and Rudra will realize too late what he lost. Rudra will have to beg, Paro will forgive him ofcourse but I wonder if he will ever forgive himself because her soul would have been hurt and he would know it. Paro is as untarnished as he is tarnished. Even after Tejawat betrayal her faith in humanity was not broken because her bholenaath was there that is why she was able to bounce back as fast as she did. But the moment she started linking Rudra to Bholnaath and expecting that same unblemished faith she was done for because her faith will be broken Rudra will himself break it and what will Rudra do when he realizes the girl he cherishes is gone the happy go lucky the pure soul is no more. Rudra will be crushed when he realizes he subjected Paro to the same pain he warned her off, how ironic he told her don't believe the wrong people the loss in faith would be devastating to live with, it wasn't her faith in Tejawat but her faith in him that broke her.
Hahaaa I am just overanalyzing. Paro and Rudra will come out of this fit. Paro won't be too hurt she will give a cute little ear twist to Rudra and he will pout a little they will hug and kiss and on to the next battle.
Edited by loveanime - 11 years ago
Ipoona thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: tvbug2011

Today, the CVs allowed Rudra to umm... play...with everybody's minds in a ruthless bid to unmask the truth.

It was all a game to Paro. Of that Rudra was certain. There was no other reason why she should insist on remaining in the house even though he'd told, no, ordered her in no uncertain terms to leave. He didn't want to see so much as her shadow in the haveli.
The girl had the nerve to look him in the eye and tell him that she would not leave. And when he threatened to throw her out of the house, she had the gall to hold out her hand to him. To call his bluff.
And then she walked in to Bapusa's room with a pot bold as brass and folded back Bapusa's blanket off his feet. That's when Rudra's eyes fell on her wrist, now encircled by his rudraksha. Her explanation: that it had accidentally entangled with her rudraksha in the Mela when he'd grabbed her hand to stop her from leaving with the Thakur, to save her from certain death. And it had protected her, saved her, she said, when he could not, physically. But she wouldn't give it back to him until he forgave her.
He was on his way out, when her voice arrested him. The herbal paste she was applying on Bapusa's feet was her Mamisa's concoction with amazing curative powers - applied three times a week it could bring a man back to consciousness. And she hadn't mixed any poison in it.
That was it. No more games. He gave up. He had to know. So he sat down and asked her straight out for the answer. What was she doing? Why was she doing it? No, not her care or playing at care for Bapusa. But her stubbornness that didn't back down in the face of his requests, threats, humiliation. Her search, desire, demand for his forgiveness. Why? Why was his forgiveness so important? Why did she set so much store by it?
Her explanation didn't make sense. Should he believe that she was actually dying, breaking from inside because he wouldn't forgive her? That she wanted to convince him that she had no hand in what happened to Bapusa, he could well believe. Although even that didn't make sense. After all who was she to him, to Bapusa? But that she was in an agony of repentance that she hadn't believed him earlier that she'd given him so much trouble, was frankly beyond his understanding.
He simply couldn't comprehend why it mattered to her at all what he thought of her, whether he believed her, if he forgave her. What difference did it make? What was he to her anyway? Why long for forgiveness from the man she'd called a jallad?
She wouldn't let him call himself that. She'd been wrong to call him Jallad, she apologised. And it mattered to her...all of it. He was her protector. How could he ask her what he was to her? He was...and the words trembled on her lips, shimmered on her lashes, hovered on their breaths, feathered against their skin, knocked on their minds, almost sank into their consciousness...almost.
Then Rudra narrowed his eyes against the clarity, the innocence, the sincerity shining in hers. Rejected her new game. Because that's what it must be. A new scheme. He stalked out. But couldn't escape the words. It mattered to her, she'd said. He was her protector. Then how could he ask her what he was to her. Unless. Unless it was hero-worship. Some delusion in her brain that he cared for her well-being. Therefore she was bound to him. That he mattered. So she couldn't leave him. Unless that's what she wanted him to think.
It took him the best part of the night to figure out a plan that would reveal the truth. Ruthless, but it would do the job. He was back in control when his eyes rested on her for a long, calculating moment as she slept at his father's feet. It was time to play ball.
He went to his room and packed a bag with money. Then went to get Paro. He spoke without heat, reasonably. He'd thought long about what she'd said. He believed that she repented for what she'd done. And he accepted that he was important to her. Her eager agreement that he was important to her only spurred him on. Now they had to figure out to what extent she could go gain his forgiveness, he told her, and received more uncontained enthusiasm, fervent promises. She could go to any extent; could do any thing; whatever he asked her to do; as long as he forgave her. He didn't really care, but he asked her anyway, to rethink her decision. Just so his conscience was clear. And she fell over herself to have him believe her: she'd thought about it. And even if he asked for her life she wouldn't question it.
He took her to the courtyard, before his family. And declared that he would forgive Paro, on one condition. She would have to do what he asked of her. Only then would he accept that her repentance, penance, her apology and her innocence were true and not an act. He turned to Paro for confirmation. Which the girl gave without hesitation.
So then he picked up a little pot of sindoor kept in front of the Lord and held it out in his palm for all to see, and tipped back the lid. And proposed marriage to Paro. To a shocked, speechless, Paro. He repeated his question to the girl who'd been willing to give her life for his forgiveness, but couldn't answer this one question. "Will you marry...Sumer?"
He might as well have thrown a grenade into the courtyard for the shell-shock that greeted his proposal. The gasps only accentuated the silence. But he was only interested in Paro's reaction. Her wide-eyed, open-mouthed disbelief. "Yes or no, Paro?" He prompted, brows-lowered over narrowed-eyes. It was Kakisa who took offence. Sumer would say no, she said. So Rudra asked Sumer, whose sneers had also melted into shock, to open the bag at his foot.
Sumer would not open any bag, Kakisa was furious. But Sumer had already pulled out bundles of cash from the bag. "There's three lakh in the bag. I'll give you 10 more. I know you dream of leaving Chandangarh and going to Jaipur. It will be fulfilled. Think about it. In return I want you to marry this girl and take her away from here." "Enough! That's enough!" It was Kakisa who broke. "This is my son not some vegetable in the market that you'll throw money at him and buy him!" "When do I marry her?" Sumer, however, had other ideas. Rudra made no attempt to mask his triumph. Sumer could marry her today. And leave that evening. Sumer would get the rest of the money after the wedding. The smile on Sumer's face told its own story. And he stepped up to shake on the deal, take the sindoor and Paro off Rudra's hands.
And dusting the traces of the sindoor off his hands, Rudra turned to the bride for her answer. Turned to a numb, horrified, girl on whom her avowals of repentence, penance, need for forgiveness, had all backfired. Bigtime!
What an episode!! Rudra's audacious, ruthless proposal, came out of left-field and knocked the breath out of me just as much as it did Paro and all the Ranawats gathered in the courtyard. So, this then was cool, calculating Rudra upping the ante. Responding, as he thought, in kind to Paro's game - her false avowals of innocence and need for forgiveness, her claims that he mattered. For, how could that be true? Because if her claims were true then... then they went against the grain of all that he believed in, beautiful women, their deception, their self-centredness. And so he drew back from the truth that stared him in the face.
The CVs gave us a captivating episode that tugged at the heart-strings as much as it played with the mind. And gave us rage, intimacy, pathos and humour all in one episode. The episode continued with Friday's PaRud altercation in the kitchen. Paro was the winner. And again in Dilsher's bedroom. So it was Rudra's turn to win at the end of today. And tomorrow it looks like Rudra will realise that his win isn't making him happy. No win at all, actually! Many lovely moments today such as the PaRud conversations in Dilsher's bedroom. There were some unlovely, but searing, moments too - I refer to the sindoor exchange between Rudra and Sumer and the way Rudra dusted his hands off afterwards.
Fabulous acting all around! But especially Ashish, who proficiently rolled out the many shades of his mind-games, which didn't quite conceal his anger and frustration or the moments of hope in between. Sanaya's defiance, enthusiasm, shock and pain were palpable. And the actor who plays Sumer was delightful especially when he thumbed his nose at his furious and frightened mother, played impeccably by Ananya. 👏 to all the cast!
After the precap I absolutely can't wait for tomorrow!! 😃

Sabs ... Loved the pace today ... Other than the left field proposal ... It seemed not so neck breaking ... Loved bold red ... Am a bit confused about Paro's dramatic change of heart ... So she know that the man she married and rudra had shot was a no good gun runner ... He seems to have morphed from a jallad to a savior overnight ... No wonder he is suspicious ... Is she hanging on truly to be forgiven or does she imagine herself ... Maybe not in love ... But enamored ... Thanks Sabs ...for keeping me posted
tvbug2011 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: napstermonster

I loved your analysis---


But I don't believe in Paro's "love." And I don't think the CVs do, either. I just don't think she has the depths of experience with him yet, to feel love. Not the kind of love she needs to feel, to deal with the burnt coal, smoke and ashes that are within that very masculine, attractive exterior. If she professes to love based on her eight weeks of Stockholm Syndrome, she will not have the strength to deal with the break down of this man, which is fast approaching.


She has the strongest feelings for him she has probably has ever had. I agree with that. Certainly attraction, certainly tenderness and your words--Hero Worship--certainly all that. How seductive he has been, for a simple village girl--their first fated meeting, right down to the last bullet---he is the hero of dreams. She has literally dreamed of him. But she is ignoring the fact her dreams are those of him being on fire--and that she is terrified of fire. And she should be terrified of a man who can do something like this.


She does not know Rudra, the broken man, the hatred for women like her, the crushed picture, the cruelty of the man. She has no real idea about exactly how flawed Rudra is. The pain that the doll represents to them--her overcoming her loss, him succumbing to it---right now she is not equipped to become HIS protector, which she will have to be. And he will not accept her in any role other than his plaything. She is his doll, being punished for being the one his mother mothered--at the cost of his childhood. And if he still suspects her for Dilsher's coma, he means it when he wants her gone from their lives. Tied to Sumer... punishment, indeed.


And she has no idea of the levels at work here--the jealousy Rudra nurtures for her, for example. He is a fantasy for her right now, a pseudo-god, who she kneels before, offering herself as a jogan/worshipper at his feet. He is a man--and not necessarily a good man. But for Paro, Rudra has been infallible so far--- she has never seen him doing, or being wrong. She sees him as someone who protects her at all costs. But what he make her do as praschith for a crime she has not committed--that will test her faith in such simple role-plays. He needs to stop being her eternal protector--maybe even become the one she needs protection, at least emotionally, from. He needs to be wrong. And THEN if she loves him--it will be a love tested through that fire she fears, but walks through, for him.


If her love in not based on awareness of his flaws, and the compassion to overcome them, it will be useless to them both. I believe that he will still be the one to love first, and love deeply. She will have to actually see him as a man, and not a god, before she can love him-and first, he will have to fall far below the protector, and become the villain, in a way, before he gets her love.

Thank you, Napster, for your profound analysis. 👏 Some great insights here.

@ No depth in her love: Agreed, although you could argue that being untouched by strong emotion for a man other than Rudra, she loves him with everything she's capable of at the moment. But agree that that is nowhere near what it will take to love him in his entirety.

@ She does not know how flawed Rudra is: She has seen him at his worst, as the Jallad. And she has stood up to him. But then she was not emotionally vulnerable to him and his devious, cruel mind-games. At the moment, she has swung to the other extreme. She has seen his pain and his proven truth and opened herself up to him. She has whitewashed him and voluntarily blinded herself to that less than savoury aspect of him. So I agree, she has no clue what lies under the surface of Rudra, but is dangerously vulnerable to him now.

@ She has no idea of the levels at work here: I'm actually not too sure that we the audience have such a good grip either. 😆 Last night made me wonder if Rudra, having accurately read her hero worship for him, was pulling this unsavoury stunt to cure her of it brutally and effectively. A rude, hard shock so that he would fall from her grace and she'd leave him and go. Or whether there was an element of compassion there and he just wanted to let her know that she'd read him wrong that he wasn't the man she thought him to be. Give her a taster of what depths he could sink to, and then give her an out. i.e. pick her up and tend to her grazes.

@ She must love Rudra the whole flawed man, and not Rudra the hero/God: Great point and agreed!
@ He will be the one to love first: I think that has already happened. No he does not love her with everything he's capable of, simply because he does not know her/won't let himself know her completely. But he is already there, not just toe-deep, but knee-deep in love. That's why I wonder if he will really be able to go through with her marrying Sumer, if she were to say yes.
piccola1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: napstermonster



If her love in not based on awareness of his flaws, and the compassion to overcome them, it will be useless to them both. I believe that he will still be the one to love first, and love deeply. She will have to actually see him as a man, and not a god, before she can love him-and first, he will have to fall far below the protector, and become the villain, in a way, before he gets her love.


WOW ! Superb analysis Nap..
golpokobita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#15
Ruthless indeed.

But I think what made the proposal dirty and filthy is buying Sumer with money. I don't know why CVs couldn't avoid that. I mean Sumer is interested in Paro from the beginning .. they could have shown Sumer consenting to marriage because of his interest (be it love or whatever) for Paro...

But the way the man (Rudra) showed his strength over woman (with wealth) wasn't digestible for me!

Of course, this goes without saying that the twist was absolutely breathtaking!


Edited by golpokobita - 11 years ago
tvbug2011 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: aruni50218


I was waiting for your review, because i was confused what Rudra's real intention was. Your interpretation, makes sense - He thinks Paro is pretending, she can't be that good, so he is testing her, albeit in a ruthless way. But does he wanna know the truth? Because if she agrees to what he says, (I don't think Paro will agree without twisting it into a big shock to Rudra), and if Paro really is good, is he going to believe it? The story would end then. Because its Rudra's dark past that drags this story forward. Thakur, Laila are only assorted MUs.
SO in the end it is, that CV's twist was mindblowing. Eagerly waiting for tomorrow. ⭐️

Hey Aruni, glad my take made sense. 😊
Rudra's set himself up in a no-win situation. If Paro goes with Sumer she'd have reinforced what he knows about women. He'd have won, but been betrayed again. If she doesn't go, her word means nothing. She was lying, she doesn't really care that much for him. So he might think he's presented Paro with a Catch 22. But it's he, who will lose - who's already lost Paro's trust as her protector and fallen off the pedestal she'd put him on.
deep0909 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#17
I like your interpretation the best! Indeed Rudra still believes Paro is playing a game... your writing about their feelings when she expresses herself is out of this world. You describe it so beautifully. I could actually visualize the exact flutter of sanaya's eyelashes, paro and rudra's collective breath and their expressions...
Hats off to you
ddsoaps thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#18
Beautiful analysis...

A truly twisted episode...

Cant wait for tonight...
tvbug2011 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: sonia_1

Absolutely love your RR's...👏

Superb episode today !
Rudra's googly with ' Will you marry...Sumer' has the entire Ranawat clan and us shocked .😆 Maybe Rudra is on to Kaki and Sumer's involvement 😕 remains to be seen.

This is beautifully written 👏...He was her protector. How could he ask her what he was to her? He was...and the words trembled on her lips, shimmered on her lashes, hovered on their breaths, feathered against their skin, knocked on their minds, almost sank into their consciousness...almost.

Thank you, Sonia. 😳😃 Delighted my writing appeals to you.
It really was an outstanding episode. And I really hope that he's doing this to smoke out the larger truth about his father's attempted murder.
DiyaS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#20
tvbug, Naps, loveanime ... thanks for your takes ... they helped me make some sense of the episode. Will be back with a longer comment later, if time permits.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".