Critics Corner #6 - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

43.6k

Users

30

Likes

2.7k

Frequent Posters

aditee thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#71
Yumna,
Maine khud ne 4 "Down the memory lane" topics kholi hain
I do this for a living...........
Will have to dig those up
rooj-i thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#72
I know I'm late but like promised I have the analysis to yesterday's epi. It's not long like my usual ones but I hope this is good enough.

Episode

Shaan and Anand scene:

Shaan and Anand scene was good. I found their dialogues a bit pheeka but other than that it was good encouraging scene. Hiten was superb and yet i felt that KT was nervous around him despite shooting with him already.

Anand's dialogues to the ladies were good, I guess it was necessary to see their point of views but the lady's delivery was bad. lol typical. lol

Shanak Scene:

I'm going to disregard the whole fidelity issue for the time being and just focus on the scene and chemistry of the two.

The scene was really good but the Shakkar part was like done on purpose I felt. I loved it how they showed it tht they are each others saharas. It felt more like KT and Yashu than Shanak and I'm not saying that as their fan. I'm saying that because the smiles, the small naughty eye-locks and touches felt like them. especially when shaan was taking the shakkar, it seemed KT was blushing.

After a while we got such a close scene. Their dialogues were good too.

Song sequence:

I felt that the song was rushed. KT can dance but he needs energy hence Hiten was really good in the song. I felt that KT sings it from the heart but Hiten is two steps forward. I'm not comparing but yet there is a difference clearly seen.
The song was def. rushed but it was still good.
Yashu's laugh was more like hers than Khanak.

Rahul and Jenny scene:

I don't know why i watched it but i did and didn't like it much. Although it was shot good, as in acting wise it was good but just didn't want to watch it.

Mangal and Khanak scene:

The most powerful scene of the whole epi. I really, really loved it! This was my fav. scene of the whole epi that made sense to me and wasn't rushed! I loved it!
Mangal's attitude from beginning till end was amazing!
the way Khanak took the stand was def. a wifely thing!

Thumbs up:

1. KT and YM superb acting!
2. Hiten was good too!
3. Even manish and that Jenny girl were good.
4. Mangal was good too!
5. Loved Mangal and Khanak scene.
6. Minus the fidelity factor, the shanak scene was good.

Thumbs Down:

1. didn't like the way song was rushed.
2. Of course the fidelity issue.
3. KT's dancing
4. Rajen scenes...
5. Some dialogues were just avanyi.
6. editing!

Prediction:

1. Is it me but is sarpanch with Mangal, like with him with him? I felt that Sarpanch and mangal will try to do something bad.
2. Of course Mangal harming Shaan or Khanak to get them out of the place.
3 Either Shaan quiting or Khanak trying to help shaan w/o letting him know that Mangal is out to get Shaan.
4. I really think tht in the end Anand's dying or halat might help and the factory will be built.

Ok im done now!

sorry for being late!

jparker thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#73
@aditee: I guess in a soap, it is normal to go back.. or look back.. it is a very normal reaction and I believe it is a must. then be it viewers or the CV's!! It is healthy and a necessity!!
That helps maintain this balance of staying in tune with the essence of the story, the characters, the show itself.. Else if it just wanders without any aim, what isthe point!!
I wish this was adapted by the CV's too!! If a new set comes, then the old must be responsible in when leaving to make the new aware of the essence!!
@rooj-i: excellent analysis!!👏
Edited by jparker - 14 years ago
vaish_123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#74
@ rooj

Great analysis 👏👏👏


rooj-i thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#75
@ Jessica and Vaishu: thanks guys...I hope we get a better epi today...lol
kubare thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#76
Rooj darling lovely analyis ...it seems all of us have narly th sam issue with the epi....😆😆😆😆
simikr thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#77
Sorry guys, but I had to put my bit in....just had to...
The only part I really liked yesterday was the Khanak and Mangal scene..I liked it so much that I wished that it was much longer!!😭
The song was just about okay..it seemed not real, or shall I say too easy, why didn't Khanak talk to the villagers too? I don't like her staying in the back ground all the time...the kids were really cute though:)
Shanak scene..me didn't like,...too sweet for my taste...
aditee thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#78
Vaishu
Looks like it was major sob fest today!
Not sure if I will review it yaar
See you after school duty in an hr!
kubare thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#79

Today's Epi dated 24-02-2011

Shanak scene: Ok ..was stretchd way to much ....but both of them..cute..
Anand Khanak & Shaan...them having tea, talking about the whole factory issue...gettng ready and then Anand getting taht heart attack...all nicely done...
Bestest Scene for me :Anand & Khanak scene too day...loved loved loved it...even with Shaan's body double entring and KT's/Shaan's cheat shots...the to who stood out were YM & HT...as have said before too..KT is an actor who does excptionally well when he has to react to good actors in front of him....he was good ....the scene could have been much better with Shaan standing with them...near Khanak...but alas good...
"I hate tears..Pushpa" are my fav dialogues now...because of HT....😆😆😆 Whole scene beautifully done...
Khandelwal family cute...really cute....an good acting...
Rahul scene...bearable really...😆😆😆😆 had to only bear him for a min with FB of Sam...call of Jenny...😆😆😆
Precap:....can't wait to see how that fares...
Anand being a big shot was already discussed by all of us when his character was introduced..
Trust issue still pending....wishlist may come into play....
rooj-i thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#80
OMG Di...u already did it!?

ok i will do another one too!

I can't wait to watch it!

Thanks...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".