ANALYSIS: 3rd Feburary 2011 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

1.9k

Users

14

Likes

75

Frequent Posters

.Dilwale. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#11

@ridssy


no one is 'after him' as you say dear. everyone is just giving their take. yours is most welcome too. we will all forgive him tomorrow or as soon as he reaches dhulwadi beacuse we love shanak too much to stay mad at them for long😳 we are just referring to today's episode.

The_May_Rose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#12
Okay, here goes my reply Zen, hope I haven't contradicted myself😳, nice analysis btw😊.....

Originally posted by: zennnn

hey all,

so a bit thanda episode, wasn't it? am disappointed to say the least. on more fronts then one but there were definitely a few highlights in there as well. so let's get on with it.

Yes it was a thanda episode.....Wanted Shaan to react strongly regarding what Rahul said....
He took more offense to what Sunny was saying, probubly because he had no business....He knows nothing about their marriage....
SHAAN:

ok, i already know all the following by heart and i am still don't pity shaan i am sorry:

1. he is a burthal.

2. he is being a guy only.

3. but don't we love him because he is a jerk.

3. he is drunk or angry or frustrated (depending on the situation).

4. shaan has a big ego. (well don't we all?) (thanks for this rooj😉)

5. and the latest one, he is in denial ( which seems strange considering yesterday we concluded that the reason he humiliated his wife in public was because he is impulsive and hot blooded)

all i can say at this point is (because i have not given up my hope of seeing a repenting shaan tomorrow) that shaan is a jerk but a lucky jerk because not only khanak, all of us are ready to let him away with whatever he does!Embarrassed😆 i just hope, this time khanak won't forgive him easily though because then i'll be super pissed at her too!😡

I will commend Sunny for being a good guy.....But Shaan already knows deep down he is wrong....His behaviour is not ego it's insecurity....Not about Khanak & Sunny, but about Khanak's feelings for Suraj.....For Shaan he has to be number one in her heart, or his life is empty.....In Shaan's mind the MMS fiasco has brought back all the insecurities about his place in Khanak's heart....Khanak asked yesterday about Shaan's faith in their love....But Shaan faith in himself is not that high, so he reacting to that I guess....
KHANAK:

i liked the scene where she was hesitant to get on the bus and hoping against all hope that shaan has again come to get her. i sympathize with her and i don't see how one can't. can you really blame me if i find widowship vs. band breaking coz' of a slap more tragic? she has been through a lot. i can not for the life of me understand how the CVs expected us to feel for the rockies when the serial started on such a serious note: widowship as well as having to live with the guilt of negligently killing someone ( though sadly the latter was never explored). anyways, anand khanak scenes i am looking forward to. hopefully tomorrow we'll get them.

It was heart-warming to see her hoping for Shaan, but then reminding herself to stand her ground....Tomorrow we should expect a exploration of how Khanak's life has changed....Regarding Shaan's regret, that too will be explored....Perhaps with a scene between Madhavi and Shaan....She wasn't shown today, but the family were....

During the engagement fiasco she was the one to emotionally blackmail Shaan about Suraj's death....Perhaps this time she will be the one to give him the himmat he needs....Accidently killing somone is no small thing.....Shaan needs to open up about it.....

KT AND YM:

i have said this a million times and i'll say it again today. these two are damn good at what they do. damn good. they are equal because one has what the other lacks and we have seen ample proof for it. however, there is one thing, KT might be even the better actor sometimes but the one thing he still has to work on is consistency. by consistency, i do not mean being brilliant in each and every episode. that's just not possible for an actor who is after all a human. but to be above average in most. yesterday, he was so good that one couldn't help feeling for him even if you were mad at his character but today, it was simply eh. i am not judging him on shaan's cool reaction. over all, the performance looked a bit monotonous and thanda.

YM, she is consistent, there is no doubt about that. she is not brilliant in every episode but at least pretty good in most. today however, i only liked two scenes of her's: the geeting on the bus one and when she remembers shaan. the part where she is disappointed on seeing anand instead of shanatanu, feel a bit short. the reaction should have showed more disappointed.

Love YashAran and ShaNak....Jaans of the show!....

SUNNY:

he rocked today's episode. i think he stole the show despite HT much hyped entry. i was waitig like anything for hiten but today the one person i really remember from today's episode is sunny and harpreet. he had the best dialogues today. very very impactful! i liked the cold calm amd firm way in which 'he showed shaan the mirror', in his own words. he told shaan what he needed to hear and which his good for nothing friends would never say. i wish i could write all his dialogues here but i am too lazy😛

I beg to differ.....He feels sorry for Khanak, he is a good guy, but it's none of his business....He also knows nothing about ShaNak's marriage.....And I have stated my viewes on Sunny before, enough said😳.....For me Shaan's mirror should be his family....I am hoping Madhavi comes through tomorrow....I was hoping Shaan would do this on his own....But since everyone has had their two cents, why not Shaan's mother?.....The letter truth etc would be icing on the cake😊......

HITEN/ANAND:

like i said! anand hi anand aanaey wala hai ab tu!😆 ok, frankly it's too early to comment on his performance but hiten has something called an easy charm. saaz once said that there is something very straightforward about his acting and today i couldn't agree more! after gaurav gera, his is the first entry in RBO that i have truly truly enjoyed.

Cute entry....Loved how he got the old lady to say ILU😆......Can't wait for the Dulwahdhi conversation.....

HOPES FOR TOMORROW:

a hot blooded reaction from shaan. i have still not given up on it......That will be next week or if we are lucky Saturday....

a funny spontaneous khanak and anand scene.Saturday....

no rasam tomorrow pleeeeeeeeez! Yep!

So those were my thoughts.....Another thing that I had to mention and you guys will laugh....I don't forgive Rahul for what he did and neither should ShaNak..... But I admired Manish's acting when Khanak stopped him speaking yesterday....And today I loved the line he said to Shaan.....' I came to beat you Shaan, but your Khanak won my heart...'👍🏼......No I am not a fan of Rahul, but Manish was good😳....
.Dilwale. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#13

@may


mayeee!🤗thanks for commenting only and not coming with a belan🤣 i love you my positive wise may! i love you bud!


why are you so mean to my sunny huh? i thought at least today you would appericiate him!😛😆


as for shaan,

lol! i am not forgiving shaan yet. period. i know i will very soon, maybe even tomorrow😳 but not today. no matter who and how he is. how 'insecure' or whatever. wait, let me add that to my suchi of excuses for shaan as well!🤣 nah i won't! only coz' i lub you ok! but it's like i said, the CVs really don't sketch the characters as deeply as we analyse them. you see what you get on tv only.

Edited by zennnn - 14 years ago
destinylove thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#14
Yaar
some of u asking why we are after shaan today and trying ur best to explain his behaviour..
we are after him because we expected more from him since he has been constantly saying he loves his wife too much
and this was not so ordinary matter It is involving his wifes honour
Yes zen
I loved ur analysis and me felt today Hiten/Yashu were the saving grace..😃
sunny was good
but shaan was not at all upto the mark for reasons best known to the cvs..I think they did not write his part properly in the script today..
The_May_Rose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#15
Love you too Zenuu🤗......I was only thinking about what comments to post, belan never crossed my mind😆.....
I don't know what it is about Sunny.....He is a good person, but kya karo???.....It's how I feel😳😆......I tried, I really tired to like him....I don't hate him, just don't love him like you do😆.....
The_May_Rose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: The_May_Rose

Love you too Zenuu🤗......I was only thinking about what comments to post, belan never crossed my mind😆.....

I don't know what it is about Sunny.....He is a good person, but kya karo???.....It's how I feel😳😆......I tried, I really tired to like him....I don't hate him, just don't love him like you do😆.....

Oh and regarding Shaan again.....If it was any other couple, with no look-a-like or hate-history.....I would be equally annoyed at Shaan....But ShaNak have alot of issues and it's not a simple right and wrong.....
Edited by The_May_Rose - 14 years ago
.Dilwale. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#17

@may


sunny is a good soul re! at least he has a heart and a brain, which shaan's so called budies sadly don't. i'd rather have him in the show than those guys! i am so done with them, seriously!

tina2mina thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#18
Very well written Zenn.. You said everything that I was thinking after watching today's episode. Even I called him a jerk after seeing the way he was refusing to believe that his own wife is innocent. Such an idiot jerk. I hope the CVs don't drag this matter for too long, where Shaan realizes his stupidity & repents BIG time. I want to see them together in Dhulwadi soon.
.Dilwale. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#19

@tina2mina


thanks for commenting! yes he was a jerk today but i am willing to forgive him as soon as he repents and goes after khanak to say sorry. i am super mad at him today but i can't stay angry at my shanak for long! but agreed! he was a total jerk today!

Sairaaaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#20
Zenn; lovely take on todays episode! Agree on EACH and EVERY word.

^^I'm still divided whether it was KT who was not at his best today or his reactions of his character were so unsatisfying,he totally deserved a kick! 😡 maha burthal he is! He's repentance better bring the vulnerable in me,so it is much easier for me to forgive him. I know I will forgive him eventually BUT totally behaved like the old selfish shaan today! about him and him only!

^^I love HT as Anand,he simply had this kinda old world charm and just brings a smile to your face,me waiting for him and Khanak to bond,it will seem simply cute :) AND not to forget sunny the star today and the others less said the better.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".