Critics' Corner # 4 Feb 4th epi pg 142

First Previous

Page

118

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Urooj

@rooj-i

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#21

I'll be honest...as much i'm a gushy romance lover but that scene is not worth it if it spells exhibitionism...I'd rather we have the old types...if they have a private balcony, away from everyone's eyes then I'd prefer that...

this was a bit messed up. Although the actors were fab in portraying...

still gotta watch the rest of the epi...

Quote

Aditi S

@aditee

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#22

25 January 2011

Didnt watch the whole thing!

Just couldnt!

Thumbs Up

Rahul receiving the slap👏👏

Now waiting for the Rock On writers and cast to exit the show

To her credit Khanak "tried" to tell hubby what had transpired! Not sure if she tried hard enough though

Thumbs Down:

ShaNak scene. Never thought this day would ever come.😭

Too staged. Is Khanak so overcome with his physicality she drops her purse? Too phillumy!

Playing for the stands in my opinion. Making out in the parking lot? I was for a second there, shocked when he parted her dupatta. I feared he was going to take it off

Wonder why they are making ShaNak as "steamy" as RASAM

I personally dont enjoy too much touching. These two can convey so much with intense or light hearted flirting!

Why make them paw each other "so" much?

I fail to understand!

If you didnt watch the opening visual and had just heard KT, you could have been fooled into thinking it was a poor man's SRK! You are right Doc D, he does copy him a lot! Aaj it was too apparent............ he did a terrible job!

Why couldnt they have been in the chori chori outfits and just be talking or arguing?

Would have sent my heart racing like anything😳😳

Her green suit was HORRID! What was that cheap metal flower pin on the center?

Her asking to carry his guitar was supposed to be nok-jhok?

And that conversation in the car?

Why do I feel something is just not right between the two? Cant place my finger on it, but something's just not right!

Her C---- was showing! Gosh! The classiness of the show had degraded significantly, but never expected the leading lady to look like a low class -----r

All ShaNak scenes were super staged!

Sunny Rahul confrontation total Kekta flavor

Holding the fist? Really?

Rahul's redemption after "one" slap?

Thats all it takes?

Maybe India should try that with all its enemies

All that Rahul ever does is work out?

Whats with that slllllllllllow smile and that smug look

So not suiting him!

He needs to be let go

How ever much he happens to be the "boss's" favorite

Edited by aditee - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

IFsKhanak

@IFsKhanak

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#23

i might have offended people at the DT by saying this

so i guess i'll just paste it here instead :P

the way shan looked at khanak in the scene with sunil, had more effect on me than the rain scene..

must be growing really old :P

this shanak scene seemed more like the scenes they want to show for rasam..

if he'd carried her to his room

i'd have understood

i think this was a last minute forced addition

to the complains we made

complains like

we wanted to see shanak in rain and we got khanak sunny

Quote

Aditi S

@aditee

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#24

@Teech: Well said!

I felt they must have read the posts of despair in the Forum and just added that later

Pathetic!

T'was

Quote

Urooj

@rooj-i

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#25

I'll be honest...the only scenes I really enjoyed of Shanak was the one with Sunil in it...That one look that Shaan gives Khanak was enough for me...so im with teech on this...if they had shown the rain scene with Shaan taking her to the room and proceeding there then it wud be worth the watch but other than that it lacked the omph factor...although the actors were superb!

The second scene that I loved was the RAsam scene...the only time I liked their scene was few of the beginning scenes or the one with Khanak.

This scene had dialogues and Manish was good till the end of that scene...no self thoughts no nothing and seedha saving Shanak...wat a waste of the scene...btw one slap is not enough for me...

rest of the epi...ummm not worth talkin...

Quote

sweetsute

@sweetsute

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#26

@aditee i agree wid u .even i didn't liked d dress

Quote

saaaz

@saaaz

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#27

YOU WANT A TRP scene....CONTEXUALISE IT......dont butcher the characters in the process...hold on dont bury the already butchered characters.....

and believe me this is not about intellectualising at all.......

I mean if they had shown a scene where Shaan and Khanak are stuck in a busstop - car breaks down and they are going through carzy inner turmoil and in the busstop two strangers are totally making out and Shanak are speaking to each other with their eyes or for that matter imagine each other in that spot.. becos for that particular moment they want to forget everything else and the strangers making out proved to be catalytical,,, I could have still digested it....it can possibly be a TRP cum decent scene.....TOTAL RIVETTING ENTERTAINMENT...like a munni badnaam hui....

BUT THIS IS B GRADE.....complete B grade.....

and I may be hurting sentiments here, but this is my opinion....

As for Sunil-Khank-Shaan scene.....YET again,...it is proved that CVs need to to get abck to K house if RBO needs to revive!!!!!

Quote

Urooj

@rooj-i

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#28

@ Saazy: i agree with you 100%

even I am not upto feeling today's epi...usually I am but not today...it didn't appeal me except for less than a minute of Sunil and Shanak and RAsam scene...that's it...for the rest, the less said the better....

yesterday's epi was worth a watch...

Quote

Aditi S

@aditee

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#29

Originally posted by: saaaz

YOU WANT A TRP scene....CONTEXUALISE IT......dont butcher the characters in the process...hold on dont bury the already butchered characters.....

and believe me this is not about intellectualising at all.......

I mean if they had shown a scene where Shaan and Khanak are stuck in a busstop - car breaks down and they are going through carzy inner turmoil and in the busstop two strangers are totally making out and Shanak are speaking to each other with their eyes or for that matter imagine each other in that spot.. becos for that particular moment they want to forget everything else and the strangers making out proved to be catalytical,,, I could have still digested it....it can possibly be a TRP cum decent scene.....TOTAL RIVETTING ENTERTAINMENT...like a munni badnaam hui....

BUT THIS IS B GRADE.....complete B grade.....

and I may be hurting sentiments here, but this is my opinion....

As for Sunil-Khank-Shaan scene.....YET again,...it is proved that CVs need to to get abck to K house if RBO needs to revive!!!!!

Sorry Saaz

I will disagree on that one thing

There need not have been any strangers making out either

In the jari booti scene

When she serves him noodles, he is staring at her face through her hair😳

When he checks her out in the aaj ki subah kuch khaas hai scene

When he pushes a lock of hair behind her ear in the KKH scene

You can clearly tell whats on his mind

He wants to make love

Thats all it takes for him to convey that to her

She understood it each and every time. Each of us watching at home would feel the scald /burn from the touch or the look

No touching, just a look or a word

Edited by aditee - 14 years ago

Quote

saaaz

@saaaz

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#30

See Aditeee

I completely get what you are saying....but seee there we go again....interpreting a today;s scene with a GOLDEN RBO moment....

for me even if I get out of that mode...and say listen these CVs needed to put TRP scene becos they had just bungled with an EM EM ASSS scene....what they did today just went and made it worse.....

to keep Shaan and Khanak within characters after having butchered them to no end.......

I mean come one...the Shaantanu you are talking about left the building before he reached and saw Khanak wet.......he came there with his head full of wanting to make out with his wife.....and tahts why I say let them imagine themselves doing it....becos frankly tahts was what this scene was...

Had to make shanak do it so that people forget what the EEM EEM ASS looked like

forget the old Shaan and the eye talking.....chaado !!!!!