Flashbacks on a Saturday! ;- )

saaaz

@saaaz

Dazzler

23

Posted: 14 years ago

#91

thanks fr agreeing but its realy depresing how insecure people bcum fr jodi s n start discussing new veiewrs n saying y they joined now,wat was RBO before ,critising new entries n again n again saying the show belongs to khanak repeadly shows their insecurity.we never said show dint belong to khanak ,but they cant just show a jodi all the time only ,even i dint like ILU track,it has nt been abt scnes as such fr me the storyline is imp.it was not priyanka s episode but still enjoyed it as the story is proceeding is best posible way with duck n rahul n happy to see FB s specialy priyanka in those .

Nahin yaar..tanvi...I don;t think we are criticing the newbies at all,,,,in fact the only thing that has come under the magnifying glass is the 'treatment' of the new track...read this whole post and you will see nowhere we are saying rasam ko bhasam karo ...in fact we are discussing...we want to see FB ...we want to know everyone's story...Writers of RBO -please tell us RASAM story the 'way' you told us Shanak story,,,make us feel for 'RASAM" too....matlab we are rooting for RASAM fans...we are all on one side...the side that represents a good show...with stories told well...and I second MAY completely...while we should 'DISCUSS" crazily the technical aspects of a daily show,..we hope the CVs make decisions after seeing our reactions post episodes for a week...I consider myself an RBO fan (becos I am STORY lover too) not shanak not Rasam...yes Shanak happened to be here before and SURAJ-Khanak happened to be there before Shanak...story ko aage kaise badha rahe hai without loosing sight of what they have built so far...in fact I thought Manish looked fantastic in the FB scenes...fantastic....

2

Reply

Quote

saaaz

@saaaz

Dazzler

23

Posted: 14 years ago

#92

Originally posted by: tanvismile
i loved the FBs ,the wer nt actual .FBs they wer just to give n idea of wat there wer in past,cool dudes,their personality,unity,fight,sam was totaly boyish ,i feel those scenes wer lovely .

I like this viewpoint you have brought in...the FB scene as just a snapshot...I all the time was looking for expressions becos there wre no words (and I am words fanatic).....but you looked at the aesthetic to convey the message.,.AH!!!! see, I have completely benefited from this perspective,...PLEASE PLEASE POST MORE....

2

Reply

Quote

tanvismile

@tanvismile

Sparkler

32

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#93

Originally posted by: saaaz

I like this viewpoint you have brought in...the FB scene as just a snapshot...I all the time was looking for expressions becos there wre no words (and I am words fanatic).....but you looked at the aesthetic to convey the message.,.AH!!!! see, I have completely benefited from this perspective,...PLEASE PLEASE POST MORE....

thank u so much.

Reply

Quote

garfield1209

@garfield1209

Voyager

18

Posted: 14 years ago

#94

Hey Tanvi ...no one was criticising ...they were wondering whats their take on this line..actually it started with Saaz following show from day one ...and some picking from Kuch Khas Hai...so all of us boarded the train at different stations.😊......so our take on the journey is different ...

And ditto on the flashback..it was just an essence of the past not actual scenes playing out ....I found that refereshing ...

2

Reply

Quote

Aditi S

@aditee

Inactive

27

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#95

Just like any/every other desi TV show, I am sure this has a viewership profile of 10-60 year olds.

I have no idea how this show ranks currently on the TRP front

One fact I know is it was not the top in the past, EVEN IN THE GOLDEN DAYS.

Thats quite disappointing for ShaNak/love story lovers like me!😒

IF ShaNak were so fabulous or were such a roaring success, brought in the best TRPs like Balika Vadhu etc (at one point) we wouldnt be seeing today's show!

THAT BY ITSELF TELLS US SOMETHING

We have no clue WHAT drives TRPs of this show

We KNOW FULLY WELL what WE LOVE about this show

Those two must meet at some point, but where, I dont have an idea

But have always been interested to know, considering I watch desi TV shows for a living😆

If Rock On track and all these additional characters and the story of Shaan's college days is what will cause it to top the TRPs

Then SO BE IT!

I wish the creatives best of luck

They gave me a great show

I dont wish for destruction or the sudden pulling of the plug or any such thing

We will all eventually find shows/love stories/ characters to relate to ....................... with TIME

I mean Indian TV must have over 100 channels, the ones that play soaps, I am guessing there must be atleast a dozen of them, Saaz feel free to correct me

Its hard for me to advise ShaNak lovers to "some how start enjoying this ShaNak void" while at the same time difficult to say to the sane/content lovers/overall show lovers "the Rock On plot should not click"

I dont know what tracks revive the meandering/drowning stories mid way , what the sure shot success formula is etc...........

I am hoping Swapnaji and creatives know the answer to that

Edited by aditee - 14 years ago

1

Reply

Quote

Krishna

@kubare

Sparkler

34

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#96

Hello al l*waves

@Saaz adn Priya...High Ten to both of you as I have watched RBO from teh beginning too....fell in love with the promo..the only show on Star One after Sarabhai vs Sarabhai that was really worth watching...

For me too like May and Priya...Suraj wa a calm person adn the chemistry between them was so very different from Shanaks....

The first time the did a scene together ...they just clicked...it was fireworks really...and from teh whole Methi Kuamr scene to the falling from the camel, buying bangles..to the talk in the Mandir to the whole Hatered part...they sizzled...

So true, Khanak's character was beautifully etched...and the CV's indeed did a fantastic job..with her....

Loved RBO from the start and hope we get to see some great epis...in the future too...

4

Reply

Quote

tanvismile

@tanvismile

Sparkler

32

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#97

Originally posted by: saaaz

thanks fr agreeing but its realy depresing how insecure people bcum fr jodi s n start discussing new veiewrs n saying y they joined now,wat was RBO before ,critising new entries n again n again saying the show belongs to khanak repeadly shows their insecurity.we never said show dint belong to khanak ,but they cant just show a jodi all the time only ,even i dint like ILU track,it has nt been abt scnes as such fr me the storyline is imp.it was not priyanka s episode but still enjoyed it as the story is proceeding is best posible way with duck n rahul n happy to see FB s specialy priyanka in those .

Nahin yaar..tanvi...I don;t think we are criticing the newbies at all,,,,in fact the only thing that has come under the magnifying glass is the 'treatment' of the new track...read this whole post and you will see nowhere we are saying rasam ko bhasam karo ...in fact we are discussing...we want to see FB ...we want to know everyone's story...Writers of RBO -please tell us RASAM story the 'way' you told us Shanak story,,,make us feel for 'RASAM" too....matlab we are rooting for RASAM fans...we are all on one side...the side that represents a good show...with stories told well...and I second MAY completely...while we should 'DISCUSS" crazily the technical aspects of a daily show,..we hope the CVs make decisions after seeing our reactions post episodes for a week...I consider myself an RBO fan (becos I am STORY lover too) not shanak not Rasam...yes Shanak happened to be here before and SURAJ-Khanak happened to be there before Shanak...story ko aage kaise badha rahe hai without loosing sight of what they have built so far...in fact I thought Manish looked fantastic in the FB scenes...fantastic....

i know all r not like dat ,i dont want to hurt anyone but i read many coments wer they shanak is main ,their tune ,read abt coments wer people even said i dont no y people joined now fr RASAM.i read it ,i totaly undertand u but i think wat happens is comarison ,ul have loved a jodi n want RASAm to b similar way ,shanak story was not flashback story type ,rasam seems to b past ,so thier revealing things slowly ,opening up with character slowly,like unsolved mysteries the thing hapens with ull is comparison that only we have no comparision we r watching it ,liking it .shanak was straight storyline as the show strated with them.not flashback type.

i love u said i m RBO fan,i totaly respect ur views.

3

Reply

Quote

garfield1209

@garfield1209

Voyager

18

Posted: 14 years ago

#98

Amen to that Krishna.... *high ten too* 😊

That mithai scene they clicked...Shaans smile when Khanak says mention not ...When we are on flash back I would love flash back of Shaan on their journey...maybe over a music seesion with Duck and Sam explaining how Khanak became a part of his life.... *sigh!*

If wishes were horses beggars woud ride..aiasa kuch tha na ?

Edited by priya1209 - 14 years ago

5

Reply

Quote

saaaz

@saaaz

Dazzler

23

Posted: 14 years ago

#99

Aditee.. so true di 😛...remember my reply to Gayu on do creatives really listen and I said low TRP shows have the best writing...they seriously do,,,,that why I diligently watched RBO from day one. even when it was zero in TRPS...also the timing of this show and none of the actors wre in BIG time previous TRP shows.....I have followed Swapna;s work..she has written some really great shows and most of Yashu;s marathi serial was actually quite good- she played a girl who wanted to pursue kabbadi professionally...it was a well told story...of course its production values were nowehere close to a Starone show...however a good story....end of the day no matter where we boarded the train....like May put it...

before Khanak was a widow- when she became one- after she remarried- and now hopefully when she is the glue that shall stick her husband's life (including his career and friends together)...a good story...I will watch..now if the new track has nothing to do with the previous stations...then hello I am on wrong train....because then after she remarries falls in love and become inconsequential...are you saying that she was better off in dhulwadi....thats when I step off the train and someone else gets on to enjoy another route...becos alongwith me I belive Khanak has stepped off too...

5

Reply

Quote

Aditi S

@aditee

Inactive

27

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#100

Originally posted by: saaaz
Aditee.. so true di 😛...remember my reply to Gayu on do creatives really listen and I said low TRP shows have the best writing...they seriously do,,,,that why I diligently watched RBO from day one. even when it was zero in TRPS...also the timing of this show and none of the actors wre in BIG time previous TRP shows.....I have followed Swapna;s work..she has written some really great shows and most of Yashu;s marathi serial was actually quite good- she played a girl who wanted to pursue kabbadi professionally...it was a well told story...of course its production values were nowehere close to a Starone show...however a good story....end of the day no matter where we boarded the train....like May put it...

before Khanak was a widow- when she became one- after she remarried- and now hopefully when she is the glue that shall stick her husband's life (including his career and friends together)...a good story...I will watch..now if the new track has nothing to do with the previous stations...then hello I am on wrong train....because then after she remarries falls in love and become inconsequential...are you saying that she was better off in dhulwadi....thats when I step off the train and someone else gets on to enjoy another route...becos alongwith me I belive Khanak has stepped off too...

Well said!

We will all choose to board and disembark this train at various points.

The train can accomodate only so many people (read, it cannot please every viewer on the planet)

The next two months are critical

4

Reply

Quote