The 'book' track is super lame!!! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

2.6k

Users

17

Likes

99

Frequent Posters

aditee thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: -Nitya-

I understand your opinion, I think the track is rather silly as well..but one thing I don't get is..why are you bringing the actor into this? You have to understand that the actor and character are different people, with completely different personalities.😳 Mentioning KT and his opinions doesn't even relate to your topic..come on, please don't bring the actors into this. They actually visit the forum..criticizing the characters and the show is fine, but not the actors(unless its on their acting.)

and about the topic..I don't see why Shaan is using a book to express his thoughts as well. I guess it's all just to give a show a comic touch due to all of the divorce seriousness that's going on right now..I haven't been looking too much into the track so can't really say anything more.
I'm pretty sure the track ended with yesterday's episode..so it's back to normal now. (:

Nitya,
I havent read the IF rule book in a while, but truly apologize if it mentions some place that I shouldnt be mentioning the actors!
But whether you like it or not storylines/plots/themes/screenplay like what we have been subject to in the past month, the horror of woh teen shabd and the idiosyncratic "Learn to do it" book
are clear reasons why nobody wants to be caught dead viewing desi soaps!
To ME KT's television prefrences make sense for the first time🤣 I wouldnt want to have been anywhere near a TV set playing RBO in Nov!
aditee thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: -Nitya-

I understand your opinion, I think the track is rather silly as well..but one thing I don't get is..why are you bringing the actor into this? You have to understand that the actor and character are different people, with completely different personalities.😳 Mentioning KT and his opinions doesn't even relate to your topic..come on, please don't bring the actors into this. They actually visit the forum..criticizing the characters and the show is fine, but not the actors(unless its on their acting.)

and about the topic..I don't see why Shaan is using a book to express his thoughts as well. I guess it's all just to give a show a comic touch due to all of the divorce seriousness that's going on right now..I haven't been looking too much into the track so can't really say anything more.
I'm pretty sure the track ended with yesterday's episode..so it's back to normal now. (:

I dont quite get that! Once they sign up for public life, shouldnt actors have the guts to face all sorts of criticism?
Unless IF is a place only for bouqets and NO brickbats because we love the fact that KT is so handsome!Embarrassed and couldnt imagine seeing a frown on that handsome face............
I havent in my life met a celebrity who does not like media attention, if they did not they would not be giving interviews to all and sundry media sources, they would be like you or I, lead a life of anonymity😕
isomers thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: aditee

I dont quite get that! Once they sign up for public life, shouldnt actors have the guts to face all sorts of criticism?



yes, criticism is greatly accepted when it's on the ACTOR and his acting skills, looks, anything. Connecting a fictional character from a show to the actor is different.😳 The actor just plays the role..


The_May_Rose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#24

I think the book track was actually quite funny....But you are entitled your opinion Adite...After laughing my heart out at Shaan's burthalness ie taking the book to the kitchen of all places😆.....I realised it bought up a really interesting and serious issue, with comedy.....

Those of us who live in the west are not consious about these subjects, as Khanak would be....I am not saying this because she is less educated....But you confidence in these matters depends on life experience, school education and what your parents are comfortable explaining😆.....
Perhaps the book might be helpful to ease her worries about marriage....It could be a book about the realtionship aspect as well as the obvious subject matter.....Just because Shaan is from the city doesn't mean he wouldn't feel a little consious too or he is doing this so Khanak does think it is all bad....He is wants her read the book and come to terms with everything her own way....
aditee thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: -Nitya-



yes, criticism is greatly accepted when it's on the ACTOR and his acting skills, looks, anything. Connecting a fictional character from a show to the actor is different.😳 The actor just plays the role..


Nitya,
Curious to know what your opinion is about the besharmi thread fantasies?
These are two actual flesh and blood human beings essaying the roles of "Shanak" if you were to pause and think about it for a minute.
Have you ever worried what KT and YM may think of the "Besharmi" (hoping its what it says) thread?
Did you happen to address it with the people participating?
Imagining an "actor" making love (read creepy) with his costar all in the name of "acting" does not pass muster for me.
Your concern for their privacy should be all encompassing, not just restricted to ONE member's opinion of KT's PUBLIC statements.
Thank you
Edited by aditee - 14 years ago
garfield1209 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: The_May_Rose

I think the book track was actually quite funny....But you are entitled your opinion Adite...After laughing my heart out at Shaan's burthalness ie taking the book to the kitchen of all places😆.....I realised it bought up a really interesting and serious issue, with comedy.....

Those of us who live in the west are not consious about these subjects, as Khanak would be....I am not saying this because she is less educated....But you confidence in these matters depends on life experience, school education and what your parents are comfortable explaining😆.....
Perhaps the book might be helpful to ease her worries about marriage....It could be a book about the realtionship aspect as well as the obvious subject matter.....Just because Shaan is from the city doesn't mean he wouldn't feel a little consious too or he is doing this so Khanak does think it is all bad....He is wants her read the book and come to terms with everything her own way....

Ditto you May ...You just saved me lot of tying 😆😆 ..
@Bold - Loved it
But I love rambling so I would add some more ...If there was her mom or gopi she would have comfortably discussed these stuff ..Shaan is now mother ,dad, friend for Khanak along with being a hubby ......So he just tries to do what a situation demands but ways are burthal at times ..
Later the gesture of getting her flowers , bangles and that ring was so sweet and romantic ...😳
isomers thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#27
^^ If you notice..I do not participate in any of those threads. I actually don't even know what's IN the thread. 😳
The_May_Rose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: priya1209

Ditto you May ...You just saved me lot of tying 😆😆 ..
@Bold - Loved it
But I love rambling so I would add some more ...If there was her mom or gopi she would have comfortably discussed these stuff ..Shaan is now mother ,dad, friend for Khanak along with being a hubby ......So he just tries to do what a situation demands but ways are burthal at times ..
Later the gesture of getting her flowers , bangles and that ring was so sweet and romantic ...😳

Loved you post too Priya😃.....Exactly, Shaan lets the book do explain the difficult issues....
Then does what he knows best....Romance, flowers and gifts....
aditee thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: -Nitya-

^^ If you notice..I do not participate in any of those threads. I actually don't even know what's IN the thread. 😳

Thanks Nitya I really appreciate your honest reply!
I apologize for directing that logic at you then..........
Makes me feel better! :-)
For a while there I was upset about upsetting you in due course of this debate.
Thk u
ssharmas thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#30
What does having an MBA degree have to do with making a MOVE? I have an MBA and I don't remember being taught about how to make a move in a relationship in the MBA program. My five year old kindergartner uses the word DUDE several times in a day..I am not sure what you are trying to imply..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".