Originally posted by: mahimn
As per the Ramayana that we read Brahma granted Ravana Lanka apart from the boon of invincibility.
Valmiki Ramayan says that Ravan took Lanka from Kuber. Ravan got Lanka from Kuber. This means Kuber had Lanka before Ravan got it.
Here is what Valmiki Ramayan, Uttar Kand says about Vaishravan i.e. Kuber.:-
Vaishravan gave himself up to asceticism in great forest and practising severe austerities, performed heavy penances, whereupon the mighty Brahma, accompanied by the hosts of the gods and their leaders, came to the hermitage and said to him:
"I am highly gratified with your accomplishments, O devoted son, now choose a boon! May prosperity attend you; you do merit a favour , O Sage!"
Then Vaishravan answered the grandsire of the world (Brahma), who stood near and said:
"O Blessed One, I desire to be the saviour and protector of the world!"
In the satisfaction of his soul, Brahma, who was accompanied by the celestials, joyfully answered:
"So be it! It is my desire to create four guardians of the Worlds. Now there shall be the region of the Yama, the region of Indra, the region of Varuna and the one sought by you. Go, O virtuous ascetic, and reign over the dominion of wealth! With Shakra, Varuna the lord of the waters, and Yama (lord of death), you shall be the fourth. Receive as your vehicle this chariot named Pushpaka, which is as bright as the sun, and be equal to the gods. Be happy. We shall now return from whence we came, having accomplished that which we had to do by conferring this gift, O dear son!"
With these words, Brahma withdrew to the region of the gods and when the celestials, with the grandsire at their head, had gone to the heavenly region, Vaishravan, having become the Lord of Wealth, humbly addressed his sire with joined palms and said:
"O Blessed One, I have received a rare boon from the grandsire of the World, but the divine Prajapati (Brahma) has not assigned me a dwelling place. Do you therefore counsel me, O Blessed One, O lord, as to where an agreeable retreat may be found where no suffering comes to any living being."
At these words of his son Vaishravan, the foremost of the ascetics answered saying:
"Hear, O most virtuous of men! On the shores of the ocean, in the south there is a mountain named Trikuta. On its lofty summit, which as great as the capital of the mighty Indra, the Ravishing city of Lanka was constructed by Vishvakarma for the Rakshasas and it resembles Amravati (capital city of Indra, the king of heaven). Do you dwell in Lanka and be happy! Do not hesitate! With its moats, golden walls, engines of war and the weapons with which it is filled, with its gold and emerald archways, that city is a marvel! The Rakshasas left it formerly in fear of Vishnu and it is deserted, all the demons having gone to the nethermost region. Now Lanka is empty and has no protector. Go and inhabit it , my Son, and be happy!"
So, as you can see, Valmiki Ramayan says that Vaisravan(Kuber) ruled in Lanka as suggested by his father. It also says that Vishwakarma built Lanka for rakshasas. However, if some story says that Brahma granted Ravan boon that one day in future he would get Lanka, then it is fine and does not contradict Valmiki Ramayan.
As per Sunderkand Lankini was send on Earth by Brahma to protect Lanka and was told that the day you are defeated by a monkey (vaanar/Kapi), take it as a sign of Ravana's destruction and death.It is so difficult to find out which one to trust.
Yes, it is written in Ramayan that Ravan's destruction had to take place if a monkey defeated Lankini. But Ravan took Lanka from Kuber.
Edited by akhl - 18 years ago