Questions after sept 9 epi - Page 4

awesome post

I too have the same questions Sangeeta and the answer is, the PH is indeed focusing on the upcoming twist that they happily forgot all the other things... The biggest blooper was Najma being elder to Nikhat... As far as I remember, Shireen did mention Ayaan and Humeira's age as 22 and 20 respectively in one of the episodes (When Ayaan saved Humeira from that chat guy)... Humeira is younger than Nikhat, so Nikhat is probably 21... And Rashid left Dilshad and kids on Najma's first Birthday, which was 17 years ago... So Najma should be 18 😕... I don't get the logic here... All the other questions which you put forward in your posts are illogical too, including Zoya riding a scooty...

Originally posted by: bheegi

Hi guys

Just watched the epi from last night. The PH really wants to rub the maburt track like salt on a wound. Why else would they ruin a potentially good episode?

Bang on target, Sangeeta! I could barely make myself watch the episode today. The writers have completely lost it. I still don't get how Maburt can happen in 2 days!

One point to note is that BB can now communicate. So, if Zoya's parentage comes out in her presence (she supposedly will attend the Nikaah), she may blurt out the gudiya factory raaz. She does know that the woman who died was the mother of Ghafoor's child who was then packed off to the orphanage. As Zoya was instrumental in "saving" BB at the Eid function, will BB pay her back with her Mom's truth? Will that truth kill Humeira, who cannot take any stress? Will that set off Ayaan? I think the promo was symbolic to future tussles. Zoyaan at this stage is absolutely baffling. They can't even marry each other by mistake due to Islamic marriage rules! Lets see how it unfolds.

I have a few questions after today's epi:

1. If the romantic dance number was just supposed to be a 1 minute twirl and embrace, why did they hype it so much? Why did they leave the cuhsions on the floor if they were not intending to do or show anything more than a mini dance lesson?

Can't believe they called that "blink and you'll miss it" scene a romantic dance!! TellyBytes had a better video!! Very disappointed. AsYa are hormonally and emotionally challenged. A couple in love and about to get married (for the 3rd time, if I may add. Not that anyone on this forum has forgotten) doesn't even share a cheek or forehead kiss? Why can't they talk about future plans, their past experiences, college etc.?

2. Since when did Najma become older than Nikhat?

This one has always baffled us. The entire age thingy is completely illogical. I went and watched a few old episodes as this was bothering me a lot!!😆 Yeah, I am like the dog with a bone about this age thing!! The writers have already contradicted themselves!

As we know Dilshaad mentioned that Rashid left them 17 years ago a day after Najma's 1st bday! In the show, it can't be more than 4 months (gauged by Tanveer's pregnancy: 3 months when kicked out of KV. Add 1 month graciously) and it adds up to Najma not being more that 19!

However, in the Jan 11th and 14th episodes, Najma told something slight different to Zoya:

Asad was 7 when Shirin left Rashid who brought a 2 to 2 1/2 year old Ayaan to live with them. Dilshad was heavily pregnant. Ayaan stayed with them for 2 to 3 yrs before Rashid took Ayaan away. (this was 17yrs ago!) so based on this:

Asad is 7 + 3 + 17 + 1 (max and very generous of us to account for time already elapsed on the show!!) = 27 or 28,

Ayaan is 2 1/15 + 3 + 17 + 1= 24

Najma is 2 or 3 + 17 + 1= 21

Zoya is 3 + 17 + 1= 21

Unless Shireen was pregnant or already had Nikhat, Najma is older than Nikhat. Question is how old is everyone and why are they hell bent on getting married so young: child marriage?!

3. When did Zoya acquire a scooter? If she has had one all along, why didn't she use it to visit Dhoni? Or has this been gifted in dahej by Aapi (from America?)

No clue!! Aapi who?? Maybe Rajveer gifted it to her. Or Mr. Khan is being cheap and bought that instead of a car and the hell with her security!

4. What was the point of that argument between AsYa today? What purpose did it serve today? We all know they will continue to fight like Tom and Jerry, married or not married.

Absolutely pointless and juvenile! Just a reason to get Asad to talk about his 5th wish (what happened to the 4th wish? 😕).

5. Why were both AsYa so callous about their upcoming nikaah the next day? When Dilshaad asked Asad if he is happy, he just kinda replied 'whatever' - there was no enthusiasm at all. Zoya was busy fighting and asking him his wishes as if she were doing a favor to him. I thought they are not supposed to see each other the day before their nikaah.

The actors know of the separation track and have lost interest too?!

6. Why was Najma distributing wedding cards at SM if Dilshaad wanted a small and secret affair this time? Seems like it's another big affair.

Don't you know the MIL funda: all bets are off when it comes to your laadli daughter! AsYa wedding is a secret one not Najma's!! 😆 They'll pretend no one noticed! Based on the BTS, it looks like its at the KV itself!!

Now, if Nikhat is marrying Farhan, don't the SM folks have to attend their sambdhan's other son's wedding?! Surprised that HB didn't insist on the 3rd marriage the same day!!

7. The question of the day: Why didn't Zoya tell anyone about Tanveer's presence in their house? Zoya knows Tanveer well and also knows that if she visited them on Najma's engagement, she has some grand plan up her sleeve.

That is the million dollar question!! She positively identified Tanveer. She's not sure of Imran's intentions or involvement but made a positive ID. She should have told the members of KV!

Can I say that the writers and PH have become too focused on their upcoming Maburt track, that are losing it completely?

Sad but true! Can I add a few.

1. Where are Aapi and Jiju?? If they are not coming, no phone calls either?
2. If Nikaah is the next day, when are the brides getting mehendi and why are they roaming around?!
3. Asad told Zoya to tell him before she goes out. Yet again she's wandering off on her own! Where did she go?
4. Can't Zoya call Rashid and invite him over for the nikaah! Ask him to get a gift too, so Asad's wish can come true!

Some more questions: 😃

one more question to add to your list

Logical questions bheegi... but we cant expect any logical answers from QH now...

Originally posted by: bheegi

Can I say that the writers and PH have become too focused on their upcoming Maburt track, that are losing it completely?

Originally posted by: bheegi

Thanks for all your comments and questions. Sorry, won't be able to reply to each separately as I am out of town.

Looks like a number of us are frustrated with the current state of affairs in QH

I don't care what twists they have in mind but I just want consistency in the script, acting and characterization. Right now, the direction is also quite poor. Apparently, another director (from Arjun) is direcing the episodes.

Hope Gul will justify the Maburt track in a logical manner. Just read the TOI article- are they going to be forced into a marriage at gunpoint? I can't see Zoya saying QH to anyone but Asad unless someone else's life is threatened (not even hers)- like asad, dilshaad etc.

If they are planning a SR kind of illusion (Tanveer taking photos) then both Ayan and Zoya just have to tell everyone that nothing happened. It's not like a drugged SR scenario.

Gul- I have high hopes from your story telling skills. Please don't disappoint us otherwise, Mahabharat is starting next week. I might just switch gears if Maburt doesn't sound convincing.

.
Totaly agree with u di. I m also waiting for mahabharat and my favorite characters arjun and karna. Hope gul not disappoint us.

BTW when are u give update of Fassale. I m waiting. Ab wohi ek sahara hai.

Originally posted by: AAK0007

.
Totaly agree with u di. I m also waiting for mahabharat and my favorite characters arjun and karna. Hope gul not disappoint us.

BTW when are u give update of Fassale. I m waiting. Ab wohi ek sahara hai.