AsYa & Teacher : One of the best scenes ever on QH. - Page 9

Originally posted by: rishika21

u said that no body tells a 9 yr old such shite.so u r talking abt real life right?

btw maine sirf kaha ki aisa sach mein hota hai aapse koi misbehave nahin kiya.itna bura kyun maan gaye aap.bura laga ho to sorry waise bhi iam going now.

Originally posted by: Madame_Noddy

sau takey ki baat ki hai aapne Vicky madam! I loved that scene to the core! The way the teacher described asd... So cuutteee!! I wish i cud meet that asad! It was so beutifully planned and executed! And it reminded me of my bengali teacher of my ex-school whom i was really close to... And i had a smile chipkaoed on my face throughout the scene! And your description of the scene made it all the more beautiful! Thank you!

Originally posted by: MisHumptyDumpty

Awwhhh Del come let me hug you 🤗

i get the point now why you are getting so angered 😆

Buti feel he was angry, hence he proved himself to be such a successful insan and went on to show her ki see you said i wont have anybody but today I have the SUNSHINE with me, for forever and ages and lives to come 😊

Originally posted by: ChamakChallo91

Awesome post! Beautifully written!

I loved that scene so much!!

Originally posted by: MisHumptyDumpty

@del - my teachers have hurt me soo very much, i still remember them fondly for scolding me as what i am now is all cause of them, is that my bad or their good luck? 😆

School is a second home to a child, and i agree some teachers go really too overboard, but they are teachers at the end of the day, you are what now all cause of them.

And as far as i know, The teacher saying 'Proving the teacher wrong is the biggest of all compliments' proves he had COME to PROVE her which she had not expected. He didn't remember her fondly 😆

Originally posted by: Jayne

I think how you described the scene imbued it with poetic connections and deep symbolism. I am certain the PH wanted it to be seen that way, so in that sense, I suppose they achieved what they set out to do.

However, I am perhaps one of those strange people who look for logic. (What, in an Indian soap? Am I Nuts?!!!).
10 years old is too young for comments by teachers about finding or not finding life-partners.
It is not an age to form any such deep impact on memories, other than momentous occasions or incidents.
One could argue that for Mr. Khan this was a momentous incident, but again, he would have been too young to think about his own wedding/bride, etc.
At that time all the fiasco with his parents was taking place, and would have had - and did! - a much deeper impact.

I am not too far from my own10 year-old self, and I can say that at no time were the opposite-sex on my mind in any shape or form except as play mates; and teachers certainly did not comment on a child's serious demeanor and behavior with predictions of future mate or lack thereof.

However, as I mentioned before, your interpretation certainly puts a very romantic, and thought-provoking lens on the scene, as I am sure the PH intended.

Jayne

Originally posted by: delena90

There is a difference between scolding a child and making a personal remark about a child. To say that a child will never find love or marry is a very unnecessary statement.

Asad should never have had to prove his personal life to a teacher. If she had called him an idiot and said he would never be successful and he had come back with his company and barrels of money to show for his name that would have been different. But what was said to Asad was akin to a teacher telling a child that you are not pretty so no one will marry you (for girls).

@red - I'll take your interpretation 😛😆