AsYa & Ammie: Ek thappad ki ye goonj. - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

110

Views

8.2k

Users

36

Likes

239

Frequent Posters

MoronsKiMallika thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: LoveRosh

Wow, I adored your analysis! All of it was well said, I completely agree with it.


And one thing I want to add is to anyone stating how wrong asad was.. I want to remind them about what GOOD asad has done.

I mean has one "Slap" downgraded him to such an extent that all of the 50 gajillion times he SAVED Zoya has gone down the drain? We have all seen how much he cares for her and we have all seen the extent at which he would go to SAVE her from harm.

In this moment of anguish and hurt and pain seeing his MOTHER in such a AWEFUL condition, he reacted by slapping the person he found GUILTY of her condition.

Anyways... nough slap talk LMFAoo..

I think the highlight of the day was Asad and Tamaataar! And the fact that ASad WENT to Rashid =| i was super shocked! I thought he may call aayan or maybe just by phone tell him..but he actually made the effort and WENT to the one person he HATES most .. and Im proud of him for that!



Thanks Rosh, Yes, its actually darkly funny how easily we forget the goodness and heroism of good people and only remember their anger.Compartmentalized judgment, much? Maybe. Its human nature to do that and this forum is just a trailor of the same.

I don't think of cross words and redemption theories for Asad at this point. He doesn't need judgment , just like Zoe never did it. They both were always flawed people with flawless hearts and that has not changed.

Anyway, i also loved Asad and Tamaatar's scene - both the actors brought out the emotion really well. And Asad going to Rashid was his honour-of-sentiment for his mother. Touching. 😊
jasw thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#62
Lovely post, Victoria! I guess everyone has their own opinion. For me, when I put myself in Asad's position, I think I too would have reacted like him. Zoya had not taken his worries seriously, otherwise she would have informed Asad that Marium is back home courtesy his mom. Asad could have taken some measures. I don't understand why man-woman, domestic violence etc. angles are cropping up in this scenario. Just imagine the most important person is hanging between life and death and the culprit(according to Asad) whose negligence caused it, is standing in front mumbling I'm sorry, which won't bring a person from death. What would be your reaction?
MoronsKiMallika thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: JPRules

Thank god for your post! I read so many threads about everyone being outraged and disappointed and appalled about Asad's 'man-hitting-a-woman' slap behavior that I was left wondering "what is wrong with me? why aren't I feeling the same?" Lol.
And then I come across yours! 🤗


Thanks JP.🤗...Oh, i also learned new hate words and swear words from the forum last night.🤣...'man-hitting-woman' is running like a ghisaa-pittaa record in my head now and no Disprin is helping. 🤔😆


For some reason I'm not angry about this scene. I don't know why cuz I'm quite a feminist, I'm always getting into arguments with people over women's issues. Maybe it was the circumstances of the slap that suppressed my rage? I can't put a finger on it. Asad is sooo not right and it was not okay to slap Zoya (it never will be) but it was after all a natural instinctive reaction. To him, his mother, his world, his lifeline is dying because of Zoya and her lies. If it was my mother I'd be going beserk. Who wouldn't want to hurt the person responsible for their mother's (or someone they love deeply) traumatic condition? Basic instinct says to go for it, and although we are fully capable of controlling it, there are times we cannot. We do all sorts of things in pain and anger... sometimes things that are drastic that lead to even more drastic effects, for which we go on to regret the rest of our lives. Asad is no different. He failed to control his rage by slapping Zoya. It's not ever justifiable or acceptable, but it is understandable. And for that I cannot be outraged at his behavior. I guess I was looking at the context rather than just his act.

That is what the whole situation was about, right? Circumstances. Emotional rage. Trauma vent. Its a human thing and not a man-woman thing. You cannot justify it under any sugar coated words and you cannot define it on the lines of right and wrong. Sometimes, things happen and we do things that is not 'us' - we fall victim to an overpowering situation. Asad was in that boat and he capsized it on Zoe - because he was traumatized and because he does not know the truth.

My heart surely broke again for Zoya. That poor poor soul!! I just want to go over there and give her the biggest bear hug known in existence!

Me tooo! A girl on whom her Aapi and Jiju have never raised their voices, who is a pampered princess gets SLAPPED by a man who is not even related to her. She was like a shaken child but i have a feeling that at the back of her head she understood where that slap came from.

Asad's punishment for this is not going to be silly little things like burning his hand, etc... It's going to be losing Zoya. He is going to lose her to his own brother. That's what this incident is leading up to. The foundations are being laid. Zoya and Ayaan are going to meet real soon. Asad will pay for everything he has done to that poor girl (always mistreating her, misunderstanding her, judging her, hurting her - physically, mentally, and emotionally) by losing her, the love of his life. The slap was the push. Zoya will become Ayaan's until Asad realizes her true value. Then he will have to fall to her feet and grovel.
THAT'S his punishment and his redemption.

Perhaps. I don't rule out self-harm in Asad's case as he basically has a tendency towards emotional rage. In case, Zoe alienates herself from Asad after this slap, then, what you are saying may happen. In case Zoe understands Asad's situation and he collapses in guilt , then, it may be a different ball game altogether.

On a more immediate level I'm crazy curious to see Zoya's reaction to his slap. How will she behave around him now? Will she forgive and forget easily (I sure hope not!)? We know Asad will regret it the instant he hears the truth. His emotional turmoil will skyrocket through the roof!

Ok rant over. Jeeezzz how did this post get so freakishly long!! 😕

Zoe is a soft mushroom inside and if she sees Asad's agony , she may let the slap pass- if she only remembers the hurt, she may not . Lets see how this plays out and i loved your rant!🤗

MoronsKiMallika thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: jasw

Lovely post, Victoria! I guess everyone has their own opinion. For me, when I put myself in Asad's position, I think I too would have reacted like him. Zoya had not taken his worries seriously, otherwise she would have informed Asad that Marium is back home courtesy his mom. Asad could have taken some measures. I don't understand why man-woman, domestic violence etc. angles are cropping up in this scenario. Just imagine the most important person is hanging between life and death and the culprit(according to Asad) whose negligence caused it, is standing in front mumbling I'm sorry, which won't bring a person from death. What would be your reaction?


Thanks Jas. Yep, everyone has an opinion as per their grey matter, behavioural pattern and set reaction to emotional and psychological stimuli, so i guess we leave it at that.

What you are saying is true. Asad REACTED. Its not a man-woman thing , a pseudo- domestic violence issue and all that jazz. Its an emotional rage reaction towards Zoe who Asad doesn't know is innocent in the current matter. Its a lot of triggers adding upto a saturation of patience and an emotional cloudburst. Its Asad's mother in the ICU and Asad does not know the truth. Why can't we allow him to be a man next door who can falter?
CutielovesChocs thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#66
Vicky jee, tussi toh chaa gaye! 😆

Brilliant post! 😃
MoronsKiMallika thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#67

Originally posted by: CutielovesChocs

Vicky jee, tussi toh chaa gaye! 😆


Brilliant post! 😃


Aur aap yahaan aa gaye!🤗...which planet are you living on these days, mushroom?😳
jasw thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: VictoriaHot


Thanks Jas. Yep, everyone has an opinion as per their grey matter, behavioural pattern and set reaction to emotional and psychological stimuli, so i guess we leave it at that.

What you are saying is true. Asad REACTED. Its not a man-woman thing , a pseudo- domestic violence issue and all that jazz. Its an emotional rage reaction towards Zoe who Asad doesn't know is innocent in the current matter. Its a lot of triggers adding upto a saturation of patience and an emotional cloudburst. Its Asad's mother in the ICU and Asad does not know the truth. Why can't we allow him to be a man next door who can falter?


It is definitely a reaction. He did not seek her out. Infact he was trying his best to avoid her. Zoya seek him out because she could not see him in despair but the timing was oh so wrong!

Edited by jasw - 12 years ago
-DavneetKaur- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#69
finally a post which makes sense and which is actually very truly justified..you know i felt the same..not saying much about what happened in the show..it was a situational reaction where a person is on the verge of losing his most precious thing and you direct your anger towards the person due to whom it happened...anyways good post..brilliant
NainaAlex thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#70
Loved your post...
From the time the news of the thappar came on SBS I was hoping it was wrong...I was sure I couldn't digest it...
But when the scene actually came I was shocked though I was half expecting it...though it was a shocker but I must say the scene was executed superbly...
true, violence is unacceptable in any form...but life is never pertfect...
and when a person is completely devastated and the person you think is responsible for that is in front of you...I don't think anyone can think straight at that time...
Anyway I just hope the CVs don't drag the MU for a long time...

Related Topics

Qubool Hai thumbnail

Posted by: desidillse · 1 years ago

[NOCOPY] Hello everyone! Happy to be here. I was searching for an opportunity to be here with all of you as a member after a long time as writer...

Expand ▼
Qubool Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Coloursoflove · 2 years ago

*New chapter updated* Asya FF: Rendezvous with Honor

Asya FF: Rendezvous with Honor Asad Ahmed Khan is the prodigal son. All the tabloids say so. Coming from an affluent family in Bhopal, he's done...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".