TB article: Preet & Ishan to die - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

5.3k

Users

17

Likes

216

Frequent Posters

pinkeye thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: Exoctica



We can't do anything... The story is in the writer's hands. But I wanted a happy ending not just because rizreet should live happily but I also feel that if riz dies, it's in a way Baba's win, although Riz will foil his plan and save many lives. But still Riz will lose his life and so will Preet. Their presence in Kavyas life can never be replaced. IMO these two meant more for Kavya than did her other family members even though they are her actual blood relations. In my opinion it would have made more sense to show riz going to jail, and then come back and live happily. If Preet can die with him (definitely means she forgives him), she can live with him too after knowing his back story. One cannot help but think had Sana told Riz the truth much earlier that his parents were not killed by Baba, things would have been SO different. But again this is a fictional story with many ifs and buts. We have to accept whatever the writer decides.

This is just my POV. No offense meant 😊



No offence taken either. We still dont know what eill be fate of Baba and his gang. Hope they get punished for their deeds too.

Coming to preet's forgiveness, even if rizwan stays alive and Preet forgives him knowing his back story, why shoukd she stay in the relatinship with the man who betrayed her , deceived her so that his cover remain intact? Trust once broken so harshly can never goes back to its original form. Its like that broken mirror which shiws the crack till it lasts. So when the most important factor on which Preet thought she built her rishta will get shattered, she will not be the same person any more. Even if she dies forgive Rizwan so that he gers relieved from his guilt, and gies to jail, why should a woman wait for that man who offered her betrayal in return to her pure devotion? Because she loves him and Rizwan has a golden heart? Isnt that disrespecting yoyr own existence by allowing another one to take complete control over your senses? Maafi ke baad bhi saath rehna zaroori nahi hai shayad. Yes she can forgive him and start afresh. Disloyalty, betrayal should not get negated by Love in practical dynamics of a relationship imo.

Now coming to Preet embracing death for Rizwan, the scene is yet to play out. But evrn if thats the case, I will take it as impulsive, momentary expression fro, a very emotional Preet who cant imagine her lufe wothout her beloved. A situation when she foes not get the chance to weigh /assess her emotions, how those got abused. Its Love and pasdion taking over, that cam be a short term, adrenalin rush reaction but cant be a long term response. Love cannot outweigh every other aspect, facet of a marriage.

I dont see a sensible woman protagonist after weighing all sides of coin ending up with a man who cheated her, who showed utter indifference to her feelings and eventually refused to acknowledge her love along with having criminal records. It jus does not look fathomable for me. No offence meant either, just my pov . On this we are on different pages and never going to conclude alike I suppose.But as in literary terms we say Love should get its chance, for that happy ending does sound perfect.
Edited by pinkeye - 9 years ago
Ms.SK thumbnail
Deal or No Deal Thumbnail Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#52
knowing the PH, rizwan till end will not know that baba had brain wahsed him and he was the one who had killed his family
Danseuse thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#53

It's best to leave the writers to tell their story. I don't believe any of these online articles, as most of the time, it's a fiction of the writers imagination. But, this ending can happen, and the question remains, why is it necessary to kill both the leads? Does dying reflect love so encompassing that one can't live without the other? Preet has been a mother and a good friend of Ishaan while Ishaan has also been a good dad and friend. Their love for each other is based on trust and mutual respect.

For both of them to die, it means that Preet finds out Ishaan's true identity. Or Rizwaan reveals it to Preet. There could also be a scene where both bump into each other (like the music concert shown before). Now, we can see the relationship taking a new turn, so let's wait and watch. 😊

For me, as a viewer, I am glad I watched this show from the beginning and discovered a powerhouse of talent by the name of Iqbal Khan. Mona Singh has always impressed me from her Jassi days. Whatever happens in the end, I am gonna watch. But I feel the story has been trimmed to meet the reduced no of episodes. That's a sad feeling!! 😕



-Rekha
1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: Danseuse


It's best to leave the writers to tell their story. I don't believe any of these online articles, as most of the time, it's a fiction of the writers imagination. But, this ending can happen, and the question remains, why is it necessary to kill both the leads? Does dying reflect love so encompassing that one can't live without the other? Preet has been a mother and a good friend of Ishaan while Ishaan has also been a good dad and friend. Their love for each other is based on trust and mutual respect.

For both of them to die, it means that Preet finds out Ishaan's true identity. Or Rizwaan reveals it to Preet. There could also be a scene where both bump into each other (like the music concert shown before). Now, we can see the relationship taking a new turn, so let's wait and watch. 😊

For me, as a viewer, I am glad I watched this show from the beginning and discovered a powerhouse of talent by the name of Iqbal Khan. Mona Singh has always impressed me from her Jassi days. Whatever happens in the end, I am gonna watch. But I feel the story has been trimmed to meet the reduced no of episodes. That's a sad feeling!! 😕



-Rekha


Well...even If we had a 6 months course for the Serial...
I would have still expected a Sad Ending...😔

Ab Malaal toh is baat ka rahegaa...that Preet's Emottions , Dilemma , Pain...never got its Due...
And even if we have got 1 week extension..It seems they are in no mood...to explore that...


jakr thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#55
I am too sad not because of the sad ending but more because of the sudden ending. Wonder such a great show with a diffenrent concept and great performances got such treatment and dying a prematured death.
Any way I wish all the best to my hero Iqbal. Hope his next give him all the success . He is the best actor as on today.
Rizreet has a special place in my heart . Theirs was a true love story and amatured believable one.
Wisll miss pkhjd and this forum.
Exoctica thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: RollingStones


Well...even If we had a 6 months course for the Serial...
I would have still expected a Sad Ending...😔

Ab Malaal toh is baat ka rahegaa...that Preet's Emottions , Dilemma , Pain...never got its Due...
And even if we have got 1 week extension..It seems they are in no mood...to explore that...



I'm not sure whether the ending would have been tragic if the show had run for 6M. The reason I'm saying this is because Riz would have definitely stopped the 26th Jan attacks. He would not have died in these attacks at least because obviously the rest of the time would have gone in Preet's dilemma and Riz's redemption. He might have been jailed for a while, but not sure if he would have died. Oh well...we'll never know the original story now😕
Hotcocoa thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#57
Sad...sad news! 😭
Cvs Not Happy 😡
Mehek25 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#58
I agree that a happy ending would have been great. But for this story it would.not have been appropriate. After all Rizwan is a foreign country's agent (I don't like the word terrorist). Even if he were to admit he was wrong and feel guilty or wanted to redeem himself, it would not have been possible or even logical. Had this been a lo.her running show they could have shown him helping India and become aole in his country. But for him there's no other probable end. Reminds me of the Sharukh-Manisha starrer Dil Se.
Preet of course won't b able to live without him so her death is also justifiable.

Just sad that it had to end so soon..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".