PKD Episode analysis - 18 Dec '12 - Page 5

Originally posted by: shesherkobita

Shathi & Zu... you guys were the lifeline on this forum for me 😭... I got my daily heckling fix from you... you had the guts to face the pelting tomatoes... i love you for that...

No one writes any good analysis on any other show... the overbearing mods close them !!! It's the weirdest aspect of India Forum...unconditional loyalty... the way it is expected in political parties in the subcontinent... the mods have been with you on this thread...which was such a relief... If you guys leave I'll probably wean off slowly too... but please don't stay bcos of me... health issues (and time difference) keep me from participating as much as I would like to also. I am glad you are my buddy on this forum.

Sabi, I loved all your thoughts... if you got something out of us.. we did too...

The episode: I am sooo glad Adi realized his love... I would've rejoiced even if the CVs showed an Alien Landing and probing Adi to realize his love... It felt like a pregnancy that was supposed to last 9 months but instead lasted 15 months!

🤣 alien probing... well, they would have had to stoop to that if the moron had not realized it now

Best part of the epi : Adi at the temple..."you better make everything alright.. she believes in you and it's her right to get help from you" or something in that line... Hay that's exactly how I pray!

(less said about the Jhap part the better.. but it seems to be the norm in serials... temple jhap or darga chants)

have heard that dialogue too often to be moved..

OTT realization ... yes it was totally filmy ... but I think with so much anticipatory build-up about " how & why" regarding Adi's realization ... CVs had to come up with something OTT... instead of using something realistic they went for the "tried & tested" serial formula. Another member (Elgee) wrote "instead of hitting Adi on the head; they hit Pankhuri on the head"🤣

🤣 never thought of that.. and me who had begging for Adi to be hit on the head

if there is no Kullu track in near future... i am out... love you guys ... I'lll keep checking to see if you post anything... big fan of your analysis...

well, near future is the damn party track right???

Originally posted by: Shell16

Hi Shanthi, I tried to resist but was hoping that you would post because my thoughts needed an outlet.

I was so into the hospital drama that could fathom what happened next. It was great until Adi hears that Pankhuri isn't doing well and starts to leave the hospital. The most logical place for him to go next was her ICU room and hold her hand and comfort her...screw the shart and such nonsense. Husbands are allowed in ICU rooms and the recovering patients need and want their loved ones near. Not off at some random temple conducting pooja. What the "HE 2 hockey sticks" was that? It wasn't even Ramji??? As spiritual as you are...God and chants and Havan don't save people's lives...good medical care does. What kind of prehistoric logic was that? As a wife you need your husband near you not off doing pooja...especially a guy like Adi. It would have been more believable for him to not want leave her bedside for days without eating or drinking or sleeping. That would have conveyed his feelings and after she is better he could have done some soul searching to examine his feelings and behavour. Not running around Mumbai and dancing on rooftops (sorry Sabrina) If your loved one is in danger of dying you should be thinking of them not your own feelings.

God what a horrible mess! Don't get me wrong Nakuul and actor playing HArish did an amazing job but it was illogical and did fit with the story.

I hope they fix this before this show too goes to the dogs.

Shelly

Originally posted by: Shell16

It seems like a show's self life is always about six months...without fail they go to the dogs at about the six month mark. I always hope they can capture magic again but have never seen it happen.

Oh well.

Originally posted by: Shell16

Hi Shanthi, I tried to resist but was hoping that you would post because my thoughts needed an outlet.

I was so into the hospital drama that could fathom what happened next. It was great until Adi hears that Pankhuri isn't doing well and starts to leave the hospital. The most logical place for him to go next was her ICU room and hold her hand and comfort her...screw the shart and such nonsense. Husbands are allowed in ICU rooms and the recovering patients need and want their loved ones near. Not off at some random temple conducting pooja. What the "HE 2 hockey sticks" was that? It wasn't even Ramji??? As spiritual as you are...God and chants and Havan don't save people's lives...good medical care does. What kind of prehistoric logic was that? As a wife you need your husband near you not off doing pooja...especially a guy like Adi. It would have been more believable for him to not want leave her bedside for days without eating or drinking or sleeping. That would have conveyed his feelings and after she is better he could have done some soul searching to examine his feelings and behavour. Not running around Mumbai and dancing on rooftops (sorry Sabrina) If your loved one is in danger of dying you should be thinking of them not your own feelings.

God what a horrible mess! Don't get me wrong Nakuul and actor playing HArish did an amazing job but it was illogical and did fit with the story.

I hope they fix this before this show too goes to the dogs.

Shelly

Originally posted by: shesherkobita