Look at how he is dealing Panchi...
And I am sure if he became a bad guy for Maithlii, he would have turned good for Pia.
Do I make sense? Well, I think I make much more sense than the current handling of the script by most popular teams of the world's largest TV industry.
Wait a minute... What I am saying? Am I liking Sid more? No, after re-thinking, I still love Abhay and so does Pia. But I am crying at the way their characters are being handled.