Arnab already knew Pia is Jaiswal - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

2.1k

Users

12

Likes

31

Frequent Posters

Posted: 14 years ago
#11
In fact, remember in the beginning of the show when Piya was arrested due to false allegation of her carrying drugs. I remember at that time too, Misha requested to Arnav to release Piya from the jail. And I remember when he went to the police station, he stated her full name to police inspector, "Piya Jaiswal." And now all of a sudden they're showing as if he never knew! 🥱
I know he didn't know her name as Piyali............but, still from the last name, "Jaiswal" he should've been curious! And how Piya also stayed in an orphanage and talked by her father leaving her and her mother...........I mean those were like very obvious hints that should've made him very curious!
Also, did you guys notice they keep changing the name of the uncle............one minute he is Pravin Jaiswal and sometimes he is Mr. Mehra! I am confused! 😕
Edited by lighteningbuzz - 14 years ago
AnamikaSJain thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#12
Arnab knew Pia as Pia Jaiswal and not Piyali Jaiswal. But what I don't understand is why did he not realize that Pia is his Piyali after hearing her conversation with Pravin Jaiswal?

Reasons
  • If Misha's Phone has to be in some one else's hand, it has to be Pia who is her close friend
  • Piya is the Scholarship Student
  • Pia is the one with surname Jaiswal
  • Abhay is the self appointed Guardian of Pia, so the mention of Abhay Raichand's interference alone should have made Arnab suspicious if not anything.
Arnab had already admitted to Madhu that he feels a bonding with Piya. And moreover, his Blood Group matches her's. Did Arnab really had to see the name of Pia in the Certificate as 'Piyali Jaiswal' to know that she is his daughter? It really does not make any sense... Anyways, Serial hai... wo be Ekta ka...So logic Bhool jaavo...
Edited by Anamika1570 - 14 years ago
Ms-Min-Ho thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#13
I agree with you if she wanted him to know that she is his daughter, she said long ago but she does not want to say she has already said Madhu her life is no place for arnav but now he knows that she is his daughter apparently it is not as happy as he was that they will do because Misha wants to throw a party about which she received a scholarship.
Edited by GuRti. - 14 years ago
remosalsa thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: RB81


s.it was arnav who said pia jaiswal.but to the doc..while he enquired abt her condition.

exactly😊, that only i remembered once, he already took her name earlier😕😕
remosalsa thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: lighteningbuzz

In fact, remember in the beginning of the show when Piya was arrested due to false allegation of her carrying drugs. I remember at that time too, Misha requested to Arnav to release Piya from the jail. And I remember when he went to the police station, he stated her full name to police inspector, "Piya Jaiswal." And now all of a sudden they're showing as if he never knew! 🥱

I know he didn't know her name as Piyali............but, still from the last name, "Jaiswal" he should've been curious! And how Piya also stayed in an orphanage and talked by her father leaving her and her mother...........I mean those were like very obvious hints that should've made him very curious!
Also, did you guys notice they keep changing the name of the uncle............one minute he is Pravin Jaiswal and sometimes he is Mr. Mehra! I am confused! 😕

yaa, exactly😃👏, during that drug time, also he had mentioned her name as Piya jaiswal only😃, that was the 1st time , whr he took her name & now all of a sudden, he is acting as if he is hearing it 1st time😆😆
remosalsa thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Anamika1570

Arnab knew Pia as Pia Jaiswal and not Piyali Jaiswal. But what I don't understand is why did he not realize that Pia is his Piyali after hearing her conversation with Pravin Jaiswal?

Reasons

    If Misha's Phone has to be in some one else's hand, it has to be Pia who is her close friend Piya is the Scholarship Student Pia is the one with surname Jaiswal
  • Abhay is the self appointed Guardian of Pia, so the mention of Abhay Raichand's interference alone should have made Arnab suspicious if not anything.
Arnab had already admitted to Madhu that he feels a bonding with Piya. And moreover, his Blood Group matches her's. Did Arnab really had to see the name of Pia in the Certificate as 'Piyali Jaiswal' to know that she is his daughter? It really does not make any sense... Anyways, Serial hai... wo be Ekta ka...So logic Bhool jaavo...

Exactly, it all should make a logic😆😆, Arnab should have guessed it...he needed that certificate only to know abt Pia😲
smile843 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#17
Arnab ki dimag ki batti sirf tabhi hi jalegi jab creatives ko chahiye ki wo jale..
so u knw.. no point in arguing why it dint strike him earlier..
for him only 2 hints were enuf.. 1. she is orphan, 2. she is piya jaiswal..

but anyways.. bloopers r an integral part of this story.. ;-D
Suneel_kumar thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Ritz93

I don't think Arnab needed to ask about Pia Jaiswal in the hospital as Kabir was already there. Arnab met Kabir before asking any hospital staff. Here is the link for the youtube episode:






😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".