Abhay: Being good can be dangerous but not bad

Ritzie thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Abhay: Being good can be dangerous but not bad'

Please don't misunderstand my intentions. I already know most of you either love Abhay or at least like him so, no complaints on this. He is named Prince Charming (or Prince Angel Super Charming) here. The only thing that seems to upset many of you is Abhay behaviour over Saturday's episode whether it was being rude to Chandeena or or to latkayofying Pia.

So, I thought I may give another angle for your thoughts so that atleast we can also see the possiblity that Abhay's reactions to either Chandeena or Pia were not impulsive but well-thought of. Makes sense? No? Let's go further then.

Chandeena first.
They share a 200 years of comradeship or staying together. Should we expect emotions? No, we are repeatedly told not to expect emotions. Should we expect understandings. Yes, atleast a bit in 200 years. That's only fair. I am not able to understand that why they couldn't see in 200 years that the beast they are looking for in Abhay, doesn't exist. It is only a lover there. And the lover in him could be understood and handled better but not controlled like they always try to do.
I guess, Pia has understood this fact in a very short span. That's why this teenager is closer to Abhay in 4 months which Chandeena couldn't in 200 years.

Is it wrong if Abhay chooses Pia's safety over his clan's safety then? Not just becuase she resembles Maithili but because she has proved to be worthy of a very good friendship. Shouldn't this fact be very visible to Chandeena after all those 200 years? Is it wrong to choose your friends safety? He always told them that he wants to save Pia's life but they never stood for him as a support in dangerous times. (I liked in Twilight how they all stood as a family when Volturi came, even Rosalie) If Chandeena are worried about their safety first over helping Abhay in trouble then it makes sense that Abhay broke the relation.


Now for Abhay's reactions for Pia:
It is very easy for Snow-white to fall in love with Prince Charming, her savior, her knight in shining armour. But it took the Beast to be on deathbed for the Beauty to accept his love. Pia still doesn't know the beastly side of Abhay and we don't know how she will accept it. Well, most of us have faith in her that she will but how, we don't know. Anyways, till then is it fair for Abhay to say his feelings out-loud? No, Abhay can't do that. Even after Pia knows about his beastly side, Abhay will fear Pia's safety before confirming his love out-loud. So, I am actually not angry with him for telling a lie to her, again. She will have to go through the litmus-test of acccepting his beastly side first. As Poco says, she has long way to go before he accepts her.
(By the way I am wishing this as a Valentine gift from BT😆)

On lighter side, Abhay ki koi nahi sunta. He repeteadly tells Pia to stay away from him and not to interfere in his personal life but she doesn't. He tells Chandena that he can't leave Pia unsafe but they don't care.



Edited by Ritz93 - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

3k

Users

15

Likes

117

Frequent Posters

kaushiki9 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
😊
very nice post again.....
very true that Pia has a long way to cover to get ABhay and accept his truth.........
In twilight Ed's family supported them bt here he is alone, may b his bro'll support him even his is said 2 b evil bt i don't c 2nd choice 4 his support.....
Chandeena wnt 2 control him
i don't think they will support him.......
Edited by kaushiki9 - 14 years ago
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Res!

-Edited-

Ritzy, you spoke my mind out. I never blamed Abhay, neither for his behaviour with Chandeena nor Pia.
I guess everyone here knows about my strong dislike for Chandeena. Yet, somewhere, I appreciated what they were doing for Abhay and hence, I never ever saw them as villains. I just saw them as grey. Nonetheless, yesterday, I could see an evil streak in both of them. Abhay told them clearly to go and tell the 'master' or whoever that they aren't responsible for him, finish! He did not want to live with them and I loved him when he said that he can fend for himself. But we saw how Chandeena wanted to control him. They want him to act like a puppet in their hands. Haseena's dialogue, "Pata nahi uss ladki mein kya hai?" I mean, seriously? Does she seriously not know what Abhay sees in Pia?? So many people in the forum say that Haseena does have a soft corner for Abhay. Maybe she does but I, so far, haven't seen any softness or tenderness from her side for Abhay except the two times she saved Abhay from Chand. And to tell you the truth, even then, it was more like she was doing him a favour. You say we shouldn't expect emotions from them and you're right. I do not expect any emotions or humanity from Chandeena and therefore, I will not point fingers or blame them for what they did to Abhay yesterday. That's their nature. That's what they are, that's what they are suppose to be: emotionless, evil monsters!
Coming to Pia, like I said in Suhana's post, Abhay doesn't want to hurt Pia. Unfortunately, he can't afford to have her knowing the truth and hence, he has to resort to means which will hurt Pia. It hurts him too but then, would he rather endanger her?? No!! He'd rather hurt her than endanger her. He himself said that she was the heartbeat of his dead heart, that he needed her in his incomplete and lifeless life, that he cannot afford to lose her. Basically, he's facing a lot of emotional turmoil and he does not know how to handle it. If we look at yesterday's scene carefully, he just 'lied'. He did not, in any way, hurt or insult her and I liked that. He didn't lie to hurt her, he lied to protect her. Was he wrong?
Edited by Chill_Out - 14 years ago
Ritzie thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: kaushiki9

😊

very nice post again.....
very true that Pia has a long way to cover to get ABhay and accept his truth.........
In twilight Ed's family supported them bt here he is alone, may b his bro'll support him even his is said 2 b evil bt i don't c 2nd choice 4 his support.....
Chandeena wnt 2 control him
i don't think they will support him.......


Thanks Kaush. The good news is that Abhay has started accepting Pia as an important part of his life but it will take time for him to say that to Pia. I loved Cullen family in Twilight but I don't think we an expect that kind of family bonding here. But that's okay. Both the stories are different.

May be there will be still some hope from Haseena but Chand, I can't say.
kaushiki9 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Ritz i was thinkin what if Dobrial's stand by Abiya......
story to tab bhi different hi rahegi......
humans protecting a Vampire & his GF
vaise to Tracker is enough to make all Vampires go mad.........
MJ_1009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: kaushiki9

Ritz i was thinkin what if Dobrial's stand by Abiya......

story to tab bhi different hi rahegi......
humans protecting a Vampire & his GF
vaise to Tracker is enough to make all Vampires go mad.........

LMAO...that would be fun to watch
-Sanjana- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
COMPLETELY AGREE WITH U!! :)
monsoonlove thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
you know..i am very glad you made this topic....
about chandeena...i had a very similar thoughts as you...bt then after reading pocs's post yesterday...i have decided not to take any stand about them...though i have never seen chandeena as villian and still don't
coming back to abhay-piya....
you are absoulately right....i completely understand why abhay is doin wat he is doin....being abhiya fan and wanting them to get together asap..i am not liking it...bt wat he did makes sense....
i know ppl are saying tht any ways piya won't give up...so he should just reveal his identity and confess his love....
it is tht easy?? no....if i was in his place..i would have done same thing..he can't just go and tell her tht he is a vampire..living dead....disclosing this big secret of his clan mean constant danger hanging on piya FOREVER...abhay is there to protect her..bt still this is about life and death...it's not an easy decision...if he discloses the truth...he is inviting constant danger for piya...and of course piya's safety is his priority...as he himself said...the little piya knows...the better for her...once she enters his dark world..there is no goin back..i know it is bound to happen..bt i wouldn't complain if it takes time...if abhay is taking forever to confess his love for piya...it makes sense..he has all valid reasons to do so...
and as for piya..we all know abhay comes at a price...abhay's fear is also valid here..he doesn't know how she will take his real identity...he also fears the future tht's very uncertain...there is a reason this is a dark love story...it makes sense if abhay is taking time in confessing his love...and isn't tht the main theme of the story..ansuni aur asambhav pyar ki yeh ek kahani...no matter how many complication..abhay and piya will have to manage the impossible love they have for each other...
Edited by kiranni - 14 years ago
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
@Kaushiki: The Ds supporting AbhIya is likely because Mish and Panchi already approve of him and Mr. D would do anything against Mr. R😉
Befikre thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
vry nice post ritz👍🏼
well i never saw abhay as a bad boy........is it his fault dat a sandwitch of him has been made b/w his 200yrs old guardians nd a new found love for which he was longing for 200yrs??? he cannot be blamed in any manner..............it's not his fault dat though he is a beast he still has a heart dat wants to beat!!!! nd it is not his fault dat his 200 yrs old guardians don't support him in any manner

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".