NOT FARE AT ALL

Page

shindom

@shindom

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

IN THE FLASHBACK SCENE YASH WAS ALL CALM AND COMPOSED WHEN HE THOUGHT THAT HE WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE FIRE SINCE HE DINT THINK ABOUT CHANGING THE OLD WIRING IN THE HOUSE. BUT THE MINUTE ARTHI SAID THAT SHE WAS RESPONSIBLE SINCE SHE FORGOT TO SWITCH OFF THE GEYSER, YASH WENT INTO ANGER MODE.

SO IT WAS OKAY FOR HIM IF HE LOST ARPITAS MEMORIES DUE TO HIS NEGLIGENCE BUT NOT OKAY IF IT WAS DUE TO ARTIS NEGLIGENCE. IS THIS FARE ON ARTI ?...

Quote

Frequent Posters

Raveena

@Loveforlife

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

I Agree but given the state he is in...he was just happy to put the blame one someone, lifting the "guilt weight" from his own shoulder to Aarti's the moment she admitted her mistake...forgetting that it was just an accident!!!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

aditi sengupta

@gcluv

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

yash is in depression so what is right or wrong is not justified at this moment because of his disturb state of mind .

he will regret to arati for sure though not now but later

Quote

DMKJ_VB

@DMKJ_VB

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

u have misunderstood the whole scene! yash was calm, but not ok with losing arpita's memories. he was terribly sad. but when he saw aarti was blaming herself, he calmed her and took it upon himself. and then aarti talked abt the geyser.isn' it absoutely normal for him to get angry? becoz before that he thought the fire was an accident, now he realized had aarti not been neglectful of the geyser, this wouldn't hv happened. he didn't accuse aarti of deliberately doing anything, he told her how careless she had been. becoz the fire did not break out becoz of electrical wiring, but the geyser! doesn't he have the right to get angry over that too? if he had to blame her, he would not have blamed himself first. i think u r being unfair on Yash!

Quote

shindom

@shindom

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

DMKJ_VB

Fire does not break out by leaving the geyser on even if there is no water in it. The geyser coil may get burnt thats all. The fire was also the result of the old wiring about which yash was talking about.

So I still feel it is not fare to blame arthi for the whole accident.

Everybody forgets to switch off the geyser atleast once in their lifetime. It is nothing serious.

Quote

Raveena

@Loveforlife

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

I think Aarti keeping the geyser on triggered the fire and the faulty wiring just spread it, fueled by Bhawris can of diesel or gasoline whatever...it was an accident but Yash was in no state of mind to understand anything once Aarti admitted her mistake!

Quote

DMKJ_VB

@DMKJ_VB

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

@ Shindom- I know what u r saying. But Yash's reaction was not uncalled for, or over. he just said that how could she be so careless, and that there was no use saying sorry now becoz everything was burnt, and he walked away from there. What terrible torture did he inflict on aarti? Did he blame her when she broke the frame by mistake? Did he not accept that he was to blame for not changing the wiring ? His reason for anger in Bhopal is definitely not that fire...so why r we unduly overexaggerating it?

My question is why do we unduly overexaggerate anything and everything that Yash does?

I still remember that when Yash went against his family, and broke his daughters' fds to pay Ansh's ransom money, aarti after seeing all that, quite rudely told him that she wanted to go along with him because he would just give the money, but she could "save" ansh! We all thought nothing of it because Ansh was in danger, and aarti had every right to be upset, ( But really wasn't that remark totally uncalled for? she could have put it differently) but strangely we don't think Yash has any right to be upset about anything! Why is it so difficult to understand that arpita's memories are not lesser than a living man to Yash?

Quote

Raveena

@Loveforlife

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

One cannot reason out with a person who is in the state of mind that Yash was and is at the moment... If any could then he won't have been in this state at all.

@ DMKJ_VB

I agree anyone in that situation where everything burnt down..everything so close to ones / Yash's heart... Would have blamed the person because of whom it happened!! It is not so difficult to believe his anger...

All this is only a part of the trigger to his extreme reaction and behavior..

Edited by Loveforlife - 13 years ago

Quote

shindom

@shindom

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

DMKJ_VB

yash repeated said that he has no relationship with aarthi and that he hates her and does not even want to see her face again. isn't this torture enough for arti? needless to say yash has been pushing and shoving her whenever she comes near him.

But according to what all of u r saying, whatever the reason for yash anger, in his 'state of mind' he can say and do anything to arti. everuything is justifiable since he is in his 'state of mind'. this is not a normal reaction.

this 'state of mind' is called insanity or madness which is why his doctor has asked him to get phyciatric help.

Quote

NOT FARE AT ALL

Related Topics

Explore Topics