In Defence of my Anshu

Charishma thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
So, today's episode 😉. I'm issuing a bit of a warning. This post is not very nice to Yash. He was less than wonderful today

Poor Anshu😭.
Its horrible that a step-father, who has not yet received any permission from Aarti, to yell at his 4-year-old step-son, did so, and in front of everyone. Does it feel good to get yelled at by a teacher in school (when you're a teenager), or by a boss at work (when you're an adult)? It feels humiliating and crushing actually. So then why is it acceptable to yell at children in front of others? Parents should never do this.

Yash is justified though. Ansh misbehaved, and Aarti said nothing. But Ansh's misbehaving at the table wasn't the sole influencing factor. The truth is Yash didn't yell at Ansh to discipline him because of his stunt with Pankaj (Pankaj is such a darling btw⭐️) .
He had bottled up his anger (from the bathroom mess incident), glared at Ansh (poor little boy) when he came to breakfast, and then yelled at him when he acted out. I'm not saying, he didn't get rightly angry, I'm saying he handled it horribly.
Yash should have spoken to Aarti and asked her to get Ansh in line, following the whole bathroom mess. But instead he kept it to himself. Until he couldn't anymore. There's a difference between disciplining a child, and releasing your frustration on them. If someone (Aarti) had done that to PayPal he would have lost his ever-loving mind.

Yash needs to come out from his own little world. He needs to stop silently observing and deliberating and actively participate in his (new) family life. He sits there, still as a statue, while chaos ensues around him, and expects his perch to be undisturbed.
He can't just expect everything to stay the same. Yash is verrry set in his ways. This will have to change. Arpita might have been happy to silently take Gayatri's lectures, but Ansh won't stand for Aarti being mistreated. Arpita might have been happy to iron Yash's shirts (just the way his OCD-self adores), but Aarti might not be so indulgent. Aarti is not Arpita, who will exist happily in his world. I have a feeling he's in for a rude-awakening.
I love GC (believe me😳 lol) , but sometimes I feel like hero-worship blinds viewers to the realities of Yash's character. Don't get me wrong. Yash is awesome. But he is not meant to be perfect, and if we were to find him at fault for something, then that's fine. He doesn't have to do everrryyything right. Call a spade a spade, and admit that he DOES owe Ansh an apology

Aarti's actions are something entirely different. She should have had this conversation with Ansh earlier. The one explaining to him about the realities of living in an extended family home, with a new father and 2 new sisters. But she didn't, and now he's hurt and confused. What else is she to do, but try to make him feel better? Her actions and words following the incident were not all that bad. That was not the time to sit him and down and explain the whys and ways of their new world. That was the time to try and make him happy. Plus, Yash deserved a scolding.
That is not a way to talk to a little boy who's just learned that dreams of him
and his "smart and handsome naya papa" were not going to come true. The talking can come later, after Ansh has calmed down. Once Yash and he have apologized to each other. Ansh doesn't come from a family that disciplines with harsh words. Those few words of Yash's probably broke his heart and scared him a little.


PS: Did anyone else notice that Ansh had only started banging the utensils when Gayatri started explaining why Aarti got less money? There's a bit of a pattern here. Aarti stays quiet when she gets yelled at, or put in place. But Ansh can't just sit back. Whether he's consciously trying to divert attention away from her, or whether he's trying to drown out the sounds of his mother being 'put down' is unclear. But still, it makes my heart melt. This little boy is so smart and loving. He'll be the star of the show I tell you. 😎


Edited by Charishma - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

1.1k

Users

2

Likes

13

Frequent Posters

RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
I agree somewhat about your analysis of Yash, but I do not agree that he owes Ansh an apology. Aarti married him so that he would become a father to Ansh, right? That's exactly how Yash behaved today. A real father would not sit back and watch when his son is behaving like a spoiled little brat, and I know my own father would have done far worse than Yash had my siblings or I behaved like Ansh. Yes, I agree that Ansh needs some time adjusting and both Yash and and Aarti should have a talk with their kids about the adjustments they all will have to make for this new life, but I do not agree that Yash is so terribly wrong that he needs to apologize to Ansh. Parents should not apologize to their kids and doing so will make kids believe that they have their parents wrapped around their little finger. It will only spoil them further, and neither should parents promise their child chocolate cake after a misbehaving episode like Aarti did.I would like to see Yash and Ansh have a friendly conversation in tomorrow's episode, but if he apologizes to Ansh, I will feel very disappointed with this show. Ansh may be cute, but he seriously needs to learn manners and Yash has been the first one in the show so far who has attempted to discipline him. Ansh's own mother failed in that, at least his step-father should.
Charishma thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
@ JanakiRaghunath:
I see what you're saying. But the fact is, Yash is not Ansh's real father. And he won't take on that position until the two of them have built a relationship of father and son.He's become Aarti's husband, and by that right he should also be Ansh's father. But it seems to be more a "in name only" type thing. Its only been 1 day, and Ansh and Yash are strangers to each other. Time needs to be given on both ends. In the meantime, if he found Aarti's lack of control unsettling, maybe he should have asked her to take Ansh in hand. Yash was overly impatient, and a little inconsiderate, of Ansh. It was not well done of him.

He responded to Ansh's sharp behaviour, with his own sharp behaviour. Even as a child, that part never made sense to me. How does that help the situation?

I remember all the times when my parents yelled at me, out of frustration, only to regret it. My father would always come around, and slowly ask me if I wanted McDonalds. It was his way of saying sorry lol I knoww. Weird right? But it always made me feel better. Oftentimes, a child misbehaves unknowingly, or because something is upsetting them. Why yell at a kid, when a few simple explanatory words can put the situation to rights? Always try the first method (maybe with a consequence), and when that doesn't work, bring out the yelling. But one should never resort to yelling straight away. No one appreciates being treated like that. Why should a child be treated less than an adult, when they are the more innocent and helpless?

Pankaj was being very patient with Ansh. Tricking him into eating, sitting him down next to him, not taking any mind when Ansh repeatedly pushed his hand away. It was very sweet. And completely different from how Yash was coming across. Panku is such a darling. Vidhi needs to give that guy some action lol He deserves it
Edited by Charishma - 13 years ago
RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Charishma

@ JanakiRaghunath:
I see what you're saying. But the fact is, Yash is not Ansh's real father. And he won't take on that position until the two of them have built a relationship of father and son.He's become Aarti's husband, and by that right he should also be Ansh's father. But it seems to be more a "in name only" type thing. Its only been 1 day, and Ansh and Yash are strangers to each other. Time needs to be given on both ends. In the meantime, if he found Aarti's lack of control unsettling, maybe he should have asked her to take Ansh in hand. Yash was overly impatient, and a little inconsiderate, of Ansh. It was not well done of him.

I remember all the times when my parents yelled at me, out of frustration, only to regret it. My father would always come around, and slowly ask me if I wanted McDonalds. It was his way of saying sorry lol I knoww. Weird right? But it always made me feel better. Oftentimes, a child misbehaves unknowingly, or because something is upsetting them. Why yell at a kid, when a few simple explanatory words can put the situation to rights? Always try the first method (maybe with a consequence), and when that doesn't work, bring out the yelling. But one should never resort to yelling straight away. No one appreciates being treated like that. Why should a child be treated less than an adult, when they are the more innocent and helpless?

Pankaj was being very patient with Ansh. Tricking him into eating, sitting him down next to him, not taking any mind when Ansh repeatedly pushed his hand away. It was very sweet. And completely different from how Yash was coming across. Panku is such a darling. Vidhi needs to give that guy some action lol He deserves it

Yes, I agree that Yash's reaction to Ansh wasn't 100% right, but it was better than Aarti's in my opinion. She just reinforces the child's behavior, and it should have been Yash offering the chocolate cake, not her. When a father yells at a child and a mother bribes the child with cake to make him feel better, the child will create a difference between them and use it to his advantage. I think what Aarti should have done was talk to Yash and ask him to be more patient with Ansh. Yash is not a bad guy, and I think if Aarti had talked to him privately first, he would have felt bad and made amends with Ansh himself, perhaps treating him to ice cream or something like your own dad did with McDonalds, but not only did Aarti give in to Ansh's unreasonable demands, she gave Yash reason to believe that his mother may have been right after all. I still believe the chocolate cake bribing was wrong, because first of all one should never bribe a child. They can make compromises, but a bribe is a BIG no no. This is one very important thing I learned in developmental psychology.
I also like Pankaj a lot, he's such a sweetheart.😳
Charishma thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: JanakiRaghunath

Yes, I agree that Yash's reaction to Ansh wasn't 100% right, but it was better than Aarti's in my opinion. She just reinforces the child's behavior, and it should have been Yash offering the chocolate cake, not her. When a father yells at a child and a mother bribes the child with cake to make him feel better, the child will create a difference between them and use it to his advantage. I think what Aarti should have done was talk to Yash and ask him to be more patient with Ansh. Yash is not a bad guy, and I think if Aarti had talked to him privately first, he would have felt bad and made amends with Ansh himself, perhaps treating him to ice cream or something like your own dad did with McDonalds, but not only did Aarti give in to Ansh's unreasonable demands, she gave Yash reason to believe that his mother may have been right after all. I still believe the chocolate cake bribing was wrong, because first of all one should never bribe a child. They can make compromises, but a bribe is a BIG no no. This is one very important thing I learned in developmental psychology.
I also like Pankaj a lot, he's such a sweetheart.😳


Children (at age 4) are not evil little things out to pit one parent against another, and create rifts between them. The behavior you describe is probably more applicable to teenagers (who are often looking for permission to do something or other, and usually one parent disagrees---chaos ensues 😆). So I agree. Children often try to manipulate their parents. And Ansh did that a little today. But I don't think he was consciously aware of it. He's just too young to have his demands come from anywhere else other than the heart. He really felt like his mother didn't care anymore.

That whole time Ansh was creating a fuss, she was just standing there. I think he felt betrayed by her, and that little packing stunt , was directed at Aarti. All he wanted, was to know that his mother was still his. She offered him cake to get him to stop being so mad, at HER. She met his request because she felt she owed him. And honestly, at that point, she did. It is her fault that he's had unreasonable expectations of what life with his 'naya papa' would be like. She lives in her own dreamworld, and has encouraged that in her son. She has her own reasons of course. I'm not upset with her either.
Its just that, Yash needs to understand that Aarti and Ansh operate differently then he and PayPal do. Just as Ansh and Aarti are coming to understand that their new house operates differently than their old one. There's alot of adjustments being made here, and all of them appear to be on Aarti and Ansh's side so far. Ofcourse its only been 1 day. So maybe I'm jumping the gun 😆

RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Yes, I agree that children are not manipulative at the age of 4, but the foundation of their personality is laid down at that age. Now, Ansh is cute and adorable, but once he's a teen, how will he be? He is appeased by chocolate now, but his demands will be bigger when he's older.
I also don't blame Ansh for his behavior, and yes I do feel very sorry for his situation because it was not as he had expected, but seriously, Aarti and Yash are bot responsible for this. They really need to sit down with all three kids and explain to them how things are going to run, and how one of them will not receive maximum attention anymore. I'm going crazy waiting for that convo, lol.
Charishma thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
But Ansh's foundation is just fine. Seriously, a couple stunts from a child uprooted from his home, and thrown into a world where he is now a 2nd Class Citizen, is not the end of the world. Nor will it result in him being a bad person. He's a bright, protective, and loving boy.

This situation is very particular. Its not like he acts like this everyday. His every attempt at friendship with Yash has been met with a passing smile, or a solemn look. His every fight with PayPal has been instigated by them. And Gayatri hates him.

He has the right to be appeased. Because he was wronged. First by his mother, and then by his new father. Besides, he didn't ask for chocolate cake, he asked for his mother to show that he's still number 1 in her life. Which he should be. At some point that position will maybe be shared with PayPal. But for now, he's number 1, and he needed to feel it. .

Seriously, i love pankaj more and more. Right when Ansh wants attention, Panku zeros in on him, and gives him the attention he's unable to get from the two people he wants it from. Someone give the man some attention also lol!
RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Not every fight was instigated by PayPal. Ansh kicked them off a humongous bed in their own room. How would any young child feel? Even PayPal are young, and unlike Ansh who wanted a father, they did not want a new mother and this is natural. It's natural in older children, let alone Yash's daughters. No one talked to PayPal about the new arrangements after marriage, and I can understand how they felt to have a half-naked boy take over their bad. Just as I find Ansh's attitude understandable, I do not find anything wrong with PayPal's either. Aarti may have interacted with them more than Yash did with Ansh, but she has not made much of an effort to be warm and loving towards them. She is always worried about Ansh and has just about ignored PayPal the entire day so far, so why should Yash be partial towards Ansh? I know this is not a give and take relationship, but if Yash is to say sorry to Ansh, I think PayPal deserve some attention and some kind of apology from Aarti too, because she has not said one word to them the whole day and paid them zero attention.

I am not saying Yash is a perfect father, but neither fo I think Aarti is a perfect mother. I think they are both equally at fault and should take some responsibility for their new duties.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".