Article: Displaced concern

Originally posted by: SaacheeSyna

Displaced concern

'Pratigya' started off as a show depicting one woman's crusade against eve-teasing. However, it has now boiled down to being a melodramatic serial portraying women as mere submissive beings, says Srabanti Chakrabarti

Remember the old proverb ' morning shows the day? It may hold true for many aspects of our life, but it is definitely not true for most television shows. A number of them started off with a promise, but beyond a few months, ended up being the same like any other show on the small screen. A case in point is the trend of socially-relevant serials that started some time back. They garnered popularity as they claimed to be different that the tried and tested saas-bahu sagas but today, it seems those serials too are suffering from ageing disorders and delivering stuff that is far from what they had initially offered. Examples include shows like Agle Janam Mohe Betiyan Hi Kijo, Balika Vadhu among others. Today a large section of the audience feels that be it wife harassment, dowry or eve-teasing, serials that started against them, actually publicise them more than warranted and in turn prove to be regressive rather than progressive stories. Something similar seems to have happened with the once-popular Pratigya. The serial that broke many a record on Star Plus because of its unique anti-eve teasing storyline, seems to have changed track completely. Today, it's boiled down to a tale where a woman is humiliated at home, her self respect trampled on by her in-laws and husband instead of portraying her to be a strong woman who stands her ground. When it started, Pratigya was supposed to be the story of an ordinary girl not taking things lying down and deciding to hit back to reclaim her respect in the society. She is molested by a man who later falls in love with her and they both eventually get married. The story moves on to her marital life and the kind of challenges she encounters and the constant pressure of answering the question of whether she did the right thing by marrying her molestor. The simplicity of the story and the common situation that it portrayed, made it relatable to everyone, both in rural and urban India. Sanjay Gupta, COO, STAR, says, "With Pratigya, we bring alive an icon whose journey all women can relate to, identify with and be inspired by. Breaking stereotypes, we have created a protagonist who is not a victim but a reformer." But is that really the case even today? Aren't we seeing lead character more of as a victim? Expectedly the caste and crew of the serial disagree. Explains actress Pooja Gaur, who plays the lead role in the show, "Every woman has been through a situation wherein she has felt helpless or has made a choice against her wishes under family or societal pressures. Pratigya's story is that of a young girl who finds the courage to take her own decision which not only transforms her life but also changes how society looks at her." Is that what makes it possible for the show to skyrocket to popularity in such a short time? Agreed that the show did become popular, but isn't it's popularity nosediving now? Is Pratigya the same show that it used to be two years back when it started? Producer Pearl Grey feels they are still continuing to send a strong message against eve-teasing. She says, "We want our message to reach out to every nook and corner of the country. Today eve teasing is something that affects all girls in our country. This serial talks about one such girl and is proving to be an inspiration for everyone." Pearl also feels that whatever the submissiveness of the lead character on the show is to make it more real and something everyone can relate to. "I did not want to portray sugar-coated or gray characters like what is done in most serials. Thankfully the audience liked the reality that we portrayed on a functional show." Point taken, but considering the audience that we have and how television impacts rural and urban India, don't the producers have a responsibility to showcase more positive stuff? Instead we are having more and more shows like Raaz Pichle Janam Ka, which are promoting superstitions and perhaps creating a lot of damage. One just hopes, future shows do not fall into the same trap. http://www.deccanherald.com/content/112475/displaced-concern.html @ bold:...they have got the facts wrong here...Pratigya didn't start two years ago...infact it has barely been a year now!!

I think this author first needs to check up on her facts before writing an article bashing MKAP. A few examples:

Originally posted by: elle45

I think this author first needs to check up on her facts before writing an article bashing MKAP. A few examples:

Something similar seems to have happened with the once-popular Pratigya.

Pratigya is not a show which used to be popular in the past. It is still one of the most watched shows, and it's going very strong.

She is molested by a man who later falls in love with her and they both eventually get married.
Pratigya was NOT molested by Krishna, but by Angad. Krishna fell in love with her on first sight.

Angad only kidnapped Prats did not molest her per story so far😕.

Is Pratigya the same show that it used to be two years back when it started?
It hasn't even been a year since the show started. It started in december 2009, I think?

her self respect trampled on by her in-laws and husband instead of portraying her to be a strong woman who stands her ground. .......Aren't we seeing lead character more of as a victim?

I think we all agree that Pratigya never fails to stand her ground. She's always about standing up for her principles, no matter what. She refuses to budge, even when we want her to. 😆 This girl doesn't take into account whether it's her mother-in-law or brother-in-law that she's sending to jail. She refused to take being slapped in public by her husband lightly. She refused to drink the dirty water of her MIL's feet. And there are many more examples..... I don't think there's any female lead on TV who refuses to compromise on her priniciples like Pratigya does. So how is she more of a victim?

I'm not bashing the author here.... it's just that when you write an article criticising a show, then you should do your homework on it first. 😆

Originally posted by: dhakarn

yeah, they seriously don't know anything about the serial except those first few episodes...........what did they except? the serial will go on showing for years to come the fight of a woman against eve teasing.............MKAP depicts reality, and in reality life goes on............it won't present before u circumstances as per ur convenience....the circumstances change, either for better or for worse....i think MKAP has brilliantly shown what all hurdles would come in the path of struggle that too by a single women against the established norms of the society.........and pratigya is not a super women to get all things under her favor.............she is just a normal indian women..................with extra ordinary strength of mind, but the people she is dealing with r not kittens............they r literally lions and she is bound to get injured fighting lions..........even now the CVs r showing reality as in how there r people who prefers to wear a mask infront of the society to get their needs done...........and honestly where did they come up with the ridiculous phrase 'once-popular' ........the serial is only just slipped 3 places from the first position and it has only been 3 weeks........still going strong............

Originally posted by: MERARAI

Dhak

The tone of your post matches your avatar.

wel said by the FF members y dey shuld do hve done their homewrk throughly

before penning down , whole yr cannot b on eveteasing only

so wel they hve shown different situation where she shows her courage and does

not bend down , shows no fear but takes her step courageously no matter what

is the situation

we must nt 4get a saying after every successful man theirs is women

but here after every successful women is her husband . who belief in her her trueness

and support her un conditionally.