Why didn't Pratigya?

MERARAI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
After what we saw last week, a few questions came to mind.

Prats thought Krishna kidnapped her. Yet she married him to defend her family's izzat in society.
Prats told Krishna she hated him and will for the rest of her life on SR#1.
She told him she would never let him touch her.
She said his so called love was delusional and selfish.
She continued to live with him in close quarters and got to know him gradually over a period of time.
At Shamu's house before she slapped him a second time Angad told her he made a mistake letting her go free without touching her the night of the kidnapping, but will take his revenge with Arushi.

In all this time between the kidnapping and finding out Krishna was not the kidnapper it is understandable she would give him hell in return. I question her sanity in choosing to marry him but that's a whole different story and the POPs took the story this way to prolong the drama.

Once she got to know Krishna better at the Adda when he poured his feelings out and knew he was innocent of her kidnapping did she ever once doubt or question how such a man could have kidnapped her? Did she never think to ask him why he pareshaaned her family in diff. ways before the wedding even as a matter of convo. when she brought up the friendship angle? Even then she kept saying she had work to do in the house.

She gave her vachan to her father knowing fully well she was making a wrong choice by hiding a big secret from Krishna. Why did she fail to be the symbol of truth at that time? (as the creative head of the show said in a recent article). Prolong the drama, of course.😛

Between the time she knew the truth and outing the secret in public why was she still behaving the same way with Krishna as she did before? Why did she flee after pushing him away when he hugged her in the kitchen? She knew he was innocent by then. Knowing the truth didn't make any difference to her. Why couldn't she treat him with some consideration once she knew the truth? Did she need to publicly out the secret before she felt him worthy of some attention from her? Somehow her behavior doesn't make sense.

In all the time he has repeatedly supported and defended her to his family did she ever see him as someone who loved her? It was only after he was devastated hearing the secret in court and cleaning her coal face painting that it even seemed to register with her that there was something real on his part, by then he didn't want anything from her (as he said it) . Was it her guilt that she had hid the secret from him? Was it relief that he accepted her even after hearing the secret and defended her to his family? Seems she may have been projecting a bit much when she called him (his love) delusional and selfish earlier on.

Is it grief at being responsible for his devastation and guilt for not telling him the truth earlier the reasons for her recent concern for him? I wouldn't call it love or anywhere close to it just yet bec' it is conditional on appeasing her own feelings of grief and guilt and trying to get him out of his depressed state knowing she was partially responsible for it.

Ka kehti ho? Bolbo!

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

2.5k

Users

11

Likes

99

Frequent Posters

BadGirlKiss thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
Owowowowowoow.lolng discription. Agree in some parts but also disagree. I guss after knowing the truth prat had sympothy for him not love. To make this relationship work she gave another chance to him by making friendship.

Remember the beganing... She never wanted to marry him... So it's someway krishnas silt. He loved her... But she didn't. So I guss that's what the created trying to show. But the proffeser going to jail and court stuff... It was completly pointless. It dosnt fit in the story line.


So I do agree with u. :D x
suk19 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
Merarai i can understand what you are saying, i dont know if you remember when pratigya had got engaged to Nithin and the prof and family was discussing and Aarushi says something like pratigya will have dosti first then love and then daddi butts in and says whats not to love hes got a good job hes educated etc. so that gives us a indication that she would have treated Nithin the same way. She cannot forget that he tried to rape her not once but twice, her and her family had no choice but to give into krishna demands, but unknowing to her and krishna that the real root of their problems and the coming together was angad.

I think pratigya was thinking that krishna does not love her he is more obsessed, when he came to hug her in the kitchen she was worried about her father, and she did not tell him about the kidnapping and she was letting him hug her, he would have reacted more differently he would have said that you pretending to love and like me so that i was on your side when it came to my parents, it becomes a bigger issue. I was happy she did react to him romantically when all those problems arised.

we are going to have to wait until after the 15th 😔 and sees what happens, this week should be good hopefully komol going against her famiy



Dreamygal301 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Mera, all good points raised. In fact I used to ask them in the earlier days. The best time for her to reveal the Kidnapping and etc was during the suhaag raat and the 'forced suhaag raat' during the honeymoon....because emotions were running high and she could have slipped out with 'the reason I hate you is because...'...or he could have said 'what have I done that you hate me so much..'......but nada from them!
Unfortunately it's all down to the writers and how they planned the story arc. It's obviously an attempt to keep the suspense and drama going on for as long as they can, no sense otherwise. There were many, many timed when the truth could have been revealed!!
But I am really hoping, now Krishna and Prat talk....he still doesn't know she and her family blamed him for Nitin's beating, the graffitti and so on. If they don't talk about all this then I would have a problem beliving in their love, in fact I would think Cvs are retaining that for future muck-up between them. I mean she never even asked him once, out of curiosity, 'by the way, when did you first see me?' ..or when he got hurt fighting angad, she could have asked 'you were the best of friends once, did you know he did this to me on the train..'?
So it's all a hide and seek game with the writers, whether it makes sense or not.......that's what drama is all about!😉
MERARAI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: jennifer111

Owowowowowoow.lolng discription. Agree in some parts but also disagree. I guss after knowing the truth prat had sympothy for him not love. To make this relationship work she gave another chance to him by making friendship.

Remember the beganing... She never wanted to marry him... So it's someway krishnas silt. He loved her... But she didn't. So I guss that's what the created trying to show. But the proffeser going to jail and court stuff... It was completly pointless. It dosnt fit in the story line.


So I do agree with u. :D x



I guess you haven't seen many of my posts. I write some of the longests posts.😳😃😃 Ask tanthya she'll tell you, I recently outdid my previous record for long posts. 😆😆😆😆😆😆

In other words when you see MERARAI .....think, Gosh! Here comes her long post.😲😉😕😃
she_ratchet thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
WOW mera...👏👏👏👏👏👏..i just ahve one word...wow..awesome post...agreed thourghout..how do u write so gud?!?! arre humko be sikaya do yar!
MERARAI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mrs.luvjaysean

WOW mera...👏..i just ahve one word...wow..awesome post...agreed thourghout..how do u write so gud?!?! arre humko be sikaya do yar!



Thankooji mrs.luvjaysean! 😳😳😳😳 I just put my thoughts down and organize them a little. Bus! 😆😆😆😆 Often some good questions pop up 😃when I am in the middle of doing other stuff.😕
MERARAI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: mrs.luvjaysean

WOW mera...👏..i just ahve one word...wow..awesome post...agreed thourghout..how do u write so gud?!?! arre humko be sikaya do yar!



sorry double post!
Edited by MERARAI - 15 years ago
she_ratchet thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: MERARAI



Thankooji mrs.luvjaysean! 😳 I just put my thoughts down and organize them a little. Bus! 😆 Often some good questions pop up 😃when I am in the middle of doing other stuff.😕


😳making me blush mera!!!😳😳😳😳😳really i'll try to do that...thnx for the advice😉and yeah...BELCOME DEAR JI!!!!😆😆😆😆
😳
shumi. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: MERARAI


Prats told Krishna she hated him and will for the rest of her life on SR#1.🤣...yaar har ek ladki kya life mai SR ek hi baar aatha hai...baar baar nahi...😆...if it happens so than that is not SR raat... She told him she would never let him touch her.
She said his so called love was delusional and selfish. all her pratigya gayeh tel lene....🤣

Once she got to know Krishna better at the Adda when he poured his feelings out and knew he was innocent of her kidnapping did she ever once doubt or question how such a man could have kidnapped her? Did she never think to ask him why he pareshaaned her family in diff. ways before the wedding even as a matter of convo. when she brought up the friendship angle? first of all she is brainless beauty.next she don't want to understad him and move ahead in her married life.her only pratigya is mottatalay papa.
She gave her vachan to her father knowing fully well she was making a wrong choice by hiding a big secret from Krishna. Why did she fail to be the symbol of truth at that time? (as the creative head of the show said in a recent article). yaar according to my POV she is the symbol of curse to men.

Between the time she knew the truth and outing the secret in public why was she still behaving the same way with Krishna as she did before? Why did she flee after pushing him away when he hugged her in the kitchen? ....her love towards that unpad gawaar is yet to bloom...she was awaiting for her moo kala ceremony....girrr...She knew he was innocent by then. Knowing the truth didn't make any difference to her. Why couldn't she treat him with some consideration once she knew the truth? what do you mean by consideration? do you want to go and kiss him....girr...her main mission was neither to understand her unpad panti nor to keep him happy ...to save her senseless puppet papa and bring him out of the jail using unpad as her stepping stone....girr Did she need to publicly out the secret before she felt him worthy of some attention from her? Somehow her behavior doesn't make sense.when her behavior made scense? 😡...to make sense to day

In all the time he has repeatedly supported and defended her to his family did she ever see him as someone who loved her? she has no time to see all those silly things...she is busy making the bed and set righting the ward rob...some time mixing the flour😡....It was only after he was devastated hearing the secret in court and cleaning her coal face painting that it even seemed to register with her that there was something real on his part, by then he didn't want anything from her (as he said it) . Was it her guilt that she had hid the secret from him? Was it relief that he accepted her even after hearing the secret and defended her to his family? Seems she may have been projecting a bit much when she called him (his love) delusional and selfish earlier on.

Is it grief at being responsible for his devastation and guilt for not telling him the truth earlier the reasons for her recent concern for him? I wouldn't call it love or anywhere close to it just yet bec' it is conditional on appeasing her own feelings of grief and guilt and trying to get him out of his depressed state knowing she was partially responsible for it.partially responsible ...?????😡

Ka kehti ho? Bolbo!

Edited by shumi. - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".