Shakthi -shud he b reviled OR ??

tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#1


Shakthi ......


The only character in the thakur's who doesn't have much Dialogues ....nor is shown to be an individual ...who is present in almost all the scenes and by his sheer presence manages to radiate an aura of malevolence..he is not someone to be easily ignored ...in the family conferences..one can ignore G.Dadi, Piyasiya [despite her rolling eyes] , the statuesque Kesar, but not this brooding HULK


Last week... the entire forum was up in arms against his insensitivity ..all the members be it Pro-P or Pro-K were unanimous in showing their disapproval...

Naturally with all the members against him....I took a side ways step and tried to assess him ..

NOTE TO ALL : THE POINTS THAT I AM GOING TO TYPE BELOW ARE NOT MY PPOV ....I AM MERELY STATING WHAT I SAW INSTEAD OF PROCESSING IT THROUGH MORAL COMPASS... I AM NEITHER SUPPORTING HIS ACTIONS NOR CONDEMNING HIM ...

looking back, shakthi struck me as honest ...he is entirely honest in his confession that he does not love his wife , neither does he pretend to be in love in front of his family..he has told them quite bluntly that he married her only becos you ordered me too..and not because I wanted too ....in other words he was being an obedient and dutiful son ...unlike Krishna !!

Neither has he kept his revulsion and dislike of Kesar hidden from her...from day 1 , she knows that her hubby does not love her, wants only one thing from her !! But still she wants to stay in on the relationship ....in other words he has not lied to his wife.


He has a high libido .....he has never denied it !! he has not boasted about it , he has stated it matter of fact and also said that he visits Kothas for this express purpose ...None have stopped him !! He had even given an option to Kesar saying that he cant control his libido, as night sneaks on, it goes on overdrive ...So either choose Baby or Pati...and Kesar chose Baby and shakthi chose kothewali !!

even though he dislikes Kesar , he did acknowledge her as an ideal Bahu ...although he loathes her , it has not stopped him from acknowledging the true fact...


He does not want any baby from Kesar and he has made it very plain to her and had Kesar any sense, she first would have tried to convert his mind or she could have taken preventive measures but she very foolishly goes and gets pregnant , putting her life and her child's to mortal danger...later if the baby is born what if the baby does not get the father's love...this does not seem to weigh heavily with Kesar...

He has said that he will not allow this baby to be born..he will take some steps to avert the birth of this child ...when he attack, he attacks after giving a warning ...and he did try to abort the pregnancy and also truthfully revealed the failed plot to kesar ,if Kesar has any Grey cells...she shud take some strong actions by informing her sasur or going of to her Maika.

what ever SS tells , he will do without a murmur and without a single rebellious thought ....he is indispensable to his father and his right hand man .......he is highly protective of his sister


Does Shakthi deserve whole hearted condemnation for being truthful and honest about his intentions and feelings ....

Is he capable of redemption .....Will he be redeemed ??

Does shakthi deserves another chance ??


Ur Comments and Opinions are welcome.......




Edited by tanthya - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

3.2k

Users

11

Likes

54

Frequent Posters

MERARAI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
Very interesting analysis about Katra Naresh Babu Sakthi Singh. True he is blatantly honest and doesn't care two hoots about what anyone thinks of him. He is proud and secure in himself. I think he and Krishna are similar in a few traits. Both are fiercely loyal to their family, they both love Komal, ignore Amma.

KN doesn't love Kesar and she accepts it
Baba loves Prats and she rejects it

KN gets his wife to do his bidding
Baba gets to do his wife's bidding

KN's wife is soft spoken and timid, same biradari
Baba's wife speaks up and fights back, doosari biradari

KN verbally abuses his wife, beats her
Baba's wife gives him baashans, he slapped her once, she slapped him twice

KN loves his firearms
Baba carries them to intimidate (except the one time he shot Angad)

KN doesn not love his wife and married for "fayda" reasons
Baba married Prats for love

KN doesn't want the baby Kesar is carrying
Baba wants to know when he will become baap

KN is scolded and demanded to do things by SS
Baba is adored and gets his way with SS

Polar opposites brothers in most ways😃
Edited by MERARAI - 15 years ago
tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#3


Yes Mera,

Both appear to be polar opposites ....

The younger one is loquacious, humorous and strong with an inbuilt radar for sahi and Galat ....

while the elder one is silent , quiet, strong with no Moral integrity...

and yet both love their family very much !! and would not hesitate to kill any one who would destroy their family ...

and also despite their constant quibbling and skirmishes ...there is no denying a strong bond of affection between them.
519678 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
hey tanthya wat an awsume analysis ! in fact i have also been thinking along the same lines that this guy is amazing at his own end, his job as an actor is to create hatred in the hearts of the veiwers and he is playing it to the hilt , but yet the man has not been gven his dues ! never caught him talking to the media or getting any exposure, due to an actor of such gud caliber !!!!!!!!! his silent presence itself brings life into the scene ! yooh !😊
HamiSky thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
haiii
As for Shakthi being honest n stuff...
its not that he alone is like that
almost all the members in SS family or at least the male members + Komal tend to speak what they think...
thye blurt out what they feel is correct...they always have had no-hidden attitude in their speech ,actions or thinking... i mean to say they are honest by nature itself ...
i can exempt Amma from this coz she follows tactful ways to get thigns done!!!
but her children are honest....wat say!!!!
elle45 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
Nice post, good to be analysing someone other than Kriya for a change 😊
Shakti and Krishna really are polar opposites of each other, as Mera said. He is, I guess, following the Thakur legacy, almost to perfection. And despite the fact that SS keeps calling him Katra Naresh (I have no idea what that means though) and telling him he's useless, Shakti is still an obedient son. He beats and reprimands his wife like SS does, he has no respect for women like SS does, he feels Men are supreme beings like SS feels. He even helps his dad with their regular business, and the "side" business.... of having ppl beaten up, like Aman. 😆 With all these qualities, he's still not favored by his dad.
Most of these qualities are not found in Krishna. Yet, in Shakti's eyes, Krishna is favored by SS, Krishna seems to get what he wants. This will, I think, be a point of conflict between the 2 brothers very soon. Shakti has already started the taunts as to how Krishna is a 'joru ka ghulam'. It's possible when he finally erupts, he'll turn into an out-and-out negative character, bringing the whole family against Kriya.
I've never liked Shakti though, we can't just blame his personality on the upbringing. Krishna and Komal have the same brought-up, yet both of them have room for improvement, for modifications. No one can change Shakti. It's true though, that the first-born is always the most loyal to the family heritage.... I heard that somewhere.
ArhainAshish thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
I dislike 3 things in shakti d most:
1-he dosent respects women esp his wife...
2-he killed his own kids 4 tyms:(
3-he brought anodr women at his own house:O
bakiii chotey chotey baatein tu hotii rehtey hain aakhir no1z perfect every1 has sum flaws or d odr..
nisha2010 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
@nice post....................

actually after reading ur post i feel like giving the title of............ the torchbearer................to shakti.............

he reflects the values that have been taught to him and believes in them......................

however different all fam members r ,how much they fight or disagree................still they have dinner together and ss always has d last word(or if gurumaa orders him )
tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: gees

hey tanthya wat an awsume analysis ! in fact i have also been thinking along the same lines that this guy is amazing at his own end, his job as an actor is to create hatred in the hearts of the veiwers and he is playing it to the hilt , but yet the man has not been gven his dues ! never caught him talking to the media or getting any exposure, due to an actor of such gud caliber !!!!!!!!! his silent presence itself brings life into the scene ! yooh !😊




Gees ,


Thanks ....

actually apart from Pooja Gor and Anupam shyam...none of the actors have shown an affinity to be a part of media circus ..Arhan looks as if he is talking with a gun held in his head , Komal looks as if she is fooling around and others never come in front of the medias camera...Is it due to the gag order or are they media shy ..and do not want their personal life to be in public domain...


tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: HamiSky

haiii

As for Shakthi being honest n stuff...
its not that he alone is like that
almost all the members in SS family or at least the male members + Komal tend to speak what they think...
thye blurt out what they feel is correct...they always have had no-hidden attitude in their speech ,actions or thinking... i mean to say they are honest by nature itself ...
i can exempt Amma from this coz she follows tactful ways to get thigns done!!!
but her children are honest....wat say!!!!



Hi Hami ,

I am not in complete agreement with you , Hami...SS is a master manipulator , he is honest when it suits him.

Krishna is honest ....

Komal is a mix of Amma and bauji ..will be all smiles and charm when she wants her sasuma to do her bidding..

Shakthi is honest, whatever he feels he says bluntly or he will show it on his face ,..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".