Regarding Neha's death. What if...

Nabakov_Musings thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Guys I have been thinking this sort of idea for quite some time so I thought why not share it. What if later in the long run in the show the audience and Roshni figures out that the reason behind Neha's suicide was not exactly the Paanch , but Gauti? Why do I have a feeling just like all of you guys that these two did have something in between them , and sure maybe the tortures the Paanch gave to her were driving small steps towards her suicide but I really think that in the middle or a little later than that in the course of Roshnis revenge she begins to figure out that the main driving point which drove her to suicide was not those five it was Gauti- maybe his silence? maybe his betrayal in not helping her? Maybe not standing up for her when they were in love? Or maybe betraying altogether was the focal point of why she committed suicide , while the tortures of the Paanch were just some bg troubles she could handle but the betrayal of a lover for supporting her when those 5 were going overboard with her made her feel helpless and lonely enough to commit suicide.. Itll be damn interesting if during Roshnis revenge Roshni figures out that the reason behind her sisters suicide were not the Paanch exactly in the first place. It was Gauti...and what will be even more interesting is if she finds this out during the time she falls for him. These are just ideas and assumptions regarding the future tracks of the serial. What do you guys think? This is just a plain speculative idea I had.

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

3.9k

Users

9

Likes

20

Frequent Posters

shruti thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
I had been thinking the same. Though Paanch tortured her in the nae of ragging what if they were not responsible for her death but someone else was. Roshni thinks of Gauti as a friend feels guilty for using him for her motive and if he had any hand in her sister death she would shattered for trusting a wrong person. Maybe in future they might introduce such track when she starts feeling something for Gauti.

Another possibility is Rajat being involved in this incident. Probably he thought of trapping the Paanch by using Neha as his pawn but it backfired back and ended up with her falling off the roof top and dying.
..DamonCrazy.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Gauti does seem fishy to me. He's always there to save Roshni at the right time. Nothing much is known about him. We only see him through Roshni's POV, unlike the Paanch who are shown separately & haven't once mentioned Neha (though that could be building up the suspense). Also Gauti was in Neha's batch, & he failed the year Neha died!

From the way Gauri slapped Roy for drug dealing & potentially getting them all into trouble, killing Neha intentionally seems way off track. Ragging toh phir bhi chupayi jaa sakti hai, murder is riskier. Either Neha's death was suicide, or an accident as a result of Roy's drugs, or the Paanch had mentally tortured, but on that day...Gauti or someone else could be somehow responsible for her death.
shaad_luvz thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Paanch torchrd neha vry much...and ragging s wrong..illegal...
So d stry must b opposing dis actoin...I thnk gauti s cnectd wit neha past...
But he wnt...and neha nevr cmplned gauti to roshini..
She olwyz cmplaned to roshni abt paanch..bur she was not scared much...
Dnt knw her suicide reasn..
Paanch s vry dangers...even they wer goin lock roshni in cage ..
Aaa...but ; how gauti reachd der...nyway no idea...
sweetypie225 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Yeah,even i was thinking about the same!!
Drone thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: shaad_luvz

Paanch torchrd neha vry much...and ragging s wrong..illegal...
So d stry must b opposing dis actoin...I thnk gauti s cnectd wit neha past...
But he wnt...and neha nevr cmplned gauti to roshini..
She olwyz cmplaned to roshni abt paanch..bur she was not scared much...
Dnt knw her suicide reasn..
Paanch s vry dangers...even they wer goin lock roshni in cage ..
Aaa...but ; how gauti reachd der...nyway no idea...


No I don't think paanch are dangerous. There was no animal and the cage was planted to just scare her. They are not killers and I am very sure they have not killed neha. I just hope Roshni does not start killing them in the revenge spirit because right now she seems more dangerous.😲
844858 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
That's a pretty good assumption...I've been thinking on the same lines..
Though,IMO I don't see Gauti as someone who was innocent but was silent while they tortured her. I really feel he would have shown some regret or pain through his character if this had happened. [ Or maybe Gauri instigated Gauti into believing that Neha wasn't good or something and that made him immune to Neha's suicide]
Personally, I have the feeling of Gauti being the EVIL one( I don't even know why, but the idea is very intriguing to me)
Keeping all that aside, I absolutely love Gauti and Neha.
But I still feel there relationship has no depth till now, that will only come when gauti's mystery is revealed( good or bad Idk, but I'm pretty sure he had something to.do.with Neha's death)
ShagufElina thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Even i think the same...whn i was watching today ...repeat telecast...
Bt really this show is interesting...
Nabakov_Musings thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: *Shruti*

I had been thinking the same. Though Paanch tortured her in the nae of ragging what if they were not responsible for her death but someone else was. Roshni thinks of Gauti as a friend feels guilty for using him for her motive and if he had any hand in her sister death she would shattered for trusting a wrong person. Maybe in future they might introduce such track when she starts feeling something for Gauti.

Another possibility is Rajat being involved in this incident. Probably he thought of trapping the Paanch by using Neha as his pawn but it backfired back and ended up with her falling off the roof top and dying.

hm but the rajat thing seems ti simple you know? besides side character hai so i doubt he had much of a hand over nehas death , but i strongly believe that nehas death was not due to the paanchs torture but because of gautis silence or a betrayal of a sort , definitely maybee. rishni falling for gauti is a given , but the gauti neha angle being revealed right then is gonna turn her world around for sure. shell realize that her revenge on the five was kind of a waste in the first place cause the main person responsible for it was the one guy she trusted. that will be rocking if that happens. lets see.
Nabakov_Musings thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ..DamonCrazy..

Gauti does seem fishy to me. He's always there to save Roshni at the right time. Nothing much is known about him. We only see him through Roshni's POV, unlike the Paanch who are shown separately & haven't once mentioned Neha (though that could be building up the suspense). Also Gauti was in Neha's batch, & he failed the year Neha died!

From the way Gauri slapped Roy for drug dealing & potentially getting them all into trouble, killing Neha intentionally seems way off track. Ragging toh phir bhi chupayi jaa sakti hai, murder is riskier. Either Neha's death was suicide, or an accident as a result of Roy's drugs, or the Paanch had mentally tortured, but on that day...Gauti or someone else could be somehow responsible for her death.

i have strong gut feeling that the main trigger behind nehas death was gauti. its like a hunch.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".