Aisha15 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Since India Forums is a platform through which we can express our views (positive or negative) I am going to try and do so in the most pleasant way that I can. With that being said Sajid is the most ignorant, rude, and arrogant so called "judge" I have ever seen on television. I am not a fan or hater of ANY of the contestants on the show so I think I can give a pretty unbiased judgement. How on earth did Sajid see more dance in Gurmeet & Debina's performance than Bruna and Omar's? Gurbina's performance was OK--not that great that it deserved a standing ovation in between. There was nothing ground-breaking about it. The whole performance was dominated by lifts. I think there were two or three places where they actually danced, and that too with miscoordination. Clearly Sajid lives under a rock if he claims he's never seen a perfomance like that on TV before. A performance like that usually occurs in every dance reality show. Bruna and Omar's performace was beautifully choreographed. It was almost like contemporary dance under water. I'm not saying a performance like theirs never happened before (although I think that's what Terrence said), but visually it was ten fold more appealing than Gurbina's. Also way more difficult than what Gurbina did, yet Sajid didn't find any dance in it. The hit choreographer Terrence gave it an 11, but our flop director Sajid gave it a 7. Ufff I can't even put to words how much I dislike him. There is absolutely nothing constructive or humourous in anything he says. No one should ever take anything he says seriously because he is just a lost case. I really wish someone would give it back to him like Sargun did last season.

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.3k

Users

5

Likes

29

Frequent Posters

Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Bang on post! 👏 I totally agree with every word of yours dear! ⭐️
I found it very rude of him to give that proud arrogant smirk when shilpa and Terence gave bruna and Omar a standing ovation and he didn't. Cool he didn't give standing ovation but atleast that rude smirk shouldn't have been there. It just seemed like he didn't have no interest whatsoever.
I'm sorry if I'm rude or whatever here but his comments were pretty discouraging too. I mean isn't a judge supposed to tell right or wrong to help the contestant improve BUT also encourage them say good try or whatever to motivate them for next time? He was so so vague in saying it was swimming! They had difficult dance moves that too underwater and he didn't even motivate them! I just hope he gets some sense very soon as this ain't taking him nowhere. Full stop.
adigaag thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
I disagree...training in swimming a proper one at that does help somewhere...you know when exactly to breath when not to , when to do which movement...yes I'm not saying that Bruna and Omar were bad they obviously did not deserve what they got ...it was another beautiful act and yes Sajid was rude and he should have given them a 10 atleast common Sajid you can do it ...GC DB although trained cannot be considered the best in doing lifts, one mistake and it could be a question of life and death, when you do it with a professional dancer it is something entirely different just like being trained in swimming and of course I do agree even professionals have bad days... but for me GC DB performance was spellbounding still under that spell...the light effects which played a major part in the performance along with the song had a very different feel to it...Adnan has put life and soul into that song with his voice ...they did not miss a single beat once they were into their performance, and the lifts this time were absolutely smooth clear and perfect going very well with the pace of the song unlike their Jiya Jale act...transitions were perfect to the T...there were some, infact many many really wow moments in the whole performance...only when they were doing their actual dancing they lost sync at 2 places...else they were on the mark...and judges contestants and audiences all have not gone bonkers to give a standing ovation just like that...I felt it was a very very genuine and heartfelt standing ovation and I'm very very proud of the fact that I'm their fan...😃⭐️👏...My opinion entirely
Edited by adigaag - 11 years ago
harshdb thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
They must be danced in Sajid dreams that's why they got full marks. 😆

I loved the concept of dancing under water. Thumbs up for the concept.
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Yeah the concept was very unique and different! 😃
Aisha15 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
@adigaag You have every right to your own opinion. I'm not saying Gurbina's act was bad, I personally just didn't find a wow factor in it. Yeah the neck lift is difficult and could have killed her but I've seen it plenty times over in other shows so it wasn't unique in that case. I'm not saying their performance was bad, I thought it was good. But other contestants who do just as good or better do not get that same praise from Sajid.
Edited by imli123 - 11 years ago
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
I agree imli! 😊
Others who just as good don't get same praise as they get from him ... They are good but why just encourage them why not other couples who are also trying hard who are also doing amazingly well?!!!
Every sentence to compare or judge someone's dancing he includes Debina Gurmeet!! 😳 He needs to make everyone feel equal and same he can't make someone feel to the top and someone to the low it's just so unfair!!!! Gurmeet and Debina who try hard aren't getting the praise they deserve just on their own but Sajid is just making it look so bad to audience. I bet they feel so uncomfortable being included and compared to. 😳
2_addicted thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Why is Sajid a judge anyways? What experience does he have other than directing crappy movies? Why is Shilpa a judge? Does she have an extensive background in dance? Terrance is the only credible judge on this show. Effin ridic.
Aisha15 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: pinkpearl5

I agree imli!😊

Others who just as good don't get same praise as they get from him ... They are good but why just encourage them why not other couples who are also trying hard who are also doing amazingly well?!!!
Every sentence to compare or judge someone's dancing he includes Debina Gurmeet!!😳He needs to make everyone feel equal and same he can't make someone feel to the top and someone to the low it's just so unfair!!!! Gurmeet and Debina who try hard aren't getting the praise they deserve just on their own but Sajid is just making it look so bad to audience. I bet they feel so uncomfortable being included and compared to.😳



Yes exactly. His comments are doing no good for anyone. Gurmeet and Debina's hard work will be overlooked because he's biased towards them. And all the other contestants surely will feel discouraged because their hard work is never good enough for him. He just needs to go.
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: imli123



Yes exactly. His comments are doing no good for anyone. Gurmeet and Debina's hard work will be overlooked because he's biased towards them. And all the other contestants surely will feel discouraged because their hard work is never good enough for him. He just needs to go.


Yep yep yep totally agree ⭐️

Appreciating and motivating someone's effort is surely not his cup of tea. May god bless him and guide him! 🥱

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".