Rani or PeeCee? Black Vs Barfi

Page

Next Last

Poll

Which performance was better?

.ProperPatola

@.ProperPatola

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

So, I just finished watching the movie black and I think Rani did an amazing job seriously. It sort of reminded me of Jhilmil in barfi. Rani's performance overshadowed PC's for me.

Not sure whether it is appropriate to compare these two characters as one is blind and deaf and other is austistic.

Do you think it is appropriate to compare these two roles, if so, who do you think did a better job in their respective roles, rani or Pc?

Shoot

Quote

Frequent Posters

Yuvika

@Yuvika_15

Moderator

+ 10

Posted: 12 years ago

hard to compare becos both are outstanding performances... both actresses did something outside their comfort zone so credit to both.

I didn't vote for either one of them becos to me they both r winners...wish u had included a "both" option. LOL

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

tantal

@tantal

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

Both. They were both brilliant in their portrayals of broken, imperfect human beings who touch the core of our hearts.

Quote

rogerrocks

@rogerrocks

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

PC IMO..I thought Ayesha Kapur was better than Rani in Black..There is something which stops me from appreciating the movie as a whole😆 Am not sure if it was caricaturish or OTT😕 I love the climax though..But yeah, i'l go with PC😆

Quote

Yuvika

@Yuvika_15

Moderator

+ 10

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: rogerrocks
I thought Ayesha Kapur was better than Rani in Black..

she was amazing wasn't she... if she was in this poll i'd vote for her... as a child artist she did a remarkable job👏

Quote

Annie

@Star_girl

Sparkler

Posted: 12 years ago

Both, honestly.

Both of them are really good.

But I like Priyanka a bit more. ❤️

Rani's off-screen personality puts me off a bit.

I know, not fair. But still.

Quote

@DianaPrince

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

both

but i'll vote for PC

her role was a bit more difficult and better executed

@ rogerrocks yes,i also think ayesha was better!!

but rani and PC both were terrific

Quote

Cutiepie_Rani

@Cutiepie_Rani

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

It is unfair to like someone over another because of their 'off screen persona' when we are talking about the better acting of the two actresses.

In all honesty Rani's character appealed to me a lot more than Priyanka's character, which I thought didn't have a strong of a role as Rani's character. It is true that I am a fan of Rani, but while giving my vote I am not being biased at all. I did enjoy Rani's performance way more than Priyanka's but Pri did well in her role as well.

As far as Ayesha, well kudos for such a young girl to give such a power packed role. She wins hands down.

Quote

927945

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

Pc was better. I find rani overrated she os not a good actress n her voice irritates me n i dont like home wreckers though pc falls in same category but she touched my heart as jhilmill [ just my opinion ]. That kid gurl in black was better than rani in the movie