3 issues that I had with Salman in Sat's episode

vish11111 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
I know everyone has given their opinion and its become a bit redundant but I wanted to list the 3 issues that I had with Salman in the latest episode...I am not going to mention anything from the previous episodes.
In this recent episode, he pointed out the flaws in Tanisha and also asked Armaan a few questions after the caller. I am fine with that. In my opinion he should be giving very little feedback to the contestants...so what he did was enough. Tanisha/Armaan do ji hazuri and say they are sorry and Salman sir is right..so Salman cannot target them any further. Agreed.

But here are the 3 issues I had:

1. Sophia walking away when Gauhar was talking issue - OK so Gauhar talks a lot and doesn't listen to others but if she had a problem with Sophia walking away then it was absolutely justified. What if Gauhar had done that to Tanisha? Or what if Gauhar does that to Salman..and just doesn't respond to his questions? Will he be fine with that? No right? It is mannerless to walk away when someone is talking to you. So I don't understand why he cited this incident while blaming Gauhar. Any sane human being would not just agree with Salman on this and argue back..which is what Gauhar did.

2. Gauhar's "just a face" comment on Elli - how can Salman judge the intentions of someone and then claim that this is what the whole of Hindustan is thinking? How fair is that? Most people didn't even make a big deal out of that comment...and there was an uncensored video of kamya,gauhar and pratyusha discussing the "just a face" comment and they clearly mentioned that she is just a face because others (team members) are using her in the task. So it was wrong of Salman to throw this allegation at Gauhar and claiming it as what Hindustan thinks made it even worse.

3. Kushal's comment about the sorry - I have seen that interview. It was mentioned very casually. He was talking about how he has no issues at all with Salman Khan, he said that Salman also said lots of positive things about me which were not shown for some reason and he also said sorry..so no issues. I idolize him. That's pretty much how it went. The media started making headlines out of it...and Salman's ego was hurt. Salman being 20 years older than Kushal and experienced with media should have checked what was the context of the statement and he could have talked to Kushal. Also he could have made a press statement himself to clear that he didn't apologize to Kushal. If he wanted to mention it on the show then it didn't need to be in front of the contestants who have no clue whats going on outside. Why was he telling them that?

These 3 things disappointed me the most and this is why I feel he is still targeting Kushal/Gauhar. His ego has been hurt.

For those who keep saying that Gauhar argues back and thats why he gets angry..I am sorry..as a host he should be ready to hear from the contestants about what they feel..not everyone is going to just give a fake apology and say "yes sir. you are correct". He is a star but that doesn't mean that people cannot voice their opinion against him.

Ready for the feedback. I know it doesn't matter because Salman fans will bash me either ways...but just for the record..I was a Salman fan and still feel that no one can host the show better than him if he can be unbiased. But these days he is being unfair!
Edited by vish11111 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

2.8k

Users

16

Likes

144

Frequent Posters

life_8 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
your points are very well said.
_mahi_ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Great job with the post..👏 The moment you start justifying yourself everywhere - in the show, on twitter- you know that you are wrong, and you are just trying to prove yourself right even though you are wrong.
I felt like he was being pretty random on Saturday..
He brings Kushal out of nowhere..
He was dragging issues about Gauhar but he didn't have much to say about Tanisha..
"Caliber stuff doesn't suit you Tanisha"
Thats it
and for Gauhar.. it went on and on and on and on..

that proves - he was trying to confuse the audience.. so that they won't much time to process his words.. so they would end up believing him.. 😕
Ms.Shy thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
you said my words 👏
vish11111 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: _mahi_

Great job with the post..👏 The moment you start justifying yourself everywhere - in the show, on twitter- you know that you are wrong, and you are just trying to prove yourself right even though you are wrong.

I felt like he was being pretty random on Saturday..
He brings Kushal out of nowhere..
He was dragging issues about Gauhar but he didn't have much to say about Tanisha..
"Caliber stuff doesn't suit you Tanisha"
Thats it
and for Gauhar.. it went on and on and on and on..

that proves - he was trying to confuse the audience.. so that they won't much time to process his words.. so they would end up believing him.. 😕


True. The calibre line was very nasty and Tanisha has been passing such comments regularly. Low-class, keechad and whatnot.

But in my opinion, let the viewers decide on that..Salman' doesn't need to probe too much into it. But if he does do it with Gauhar then he should do it with others too!
TheBigTamasha thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
agree with u completely👍🏼 Pehle he acted as Tanisha's spokesperson only but now looking at his performance he has been promoted and hence will play spokesperson for each and everyone who have a problem with Gauhar justifying their wrong doings and coming up with his own interpretation of what Gauhar actually meant when she says falana falana things about them...no surprises here this weekend the hot topic of debate wud be "Gauhar why did u get so upset with Ellie nominating you"😆 and ooops he will do it again "Gauhar, Kamya, Prats and Ajaz...Do u guys still think that Kushal shud be brought back"🥱😆
sector thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
i'm a Salman fan, but the things you said are very very right, i do agree as well as appreciate your simple, unbiased post, i think it comes across as an excellent piece of unbiased writing. 👏
sector thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
One more thing, while on this topic, (please don't bash me guys if my words are not as well chosen as this TM did ) i have a feeling that Salman is being too mean to Gauhar.

I myself turn away my face everytime i see Gauhar or the moment she uses her loudspeaker like voice. See, the difference here is that my hating Gauhar is too small a thing to be noticed by anybody becoz i or many others like me are a nothing as compared to Gauhar. She is a star with a huge fan following. Secondly, when people like me hate her, we do it in the confines of our home. i always avoid bashing any contestant, ( except in one topic i did agree that she doesn't observe sound hygiene) but here i had to say it becoz i feel that Salman venting his hatred at Gauhar on nationa TV is being very unfair.

They all have the right to play the game as they feel. Gauhar however, is very aggressive every time she tries to answer Salman, and i am amazed to see anything feminine with so much venom inside. Gauhar's voice, mannerisms, attitude do put off people, but then Salman dear could chose to simply ignore her like he did with Sapna last year. Anyway, before my point gets lost, please do tell me people, why does Salman hate her ? i already said his hatred on national TV is unfair, so my curiosity is just the Why portion of it.



vish11111 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sector

One more thing, while on this topic, (please don't bash me guys if my words are not as well chosen as this TM did ) i have a feeling that Salman is being too mean to Gauhar.

I myself turn away my face everytime i see Gauhar or the moment she uses her loudspeaker like voice. See, the difference here is that my hating Gauhar is too small a thing to be noticed by anybody becoz i or many others like me are a nothing as compared to Gauhar. She is a star with a huge fan following. Secondly, when people like me hate her, we do it in the confines of our home. i always avoid bashing any contestant, ( except in one topic i did agree that she doesn't observe sound hygiene) but here i had to say it becoz i feel that Salman venting his hatred at Gauhar on nationa TV is being very unfair.

They all have the right to play the game as they feel. Gauhar however, is very aggressive every time she tries to answer Salman, and i am amazed to see anything feminine with so much venom inside. Gauhar's voice, mannerisms, attitude do put off people, but then Salman dear could chose to simply ignore her like he did with Sapna last year. Anyway, before my point gets lost, please do tell me people, why does Salman hate her ? i already said his hatred on national TV is unfair, so my curiosity is just the Why portion of it.




Good point. I can understand that some people cannot stand Gauhar's loud nature but the reason I personally like it because at least she says something! I mean its much better than just keeping quiet or not voicing your opinion. But yes she should get a little less argumentative and control herself a bit..

As for the WHY part of it. I think it started with the Kushal-Tanisha incident. When Salman was lashing out at Kushal and Gauhar...Gauhar was not agreeing and said "Not fair". That didn't go down well with Salman because he was expecting Kushal and Gauhar to admit that they were wrong and that they did bad with Tanisha. And then since that day Gauhar and Kushal fans have been after him on Twitter and are bashing him a lot. He is definitely getting effected and that is why he is defending himself on Twitter. So its all getting too much for Salman to handle - Gauhar screaming back at him, Gauhar's fans on Twitter, accusations of being biased..he is just confused at the moment..

How I would love it if Salman himself gets Kushal back next weekend, says he is sorry if people were hurt and starts afresh. Maybe thats asking for too much. Hopefully he just makes the episodes fun and doesn't interfere too much into who the contestants are playing.

btw thanks for your positive feedback :)
Guguminti thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Good point And atleast I can say the first point was truely 100% right because walking away when someone is talking is not his/her wish it's just mannerless. If she didn't wish she should have said Gauhar that I don't want this topic now may be later that would have been fine

When Imam once said to Salman I don't want to answer to this que because the que was about a contestant whom Imam hated he said him just go away and don't sit here which imam followed Y didn't he think that it was his choice anyway

And About girl's respect Read this got from an article
Sunny - "Salman is giving undue favour to Tanisha. I've personally felt that Gauhar's confidence and guts along with her ability to stand firm on any situation is somehow not digested by Tanisha and this is the reason Salman is after Kushal and Gauhar. There have been situations earlier also where such small violence acts have been. Even women are disrespected far badly than this season. But none of the instances show Salman slamming anybody. Why this time ??? Salman...please...you have a lot of fan followings...don't tarnish your image by this damn show...be neutral as you were in other seasons and you will be loved again"

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".