The real Mariam-uz-zamani

myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
The real Mariam-uz-zamani Hira Kunwari did not have a great life as decipted in the serial or movie Jodha Akbar.
During Akbar's time, Rajputs did not consider Mughals as equal to them. Raja Bharamal whose kingdom was being threatened to be annexed by Adham Khan, the general of Akbar and his foster brother thought of a last ditch effort to save his kingdom and family. He decided to offer his daughter Hira Knwari's hand in marriage to emperor Akbar. Hira Kunwari and her mother was dead against this wedding as they knew that she will become an outcast among Rajputs and her own family after marriage.
Hira Kunwari very well knew the implications of being forced to marry an muslim ruler. Hence although she converted to Islam after marriage to Akbar still she retained her hindu rajput customs of worshipping and customs. The rajput princess who married muslim ruler were treated their daughters as an outcast. The rajputs would not dine with their daughters who had convverted. Hira Bai who married Akbar was treated as an outcast in Rajputhana and she never visited her family home Amer in 61 years after her marriage. Here there is a discrepancy saying that she had visited Amer once with Salim and there was an uproar both in Amer and Agra fort. The mughal court ulema opposed her visiting Amer with Prince Salim and in Amer they shunned her and treated her with contempt as she was a muslim now not allowing her to dine with her family. Akbar after knowing this decided never to send Hira Kunwari and Salim to Amer again.
At Agra, Hamida Banu and aunt Gulbadan opposed Akbar's marriage to a hindu princess as they were close to Ruqaiah and Salima. Hence although Akbar sent messengers to get them to attend his wedding none of his family mother, aunt, sister and wives attended the wedding. Akbar went ahead with marriage for political reason but had to face opposition within his family. Its only much later that his family was reconciled to the fact and tolerated Hira Kunwari(once she gave birth to an heir). Because she was an Hindu she had no significant role in Agra court or Delhi although she would handle the ship trades that took pilgrims to holy land and sold spieces to other countries. But otherwise Hira Kunwari had no great standing in Mughal court.
Her only supporter was her husband Akbar and her son Jehangir. Jehangir who had seen his mother being treated like outcast in Rajputs and also not given importance at Mughal court was very upset but could not do much given the circumstances. Akbar also tried to pacify the Rajputs by giving them key posts like for Man Singh and Bhagwan Das but still Hira Kunwari was treated indifferently by her Rajput family members. Man Singh was the adopted son of Bhagwan Das. Hira tried to placate her family by marrying her neice's to her son Salim but this outcast treatment lasted for a few more generations by Rajput families of their daughters who married muslim rulers. In order to placate them both Akbar and Jehangir allowed their wives and mothers to worship hindu Gods inside agra fort and also allowed diwali, holi and rakhi to be celebrated in the fort. There are also instances of both Akbar and Jehangir visiting temples. But none of this made the Mughals more acceptable to their rajput relatives except some exceptions.
The law of succession in Rajputs was patramonial hence they readily agreed to give away their daughters Rajput princess in marriage to Mughals for political survival and benefits. But the mughal relatives were never invited for any special ocassions of their relatives. Also they refused to take muslim wives as they wanted their family line to be Rajputs only. When mota Raja udai singh of Jodhpur decided to marry Jagat Gosain aka Jodha Bai to Jehangir the Rajput Rathore Kalyan Das threatened to kill both of them and Akbar had to send imperial foces to attack siwana to save them.
Rajput ladies who married Mughals became muslims and were buried in muslim cemeteries and they could no longer visit their families and even dine with them. It is confirmed that if/when Hira's family visited Agar fort(rarely) they would not dine with Akbar and his family or ministers.
Hiira wanted to be buried with Akbar but again there was oppositions. So she decided her resting place and Jehangir built her tomb very near to his father Akbar. Jehangir who wanted her memory to remain forever and give her a tribute built the Mariam-uz-zamani mosque so that his mother is remember long enough.
This is taken from an article(research scholar) from a university
Edited by myviewprem - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

37

Views

61.3k

Users

29

Likes

140

Frequent Posters

stuti123 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
thank God they arent following the real history😉 fully
Edited by stuti123 - 11 years ago
ILTHBEB thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Different sources give controversial information abt MUZ. Don't know which one should believe!
Newdime thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Very insightful. Just passing by and saw this article and continued to read. Didn't know we have this show going on.
mehaksingh thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: stuti123

thank God they arent following the real history😉 fully



History_geek i think has given in detail a post after a thorough research through 50 to 60 books
AbHer_neha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Actually, there is no unanimity on Mughals history...different historians have different views on the relationship of Jodha & Akbar...there are few articles who say Jodha had an influence on Akbar & she used to occupy a very influencial position in the Mughal court...and also Jahangir din give much importance to her mother...rather he was more close to Ruq & Salima...sach me kya hua pata nahi...par jitna bhi search kiya usse ek baat toh confirmed hai that Jodha was an important part of Akbar's life...😳...TFS...😃
Edited by AbHer_neha - 11 years ago
Rutuja... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: stuti123

thank God they arent following the real history😉 fully



seriously thank god😳
Mallika-E-Bhais thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
God knows which is true & which is not!!!
But this much is confirmed-They definitely left an impact. 😳
jalludewani thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
History is a mistry... I don;t know why we assume that real never lived happy life with akbar... No doubt she have to struggle to survive but she succecceded for sure if the rajput womens are treated that & rejected by there families then real jodha never get her brother daughter married to her son...what we read is the one side of picture we don:t know what happen behind the walls ... Jodha surely have a place in akbar heart most of akbar childs are from her & she with hameeda begum involve in the mughal buisness too shows hameeda share a good relationship with jodha..there is definetly something special in jodha akbar relationship
mehaksingh thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: jalludewani

History is a mistry... I don;t know why we assume that real never lived happy life with akbar... No doubt she have to struggle to survive but she succecceded for sure if the rajput womens are treated that & rejected by there families then real jodha never get her brother daughter married to her son...what we read is the one side of picture we don:t know what happen behind the walls ... Jodha surely have a place in akbar heart most of akbar childs are from her & she with hameeda begum involve in the mughal buisness too shows hameeda share a good relationship with jodha..there is definetly something special in jodha akbar relationship



i appreciate your view point and agree with it. we can enjoy the show if we can look at the things with a positive attitude i feel. jahangir or others they didn't mention much of rajput mother because he is a cross breed. that historians influenced by mughals might have not mentioned or over centuries they might have rewritten or changed to an extent the versions.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".