anandi a misfit in shekhars family? - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

79

Views

7.1k

Users

28

Likes

403

Frequent Posters

642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves



No 2 persons can be similar. If Jagya has some defects, he also has some positive points.
Saving women in distress and expecting nothing from them.



He got engaged or married to women he saved. He may not have expectations but this always ends up happening!😆

He expects nothing, he just gives of himself.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: redapple1

Yes leaves. All the characters have positive and negative points. I just tried to bring the contrast between two heros. One is on one extreme for being there for his sis (even though she is wrong) and the other on the other extreme forgetting about her existence. 😃



I think for some time Shiv had also forgotten he had a sister, which is why she is taking revenge and he is also serving her cause to make up for ignoring her earlier!🤣

Main uska bhai tha aur main kuch nahin kar saka? Mera pappu ban gaya? Revenge! Court case!🤪
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: Picasso9


Sorry, but this is how I see it.


Similar to Anandi, Ganga is of a rural background, also suppressed, actually abused and tortured even more. So it is quite easy to make an educated guess that to a girl like Ganga, having congenial relationship with in laws especially mother in law is also top most desire. How can you say she is attached to only one person. Jagya comes with a whole extended family. A family that she received shelter from. Obviously she has attachment to that family as well. Actually her attachment COULD be to the point of worship because she never had a family like that. Sumitra treated her worse than Ira ever treated Anandi (calling her baasi Phool, abshagun). Doesn't those abuses point to her tortuous past of being raped over and over again.

Anandi is not completely alone, like Ganga has certain members supporting her, so too, Anandi has CM supporting her and Alok speaking for her and Daddu sometimes hushing Ira like DS does Sumi.

Anandi is appeasing them by being silent to all the abuse. Just looking on with tearfilled eyes. Standing with trays, serving them, telling them they are not wrong in how they are feeling. Telling them she understands why they are feeling the way they do, but leaving things incomplete. She is appeasing them by not giving her decision of yay or nay for support but buying time. What's the use of springing it on them in the court?



Don't bring her tortured past in this. A person who has been tortured so badly will not enter into romantic relationship so soon nor trust people easily, especially of opposite sex. Ganga moved on pretty quickly.

So okay, I accept she is really strong. Compared to likes of Anandi, Phooli, Sugna, Gehna, Asha, Gauri even - who took long to get over their past or whose trauma got the better of them.

She has foremost desire of acceptance from MIL? That will be fulfilled. She is not going against her. Rather defending her son.

This is a chance for her to prove her worth to Singhs and of course, to save her husband.

She has absolutely nothing to lose in her decisions or actions in this case.

So she is more assured.

In case of Anandi, she mostly waited for them or tried to convince them to change their decision. And she is under intense pressure because her husband is not with her as of now.

It is about who a woman has to live with - that makes her assured or unsure. In case of Ganga, even if Sumitra detests her, still her husband is with her (I mean support). Her Bapusa is with her. In Anandi's case, the ones who she has to live with, are not with her except CM who cries with her or gives her shoulder to lean on. Alok has spoken to Ira in Anandi's absence. Anandi does not know if anyone is with her except CM.

Anandi has obligations to both families and something to lose no matter what. So she is unsure.

What appeasement? Ganga also tolerates abuse of Sumitra silently! And if she were at their home, she too would be doing some housework around as she now does at Lal Singh's house!
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: Sheetsden

I just want to ask how do you know mahi and ashima had one night stand ?
I am not talking about anandi here. What's wrong in ashima and mahi doing whatever they want with their each other consent ? It's not they r forcing on each other. There is no need to tell it to family.
It makes sense only if they tell it to their future life partners about the incident as its good to tell past affairs. There is no characterless in it. They r not married or engaged to other people to call them characterless.



Come on! They were holding each other. Look at the BGM, camera and ultimately the picture they focused on and later how Ashima was angry and guilty.

ONS is like this only in Hindi serials. 😆

Okay, sleeping around before marriage is not characterlessness. According to you.

You are against Anandi feeling for her maika but find nothing wrong in ONS and still want to give benefit of doubt?

Shiv bhakti is okay. Is Mahi bhakti a part of Shiv bhakti too? (No offense)
divine_ram thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: Skepblun



Come on! They were holding each other. Look at the BGM, camera and ultimately the picture they focused on and later how Ashima was angry and guilty.

ONS is like this only in Hindi serials. 😆

Okay, sleeping around before marriage is not characterlessness. According to you.

You are against Anandi feeling for her maika but find nothing wrong in ONS and still want to give benefit of doubt?

Shiv bhakti is okay. Is Mahi bhakti a part of Shiv bhakti too? (No offense)

They both are adults and not engaged to anyone in their life. They are not cheating anyone. They might have give in to their feelings and its very personal. They both will face the consequences and ashima who is shiv's age is sensible enough to decide if pregnant would want to raise the child alone or contact the father of the child. They are not spoiling the life of anyone in this situation. According to me I don't even mind live in relationship before marriage. It's upto to the adults what they want in their life provided they are not cheating each other and honest in their relationship.
I don't mind anandi feeling for maayka but involving in jagya life due to DS is not a good idea.
I really don't like mahi ashima story but I was talking about their so called ONS.
I live in US and studied here so seen lot of students have live in relationship before marriage or one night stand. They are sensible to deal with the situations are move on in their life either way.
I respect people who have live in relationship and if that does not work find partners who understand ther past affair and accept them wholeheartedly. They atleast honest to accept their past relationships with the future partner. I call characterless people when they hide their past ONS/live in relationships with future partners if the past relationship breaks off.
leavesandwaves thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: Skepblun



Come on! They were holding each other. Look at the BGM, camera and ultimately the picture they focused on and later how Ashima was angry and guilty.

ONS is like this only in Hindi serials. 😆

Okay, sleeping around before marriage is not characterlessness. According to you.

You are against Anandi feeling for her maika but find nothing wrong in ONS and still want to give benefit of doubt?

Shiv bhakti is okay. Is Mahi bhakti a part of Shiv bhakti too? (No offense)



😆
vasiraju thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#77
leaves can i join the discussion ...are do you think i am misfit to discuss here 😊
divine_ram thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#78
Where did shiv Bhakti and mahi Bhakti come from ? I was discussing on mahi ashima ONS and how I don't find it characterless. When you people are not broad minded to talk about those you bounce on being fans of the characters 😲
vasiraju thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#79
i was just thinking from few days ..
whom do we prefer most ...

A person who believes whatever he does is right ..even getting married to his Fav girl even going against his family ...and thinks one day his Family will forgive him and accepts him and his wife ..though they are not happy for time being ...once they accept because their love for his ..thought they may taught the girl...did the boy will ever think about it 😕...

A person who love his family as equal as he loves his girl and marries going against all odds ..making his family accept for the match ..and marries her with full pride and happiness ..when the time comes ..to choose between his family and wife ..that he chooses his family and expects his wife to support him ..though she is suffering from the decisions taken by his family and by him ...
Edited by vasiraju - 12 years ago
vasiraju thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: Skepblun



Come on! They were holding each other. Look at the BGM, camera and ultimately the picture they focused on and later how Ashima was angry and guilty.

ONS is like this only in Hindi serials. 😆

Okay, sleeping around before marriage is not characterlessness. According to you.

You are against Anandi feeling for her maika but find nothing wrong in ONS and still want to give benefit of doubt?

Shiv bhakti is okay. Is Mahi bhakti a part of Shiv bhakti too? (No offense)



@Skep ...

i was really surprised to see so much of discussion on Mahi and Ashima ..

For a girl who born and brought in India ..may be have some obligations to sleep with a boy before marriage means a Characterless called by society ..

But a girl like Ashima who was born and brought up in the countries like UK ..where Girls learn about physical relationship from the childhood ...even in the schools they teach the protection measures ..and they are said that those feelings biological and can happen to anyone at anytime ...its just a hormone process ...

i don't think from Ashima's POV its a big issue ..yeah you may ask that why she felt angry and guilty ..i think she was angry and guilty ..to the person whom she give in 😆..he is the brother of the person whom she feels and tells everyone how much she loved shiv ..

and even Mahi knows that she internally thinks about his brother ..so may felt that she don't have that will power to hold herself what she feels for ..she just give in to her Physical body needs ..and didn't do justification for the love which she thinks is pure and untouchable by any other person .


Edited by vasiraju - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".