Judges' comments and elimination

Leaving aside the viewer's votes as I do not know how many actually come and make a difference, does anyone else feel the judges give hints as to who will be out in the coming weeks? After all they do have 50% say in the elimination

I remember hearing negatives about Sankalp, Emon, Priyam and Akash in the weeks before they were finally evicted. Today the focus shifted to Sugandha and more than that, on Anjana. Due to this I have a feeling one of these two will leave next week, most likely Anjana.

Did anyone else get that feeling?

This is pretty common in reality shows...sort of channel trying to justify upcoming elimination

^Yeah, it is pretty common to give the indication. It is just that the timing sucks. Suddenly a judge comes up with 'I want to give you this constructive feedback'.

yup its true..bt i will miss priyam. n anjana deserve to b at top5

Yes you are right. How come judges praise someone and give standing ovation in one week and eliminate the contestant in another week. I dont think viewer's votes matter at all. It's all judges decision and more over channel's. They have already decided who will win.

I am not sure if anyone noticed - yesterday when Nirvesh was on the red sofa. He looked and vishal and vishal kinda of gave him an assurance and Nirvesh nodded.

Originally posted by: Roark

I am not sure if anyone noticed - yesterday when Nirvesh was on the red sofa. He looked and vishal and vishal kinda of gave him an assurance and Nirvesh nodded.

So are these children being evicted on Judge's choice?

Yes, that signal to Nirvesh was obvious. I think judges know the results beforehand

Also, it could have been editing but Anjana's mother has never looked so tense before and even after Anjana was saved, she still looked unhappy. There must be more khichdi being pakaoed behind the scenes

I don't mind if the decision is based more on judges' marks but feel they should give (and we be shown) both the positives and negatives of each singer.

I too noticed it when Vishal shekhar gave an assurance nod to nirvesh when he was on red sofa. Similar nod was given to priyam when she was in bottom three with aakash and anmol.

I feel we are looking too much between the lines here and comparing this show with every other reality show.