Can love happen twice??? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

1.4k

Users

10

Likes

28

Frequent Posters

Priyasi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: anonee

Priyasi - you have raised a very good quesiton.

Love between two is essential but so is a sustainable emotional and behavioral compatability between the two individuals.
Prashant's and Aarti sustainability/compatability factor was low and it was eventually followed by Prashant walking away.
We never got to see Arpita and Yash's compatability/sustainability factor as Arpita died young. All the flashbacks were romantic in nature so we never got to see them in routine day-to-day interactions. I suspect there was some issue over there because there were no pictures of Arpita and Arpita-Yash with the kids.


Thanks... But this is a topic which has been bothering me for a long time since the day I read those comments in one of the posts in a forum... It bothered me since I strongly believe in love and also that love CAN happens twice...
Priyasi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: mostar

I strongly believe that love can happen twice. It happen to me, I experienced love twice, you don't forget your first love, but you can love equally strong second time.


I am really happy for you... This is what I was talking about... Love can happen twice and both time it can be equally strong and serene
Priyasi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: poonamgarg

Priya tumne jo kuch bhi kaha hai totally agree wid you n after watching PVZMD no doubt ki love dobara bhi ho sakta hai😃


Thanks Poonam... I am so glad that uptill now, no one has disagreed with the statement that love can happen twice... This is the maturity of PVians and this kind of topic could only be discussed here without hurting anyone
Priyasi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: palbhar

You can fall in love again but first love will never be forgotten!!! In Yash 's case, he was lucky Arpita was a wonderful human being...falling in love with Aarti doesn't mean he has forgotten Arpita, he has just moved on.

Aarti will never forget Prashant as he was her first love and he gave her Ansh...however the ugliness between them will make her want to move on with Yash and can you blame her!!!


I am so happy that most of us believe the same... So true, you can fall in love again but at the same time first love never leaves your heart. It is, the second phase of love create different place for itself without forgetting the first love...
Priyasi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: villager00

Hi Priya, very nice post/thought!

This is why i am still haunted by the show's abrupt ending.. so many things to delve upon regarding the different characters. I believe that Yash loved Arpita in that 'young love, sweet love' line, same is through with Aarti's feeling for Prashant. That carefree

Philosophers say we get to experience three stages of love in our life, puppy love, first love and true love. I might fit Yash and Aarti's earlier experiences to the category of first love, that most basic dictation of the mind saying 'I want you and i want you to want me too'. And rightly so, they played it as it is. Unfortunately, fate have other plans for them in the form of different disasters.

Their second venture i'd say is true love, where sense and sensibility came first before the push of wanting and needing someone. It was gradual but full-knowing. Of course, there's the possibility of that first love becoming true love, only we were shown different in the show. In real life, yeah, i believe it is possible for love to happen twice without marring the first love.

In the second PV, that of SP-Radha, i remember feeling frustrated that they were being married off and we the audience did not get to know what they were thinking or feeling. I wanted to know the elders take on it so much... *sigh*


@ bold, I too believe in this. But never read this anywhere. I heard this my friend was sharing her experience... Though she ignored the puppy love part since she never had one but she stressed upon the other two facets of love through her personal experiences. Since I never exprience love in my life, I simply believed her because I know experience is the best teacher and what she said was not from from the book of her life... But when I read those comments, they confused me and after thinking about this I planned to make a post to get some answers. And now I am so happy that I posted...

Coming back to Yash and Aarti... Though Yash moved on with Aarti Yet Arpita will always be in his heart in a good way and though Aarti now lietrally worships her Yashji still her first love will always stay in her heart but in a bitter way...

And I so agree with you that I too wanted the CVs to show some of the confusion or emotions of SP and Radha before their PV but sadly it was never shown... All thanks to channel's interference...

Priyasi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: jasraj123

very sensitive topic

but i think it can
as I have seen many people settled in their life again after not successful first time
and of course yash and aarti example we have too


I know Di, LOVE is sensitive, right?

Yes, Yash and Aarti's example is the best for this...

I am glad you always comment... Thanks Di
Priyasi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: IsYaRoCHeR

For me, I totally believed that love can happen twice...


I don't know what to say..

But I always believe in this sentence (strongly)..

If you love something, let it go. If it comes back to you, its yours forever. If it doesn't, then it was never meant to be.


If you observe this sentence properly, I think you'll get your answer..

But if it never meant to be for you, then believe me, a second one is waiting for you ! 😊

You can try relate it with Yash-Aarti story too ! I won't tell you much as I'm still very young and for me, Love is very complicated.. 😆

I hope you'll find some good answers from our other experienced friends.. 😳 But think about the quotes I have posted, that particular quote had helped me and many others to get over our first failed love and move on till we'll meet another love ! 😉

Anyway, Punar Vivah-Zindagi Milegi Dobara serial itself has given us an answer through Yash-Aarti relation! 😃


@bold... I too in this Isya and if I am not mistaken something like this was said in the movie Ishq Vishq wherein Amrita Rao says, "Agar tumhara pyaar jana chahe to use jane do, agar wo lautkar aaye to woh tumhara hai...' this was one my fav dialogues from the movie and so I remembered it so clearly...
I have indeed founf some spectacular answers and most all them are positive about this thought and I am so glad about it Isya...

If life gives you a second chance it definitely doesnt mean to forget the past and move on, but it simply means to make some space for the new memories without letting go of the past memories of your first love... First love - however good or bad it was - always remains special - in good or bitter way...
Priyasi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: angake

Priyasi,


This was the crux of our show. That you can fall in love twice and that when you fall in love again that doesn't mean you have to completely forget or erase the memories of your first love. They can coexist. Love has so many facets and so many different meanings. I think Yash loved different things about Arpita and Aarti because both the women were very different in the way they dealt with life. He probably admired and respected different things about Arpita and Aarti. Falling in love does not mean there is only one set defined way to fall in love. Similarly the reasons for which Aarti fell in love with Prashant and why she fell in love with Yash were entirely different based on circumstances as well as her maturity and what she wanted from life at that point.


Prashant did wrong by Aarti but I can never say Aarti's love for him was fake. I completely disagree with this argument that Yash and Aarti's love was the true love and not their first loves. I do believe Yash and Aarti were soul mates (that is if you believe in the existence of soul mates) but their first love with Arpita and Prashant respectively was just as much real and true as their love for each other was. One of my favorite Yash-Aarti interactions of the show was during the Diwali episodes. Prashant instigates Yash by saying that Aarti will never be happy that he still loves Arpita. Yash then confronts Aarti about it and asks her if it is necessary that he will have to erase Arpita's memories to make place for new memories. And Aarti retorts angrily saying that she has never ever asked that of him and no outsider should dictate how their relationship should be. That to me defined Yash and Aarti's relationship that they loved each other immensely, they were soul mates but they didn't have to trivialize their first relationships to prove that their relationship was the true one. I think the creatives showed this message beautifully with Arpita-Yash-Aarti triangle. But alas, before they could do it for Prashant-Aarti-Yash triangle, the channel interfered and that story was cut short.


I thought the BMT track was very important. I know a lot of viewers were pissed at Aarti for interacting with Prashant during the BMT track. But I loved it because I thought Aarti was going through two monumental realizations with regards to her relationship with Prashant as well as Yash.


Realization 1: She for the longest time was holding herself responsible for hers and Prashant's break up and she was finally seeing that she was not the only one at fault. I especially remember the scene where she takes Ansh for a transfusion and Prashant then drives her home and their car gets stuck and she has this conversation with Prashant about love and Nida and such. During that time she tells Prashant how he never valued relationships. It was so beautiful because I could see an evolution in Aarti's thought process. She always thought that Prashant did his parents a disservice as well as Ansh but for their relationship breaking up I think she took most of the blame. But I think during the BMT track was when she came to the full realization that she needn't put all the blame on herself for her disastrous relationship with Prashant. Because by then she had come to realize how beautiful a person Yash was and how he valued relationships like she did and if her relationship with Prashant broke up, she wasn't solely responsible for it and Prashant was equally or in my opinion more so to be blamed than her.


Realization 2: I think she also felt that she had to hate Prashant to completely fall in love with Yash and I think she would have eventually figured out that her feelings for Prashant who is the biological father of her son and her feelings for Yash who is the man she has given herself to physically and emotionally as well as the man who is the real father of her son in every way that matters, can coexist. She didn't have to deny Prashant his child to prove the fact that Yash was Ansh's father now or that it was Yash who she loved now. I think that was where the track was eventually leading to.



But so sad that the audience could only see Aarti lying to Yash during the BMT track. Yes, on a superficial level that is what was happening but on a deeper level there was so much more happening. The audience couldn't pick up on the subtler emotions and realizations that the CVs were making their female protagonist go through. No, I am not blaming the general TRP audience at all but just the realization that this show was certainly ahead of its times and maybe one of the reasons why the TRP audience- who seems to like everything explicitly spelled out to them- couldn't accept that track. 😭


Fantastic post, Priyasi. 👏



To be very frank to you, I was one of those who blamed Aarti for her MISTRUST on Yash. I was never against in her meeting Prashant or hepling him but I was irritated that she did not trust Yash enough to confine with him her problems and suffering... But now as I see through with this completely new light, I see how beautifully the writers had weaved this story which was very brutally killed by the channel and I HATE them for this...

TRP audience would have accepted the ORIGINAL story with progress in story... Its just that when something new comes up, people take time to digest the new concept and eventually when they do, they cant stay away from it... But sadly the channel was not ready to give the audience that needed time... When the TRPs came after six months and there was sudden drop in PV TRP, the channel certainly interfered and there the downfall of PV started. Had it been in flow with the original concept, I think the audience would have accepted it the way they accept other shows... Change is the need of the hour and PV dared to take the initiative...

@bold, I just loved this explanation of yours... yes, first love and second love can COEXIST. And my belief is getting more stronger than (well, I always believed it but when someone reassures, it makes you feel happy - read this in an FF and think this line so much suits here)

And thanks for commenting and putting forward your view... It certainly helped me a lot... Thanks again...
IsYaRoCHeR thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Priyasi


@bold... I too in this Isya and if I am not mistaken something like this was said in the movie Ishq Vishq wherein Amrita Rao says, "Agar tumhara pyaar jana chahe to use jane do, agar wo lautkar aaye to woh tumhara hai...' this was one my fav dialogues from the movie and so I remembered it so clearly...
I have indeed founf some spectacular answers and most all them are positive about this thought and I am so glad about it Isya...

If life gives you a second chance it definitely doesnt mean to forget the past and move on, but it simply means to make some space for the new memories without letting go of the past memories of your first love... First love - however good or bad it was - always remains special - in good or bitter way...


OMG ! You watched Ishk Vishq ! ? That's my fav movie and my fav couple is in that movie as well ! 😆😳 And yeah.. That's my favorite line ! I strongly believes in that line because it's very true in my opinion ! 😃

And agree with your second paragraph ! 😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".